Humans logo

How to Stop Overthinking in a Relationship: 9 Ways to Quiet the Spiral

Simple ways to separate facts from stories before your worry becomes a fight

By Alex MallPublished about 21 hours ago • 8 min read
How to Stop Overthinking in a Relationship: 9 Ways to Quiet the Spiral
Photo by Alazar Ferrazzini on Unsplash

It may be something as innocuous as their response taking a little while or seeming a bit curt. But very quickly, probably in less than an hour, you will "know" all sorts of things about the future of your relationship, none of which you know from any exchanges with your partner. It is extremely widespread and deceptively easy to make big changes to reduce. All of these ideas, many with suggested words to use, can be applied straight away.

Acknowledge to yourself (and others) that you are overthinking

As long as the thoughts seem valid and believable, they are very compelling. So calling them by name strips away some of their power. So next time you are poring over every word of a message from your partner (and beyond the first read or two, you are unlikely to gain any more information!), just make the statement: "I'm overthinking things." At least you have then stepped back from the situation to look at your own thought process. Labeling any anxious thought appropriately is very defusing (this term is much used in CBT). Once a thought is identified and acknowledged as anxious, you are less likely to accept it uncritically.

So for example: "There are a number of things my mind could be telling me at the moment, none of which I actually know to be events."

Distinguish between the facts and assumptions

There will be very little information to work from on which to base your assumptions, which will make up the bulk of your "knowledge." For example, all you may actually know is that a message has taken some time to arrive and is fairly terse. But you may "know" a host of other things too: that they are unhappy, being deliberately unfriendly, wanting a breakup, and so on.

So it is useful to physically write down 2 lists: things you know; things you think. You will probably find you have very little under things you know, compared with a long list of things you assume to be true. Just recognizing the huge proportion that is assumption must be helpful in reducing the apparent validity of your conclusions.

Think of at least 2 other reasons for the event

As mentioned above, it's very easy to jump to the most frightening conclusion for your anxious mind. But there will almost certainly be a number of other equally likely reasons. So if your partner sends you a very matter-of-fact sentence ending in a full stop, as opposed to the more enthusiastic exclamation mark, they may be annoyed with you. But equally, they may be rushing off to an appointment or busily lifting things in and out of the car. So there is little point in attaching great significance and believing 100% that you know why when there are a variety of alternatives. Of course, there may be good reason to be concerned, but there is no justification for assuming that your worst fear is definitely the case.

Some indicators that overthinking may be occurring

You may recognize many or all of these:

  • re-reading messages to try to work out more meaning from them, such as the enthusiasm, or lack of it, of the writer, and how long it took to reply

  • spinning off into unflattering scenarios due to some minor snub or change in your partner's behavior

  • seeking frequent reassurance of your partner's continued interest and affection, only to doubt it again after a matter of days or even hours

  • studying their friends and posts on social networking sites

  • finding it difficult to focus on current conversation, preoccupied with analyzing previous conversations.

Any of these from time to time would be unremarkable. But if several apply, are a feature of most weeks, and recur shortly after receiving desired reassurance, then you may be suffering considerable overthinking.

Impose a time limit before acting on the impulse

There will often be a desired outcome from all the rumination: to write yet another message to the offender, to see how recently on the net they have been, to compose an extensive set of views on matters affecting you both, and so on. So impose an arbitrary period of time, say half an hour, before allowing yourself to do these. In the meantime, do something active and distracting. After the time period, allow yourself to do so if you still very much wish. You'll probably find there is much less desire to proceed, as impulses tend to wane after a short peak, whereas you are likely to be fairly strongly affected emotionally for as long as you continue to dwell.

So you may wish to tell yourself something like: "I can spend time thinking about this from 8 o'clock. I feel strongly about it at the moment, but I know that's no guide to how I'll feel later."

Seek a straightforward answer to 1 question

There is usually plenty of opportunity to speak to or message your partner, but it may all be oblique, tentative, testing the water... "ok." ...and then anxiously awaiting their reaction. Try stating one matter that you wish clarified, in as neutral a manner as possible, and then accepting and believing what they tell you.

For example: "I've sensed from your recent messages that you may be a little upset about something. I don't want to assume, as I tend to do, but would be glad of the opportunity to hear your view, if there is one." This raises the issue but also makes clear that you are aware of your own tendency to ascribe reasons, and so asks only for information, hopefully encouraging a frank response.

