Can He Love You and Still Be Wrong for You?
Love can be real, even when the relationship isn’t the right fit for both of you.
Of course he could. There are many aspects that would determine if he was right for you. So it may be disappointing to realize that he isn't able to give you what you want from a relationship, despite loving you. After all, if he loves you, surely there's no reason why things couldn't work out?
Of course there can be. There could be many areas where you simply aren't compatible. For example, life goals, ability and desire to communicate effectively, openness and closeness, and his behavior towards you. So there are many other questions to consider: would this be a mutually respectful, reliable, fulfilling relationship?
He may love you, but be incompatible with you, or not ready.
Loving another person only describes that person's emotions. Being compatible covers a wide range of issues regarding your individual circumstances, desires, and so on. And being ready covers each person's ability to commit and participate in such a relationship at the current point in their lives.
There may well be overlap between each of these areas. For instance, he may love you but be reluctant to label the relationship; love you and want to spend his life with you, but shy away from discussing certain issues with you; or you may both love each other but wish to lead very different types of lives.
For example, one of you may wish to have a family and children at some point, whereas the other knows he doesn't want this. Neither is "wrong" to feel this, and it's not clear that just because they love one another would overcome this obstacle.
Naturally some incompatibilities are easier to negotiate. He may wish to spend all his free time with you, whereas you would wish to have more time to yourselves. Presumably you could each state what would be acceptable to you and meet halfway. So the issue would be each person's flexibility to meet the other part-way.
Clearly there would need to be a degree of mutual respect, open and frank communication, and individual friendships and pursuits. Many of these features are listed by the US Dept. of Health and Human Services as characteristics of a healthy relationship.
Look at his general behavior over a period of time.
So he may well mean it when he tells you he loves you. However, you can't automatically assume anything about how your relationship would be, based on that statement alone. You need to look at other times when you have spoken to him.
For instance: would he be attentive to your needs if you told him about them? Once you had agreed something with him, would he uphold his side of the bargain? If there was something troubling you, would you feel safe to tell him, and not expect ridicule or criticism? Would he be prepared to discuss improvements if something didn't go as planned?
So back to the example above: suppose he often canceled plans to see you at short notice. If you told him this wasn't ideal from your point of view, would he be sympathetic and try to ensure he let you know in advance when possible? Of course, this would be an indication of how willing he was to try to accommodate your needs.
On the other hand, if he dismissed you as needy each time and assured you it would be different next time, to no avail, you would probably conclude this wasn't something he was prepared to alter. It would be reasonable to base your decision about him and the relationship on these actions, regardless of whether or not you thought his love was sincere.
You wouldn't expect him to be perfect and always available, or never make mistakes. There would inevitably be occasions when he failed you. How he reacted afterwards to acknowledge his failings and try to remedy the situation in the future would be a guide.
Directly ask him about his wishes, and tell him yours.
Rather than trying to read between the lines of everything he says, or setting traps, why not just ask him straightforwardly? This allows him the opportunity to be truthful with you.
"I care about you. I would be interested to know what you would see us doing in a relationship."
He may want to take some time over his response. Would he return to you and continue the discussion? Obviously it would be preferable if he answered you directly and satisfactorily.
If there are certain things he does which trouble you, it would be helpful to point out how this makes you feel, for example:
"It upsets me when you cancel arrangements at short notice. Would it be possible to agree on some way of dealing with this?"
You aren't expecting him to comply 100% and never alter arrangements once made, just hoping to agree on a satisfactory way of communicating it.
Likewise you could tell him of qualities you would wish a partner to have. For example:
"I would want someone to be truthful and reliable."
You could go on to ask if these were things he would want.
Again, you would want to hear his response to this. But equally importantly, would he then be willing to listen further to what you needed, and work towards a mutually satisfactory solution? If you always seemed to be going round in circles, this would obviously be indicative.
I also share practical relationship tips on LinkedIn.
He doesn't have to deserve punishment!
There is no need to come up with reasons why he is an awful person and could never have loved you. As discussed above, you may well conclude he does have affection for you, but for whatever reason he isn't able to fulfill many of your requirements.
Some points you may wish to reflect on:
Am I able to be open with him about my wants and desires?
Would I feel respected in any argument?
Is he willing to try to resolve difficulties as they arise?
Am I happy with the current situation, or am I only being tolerant, hoping things will improve?
Of course there's no right or wrong answer to these. They're simply points to consider regarding how you feel in the relationship, and the options open to you. Obviously there's no rush to reach a verdict, and you may alter your opinion at any time.
Presumably he would be sorry to lose you if you decided to end things. However, this isn't a reason in itself why you should remain in the relationship. Equally, he could love you and it could still be inappropriate for either or both of you to continue together.
However, if in any way he sought to restrict your associations, contact with others, and so on, so as to dominate and intimidate you, there are organizations to help. In the USA, the National Domestic Violence Hotline can be contacted on 1-800-799-SAFE, 1-800-799-7233, by texting START to 88788, or via an online messaging service.
FAQs
So could he love me, but just not be ready?
As above, he may love you but be unwilling or unable to fulfill other criteria important to you. You may admire his frankness on this point, but then need to decide if the rest was satisfactory.
What signs indicate incompatibility?
There may well be several areas of difference, as outlined above. The main point to then assess would be if both parties could talk about these respectfully and be flexible. Of course some differences would be easier to compromise on than others. However, if one party was totally inflexible, this could be a bar to a successful relationship.
If he tells me he loves me, but doesn't act as though he does, should I stay?
It's not necessary to reach a conclusion about the sincerity of his feelings. Simply point out particular actions which are having an adverse effect on you, request changes, and observe if his behavior changes accordingly. Naturally you would wish to make your decision about remaining based primarily on how he treated you day-to-day.
Conclusion
As you can see, although it would be desirable if your partner loved you, this alone doesn't guarantee that you would have a happy, successful relationship together. Equally, you don't need to deny the degree of feeling either of you may have to conclude it isn't suitable for you.
You can find more from Clearer Connections on Patreon.
About the Creator
Alex Mall
I’m Alex Mackenzie, the creator of Clearer Connections. I write about relationships, communication, and small steps that can help people feel closer and better understood.
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.