Cancelling Cancel Culture
The Lost Art of Thinking for Ourselves
Why disagreement shouldn’t mean destruction, and why it’s time we stopped allowing the loudest voices to do our thinking for us.
There was a time when disagreeing with somebody was simply part of being human. We could have different opinions, different beliefs, different interpretations of the same situation, and somehow still manage to coexist. We could argue over a cup of tea, roll our eyes at one another, agree to disagree, and carry on with our lives.
Somewhere along the way, however, disagreement became something far more sinister. We stopped challenging opinions and started attacking the people who held them. We stopped asking questions and started demanding consequences. We stopped thinking for ourselves and began looking around to see what everybody else thought before deciding what we were supposed to believe.
Welcome to cancel culture, where the court of public opinion is permanently in session, the jury consists of complete strangers, and the sentence is often delivered before anybody has bothered to examine the evidence.
I think it’s time we cancelled cancel culture.
Not because people shouldn’t be held accountable for their actions. They absolutely should. Not because harmful behaviour deserves to be ignored, or because freedom of speech means freedom from consequences. It doesn’t.
But because there is an enormous difference between accountability and public humiliation, and somewhere along the way we seem to have forgotten where that line is.
The Problem with the Digital Mob
Social media has given us something extraordinary: the ability to communicate with people across the world, share experiences, challenge injustice and amplify voices that might otherwise go unheard.
Unfortunately, it has also given us the ability to destroy somebody’s reputation without ever having met them, spoken to them or understood the circumstances surrounding whatever they’ve supposedly done wrong.
A screenshot appears. Somebody makes an accusation. A video circulates without context. A controversial opinion is shared.
Within minutes, the comments begin.
People demand apologies. They call for resignations. They encourage boycotts. They announce that they will never support this person, organisation or business again.
Then comes the really worrying part.
Other people join in, not necessarily because they understand what has happened, but because they can see which side everybody else is taking.
Nobody wants to be the person defending somebody who has already been declared guilty by the internet. Nobody wants to risk becoming the next target simply for asking whether there might be another side to the story.
So they join the crowd.
They share the post. They repeat the accusations. They add their own outrage.
Before long, an opinion has become an accepted truth, not because it has been examined, but because enough people have repeated it.
That isn’t independent thinking.
That’s mob mentality with a Wi-Fi connection.
When Did Asking Questions Become Defending Bad Behaviour?
One of the things that concerns me most about cancel culture is how quickly curiosity gets mistaken for complicity.
If somebody is accused of doing something wrong and I ask for evidence, that doesn’t mean I’m defending them.
If I suggest that a situation might be more complicated than a thirty-second video makes it appear, that doesn’t mean I approve of what happened.
If I disagree with the punishment somebody is facing, that doesn’t mean I agree with their actions.
It means I’m thinking.
There is a worrying tendency to divide the world into two categories: those who agree with us and those who are against us.
But life isn’t that simple.
People are complicated. Situations are complicated. Intentions, misunderstandings, cultural differences, historical context and personal experiences all contribute to how we interpret the world.
We should be able to acknowledge that somebody has behaved badly without deciding that every aspect of their character is irredeemable.
We should be able to challenge somebody’s opinion without demanding that they lose their livelihood.
We should be able to say, “I don’t agree with what you said,” without immediately following it with, “Therefore, you deserve to be publicly destroyed.”
Most importantly, we should be allowed to ask questions.
Because the moment people become frightened to question the popular opinion is the moment independent thought begins to disappear.
The Difference Between Accountability and Cancellation
I want to make something very clear.
There are people who do terrible things. There are organisations that behave irresponsibly. There are public figures who use their influence to spread harmful ideas, and there are situations where public pressure is necessary to achieve justice.
Accountability matters.
Sometimes boycotts are justified. Sometimes people should lose positions of authority. Sometimes public criticism is the only way to make powerful individuals listen.
But accountability should have a purpose.
It should seek acknowledgement, responsibility, meaningful consequences and, where possible, change.
Cancellation, at its worst, seems to seek something else entirely: punishment without an endpoint.
An apology is dismissed as insincere. An explanation is treated as an excuse. Evidence of personal growth is ignored because somebody has already been assigned the role of villain.
We tell people to educate themselves, then ridicule them when they admit they didn’t know something.
We demand that people learn from their mistakes, then refuse to allow them to demonstrate that they’ve learned.
What exactly are we hoping to achieve?
If the objective is to make society better, surely we need to create opportunities for people to become better.
Otherwise, we’re not encouraging growth.
We’re simply encouraging people to become better at hiding their mistakes.
The Lost Art of Forming an Opinion
Perhaps the most important thing we can do to challenge cancel culture is surprisingly simple.
We can start thinking for ourselves again.
That means reading beyond the headline. Looking for the original source. Considering whether information has been edited, exaggerated or removed from its context.
It means listening to more than one perspective, even when doing so makes us uncomfortable.
It means recognising that a thousand people repeating the same statement doesn’t automatically make that statement true.
It means being willing to say, “I haven’t seen enough information to form an opinion yet.”
Imagine that.
Not having an immediate opinion.
In a world where everybody seems expected to comment on everything, choosing not to take a position until we’ve understood the situation can feel almost revolutionary.
But we don’t owe the internet an instant reaction.
We don’t have to join every argument.
We don’t have to condemn somebody simply because our friends have condemned them.
Equally, we don’t have to defend somebody simply because we like them.
Our opinions should belong to us.
They should be shaped by evidence, experience, empathy and critical thinking, rather than whichever social media post happens to be attracting the most attention.