Photo by Daniel Dan on Unsplash

Avoid excessive reassurance

It will be very comforting and reassuring at the time, but with regular repetition, it will become less effective, needing ever more frequent application. So if you've asked several times already whether they love you, there is little point in continuing! Try making a note over a week of all occasions you desire and receive reassurance, and precipitating events if applicable. You'll probably see clear trends, with various triggers all tending to stir up a basic area of insecurity, with little or nothing to suggest any actual changes on the part of your partner.

So try to reassure yourself, reminding yourself of recent assurances and lack of events since then to alter your view, other than increased anxiety.

Allot specific time each day to worry

Presumably, you have tried telling yourself not to worry and given up on the futility! So decide on a short period each day, preferably regular, which will be devoted to worrying. Any other time that worries intrude, note them down briefly and reassure yourself that there is ample time devoted to it later that day. It may seem absurd, but it is surprisingly effective to tell your mind it can worry about a topic at a particular time later. You will then spend your allotted time worrying about as many things as you can think of (referring back to the methods above to be objective). Initially, it may be hard to fill 15 minutes, but gradually you may find less and less to occupy the time.

Let your partner know of your tendency

Obviously, it is better if they can understand why you may be acting in certain ways and be aware that there is nothing particular to provoke it. There is no suggestion that you want them continually allaying your fears. But it seems sensible that they should know why, for example, you may be hurt and questioning after only a terse reply from them. You may also want and be able to agree with them what appropriate levels and methods of reassurance would be.

You may want to say something like: "There are times when I know I'm being unreasonable, particularly if you've sent me only a short message. I'm inclined to jump to conclusions that you must be angry with me, although of course, there may be all sorts of innocent explanations. I'm conscious of this and trying to check myself, and don't expect any different length of message from you. Just thought you should be aware of my state of mind at such times."

Of course, there may be good grounds for your concerns

All of the above assumes there is little to provoke your worries. But clearly, there may well be events and behavior of your partner which justifiably cause you concern. Again, it is useful to look at your list of facts. If there are many, such as lies, unfriendliness, failure to keep appointments, and other commitments, then you are probably right to be concerned about the nature of the relationship. And the solution to this will be open discussion of these events and behavior. So it is important to distinguish between a preoccupation with worrying due to little real cause versus reasonable suspicion prompted by events.

Some common questions

Will I always be prone to overthinking things?

From time to time, we will all be inclined to read all sorts of meanings into other people's actions, words, and messages. But if this is very frequent, unremitting once started, not alleviated by reasonable levels of reassurance, and starts to color much of your behavior and mood, and affect your sleep, then you cross a boundary into excessive worrying.

Why am I so susceptible to overthinking messages?

With the absence of your partner to observe body language, facial expression, intonation of voice, and so on, there is a lot left to the imagination as to what may be behind a message. And as we've seen, it is easy for the imagination to run to negative conclusions. Any reduction in frequency and length of messages, and in the degree of enthusiasm expressed, can all be interpreted negatively. But of course, they are far more likely simply to be a reflection of the demands of the day.

How can I refrain from drawing negative conclusions?

As outlined above, acknowledge the thoughts, consider what information, if any, you have to support them, think of at least 2 other alternatives, and consider what facts go against your conclusion. If still in real doubt, ask your partner about this one issue. Otherwise, try to reassure yourself that these are just thoughts, with little basis.

Could my behavior as a result damage my relationship?

Very possibly. Persistently seeking to test your partner, investigating their activities, and needing constant levels of assurance would be trying for anyone and might well eventually alienate even the most understanding person. So all methods to reduce the extent and duration of overthinking are beneficial not only for your own well-being but also for the relationship.

To conclude

There are many ways to reduce the amount of time and distress spent in anxious thoughts and assumptions. Recognize them, be aware of how little information you actually have, defer taking action, seek one clear piece of information, limit recourse to others for reassurance, set aside time to worry, and enlist the cooperation of your partner. All should serve to shorten and reduce episodes of anxious overthinking, allowing you to enjoy more peaceful and happy periods.

Photo by Annette Sousa on Unsplash

divorcebreakupsadvicemarriagefamilydatinghow tolove

About the Creator

Alex Mall

I’m Alex Mackenzie, the creator of Clearer Connections. I write about relationships, communication, and small steps that can help people feel closer and better understood.

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Alex Mall