There is nothing wrong with changing your mind, either.
In fact, I would argue that being willing to change your opinion when presented with new information is one of the strongest indicators that you’re actually thinking independently.
Stubbornness isn’t intelligence.
Neither is agreement.
What Are We Teaching the Next Generation?
As somebody who works with children and young people, this is the part that troubles me most.
We spend years encouraging young people to develop confidence, creativity, communication skills and independent thought.
We tell them that their voices matter. We encourage them to ask questions, challenge ideas and develop their own understanding of the world.
Then they open social media and discover an environment where expressing the wrong opinion can result in ridicule, exclusion or public humiliation.
What kind of message does that send?
How can we expect young people to become confident, independent adults if we demonstrate that the safest way to survive socially is to agree with everybody else?
In drama, I actively encourage young people to make their own creative choices.
I don’t want a room full of children who simply repeat my interpretation of a character. I want them to explore possibilities, challenge my suggestions, explain their decisions and discover what they believe works.
Sometimes they make choices I wouldn’t have made.
That’s wonderful.
Because the objective isn’t to create miniature versions of myself. It’s to help them develop the confidence to become themselves.
Surely we should be approaching their opinions in much the same way?
We should teach young people how to evaluate information, recognise manipulation, question sources and respectfully challenge ideas.
We should also teach them that disagreement doesn’t automatically make somebody an enemy.
Being able to sit in a room with somebody whose beliefs differ from your own, listen respectfully and explain your perspective without resorting to personal attacks is an essential life skill.
It shouldn’t be a rare one.
The Courage to Stand Apart
There is something incredibly powerful about being able to stand apart from a crowd.
Not because you want to be difficult. Not because you enjoy being controversial. Not because you believe everybody else is wrong.
But because you’ve taken the time to reach your own conclusion.
Sometimes your opinion will align with the majority.
Sometimes it won’t.
Sometimes you’ll discover that the crowd was right all along.
Sometimes you’ll realise that the loudest voices were missing something important.
The point is that you reached your conclusion through thought rather than pressure.
We also need to stop confusing popularity with morality.
A widely shared opinion isn’t automatically a good one. An unpopular opinion isn’t automatically a courageous one.
What matters is the reasoning behind it.
There is no virtue in blindly following the crowd, but there is equally no virtue in disagreeing simply for the sake of being different.
Independent thinking requires more effort than either.
It requires us to examine our own biases, acknowledge uncomfortable facts and accept that people we admire can be wrong.
It also requires us to recognise that people we dislike can sometimes be right.
That might be one of the hardest lessons of all.
We Are More Than Our Worst Moments
I often wonder how many of us would survive the scrutiny we so readily apply to others.
How many of us have said something thoughtless?
How many have misunderstood a situation, reacted emotionally, made an inappropriate joke or held an opinion we no longer agree with?
How many of us can honestly say that every word we’ve spoken, every decision we’ve made and every belief we’ve ever held would withstand examination by thousands of strangers?
I certainly couldn’t.
I’ve made mistakes. I’ve misunderstood people. I’ve changed my opinions as I’ve grown older and learned more about the world.
That’s part of being human.
Of course, not all mistakes are equal. Some actions cause lasting harm, and forgiveness cannot be demanded from those who have suffered.
But there must be room for proportion.
There must be room for learning.
There must be room for people to acknowledge wrongdoing without being permanently defined by it.
If we create a society in which one mistake can erase a lifetime of positive contributions, what incentive are we giving people to admit when they’re wrong?
If every disagreement becomes a battle, what incentive are we giving people to engage in meaningful conversation?
We cannot demand perfection from imperfect human beings and then act surprised when everybody becomes frightened to speak.
Cancelling the Culture, Not the Conversation
I don’t believe the solution is to stop criticising people.
Quite the opposite.
I think we need more meaningful criticism, more thoughtful discussion and more willingness to challenge ideas.
What we need less of is performative outrage.
Less jumping to conclusions.
Less treating somebody else’s downfall as entertainment.
Less allowing algorithms, influencers and comment sections to decide what we should think.
We need to become comfortable with the possibility that two people can look at the same information and reach different conclusions without either being malicious or unintelligent.
We need to understand that defending somebody’s right to express an opinion is not the same as endorsing that opinion.
We need to remember that empathy isn’t reserved exclusively for people we agree with.
Most of all, we need to stop treating every disagreement as an opportunity to recruit an army.
Not every conversation needs a winner.
Not every mistake needs an audience.
Not every controversy needs our participation.
Sometimes the most constructive thing we can do is listen, reflect and have a conversation without inviting the entire internet to take sides.
A Final Thought
If we’re going to cancel anything, let’s cancel the idea that we must all think alike.
Let’s cancel the pressure to have an immediate opinion about every controversy.
Let’s cancel the assumption that asking questions means taking sides.
Let’s cancel the belief that somebody’s worth as a human being can be measured by their worst moment.
Let’s encourage accountability without cruelty, disagreement without hostility, and criticism without humiliation.
Above all, let’s encourage people to develop the confidence to think independently.
Because a society in which everybody is frightened to disagree isn’t a society that has achieved understanding.
It’s a society that has learned to remain silent.
I don’t want to live in a world where everybody agrees with me. I want to live in a world where everybody feels able to think for themselves.
And if somebody disagrees with that?
Well, I’d quite like to hear why.
About the Creator
Millie Hardy-Ashton
I’m Millie Hardy-Ashton, writer, theatre practitioner and PhD researcher. Through personal reflection, humour and honest commentary, I explore disability, accessibility, creativity, popular culture and the beautifully messy business of life
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.