Psyche logo

What Do You Do When You've Tried Everything for Depression?

There is a particular kind of frustration that comes with trying to get better and still not feeling better.

By Chesky BreuerPublished 3 days ago • 4 min read

I've noticed that when people talk about depression after trying several treatments, the conversation often changes.

At first, they're asking what might help.

Later, they're asking why nothing seems to be helping enough.

They may have tried different antidepressants, adjusted doses, attended therapy, or followed treatment plans that initially seemed promising. Some approaches may have helped for a while. Others may have brought difficult side effects without much improvement.

Eventually, a question begins to emerge:

"What am I supposed to do now?"

I think this is one of the most difficult questions in mental health care, partly because it can make people feel as though they've run out of options.

But trying several treatments without getting enough relief doesn't necessarily mean there is nothing left to explore.

It means the next conversation needs to look more closely at what has happened so far.

When Depression Doesn't Respond to Treatment

Treatment-resistant depression is generally used to describe depression that hasn't responded adequately to at least two antidepressant treatments given at appropriate doses and durations.

For someone experiencing this, the term can provide a clinical explanation for what they've been going through.

But the diagnosis alone doesn't tell the whole story.

One person may have experienced little improvement despite trying several medications. Another may have noticed some relief but continued to struggle with sleep, motivation, concentration, or everyday responsibilities.

Someone else may have stopped medication because the side effects became difficult to manage.

These experiences aren't interchangeable.

Understanding what happened during each treatment attempt can help a clinician identify patterns, reconsider the treatment plan, and determine what might be worth exploring next.

The important thing is not simply counting how many treatments someone has tried.

It's understanding how they responded to them.

What If Traditional Antidepressants Haven't Helped Enough?

This is where treatments such as Spravato® and ketamine-assisted psychotherapy may enter the conversation.

Spravato contains esketamine and is an FDA-approved treatment for specific depression indications, including treatment-resistant depression in adults. Depending on the indication, it may be used alone or alongside an oral antidepressant.

Ketamine-assisted psychotherapy is a different approach that combines ketamine treatment with a structured therapeutic process. The use of ketamine to treat depression is off-label, meaning it is not an FDA-approved psychiatric indication. Spravato contains esketamine, a related but distinct medication with specific FDA-approved indications and its own administration and safety requirements.

These treatments have attracted attention partly because they work differently from conventional antidepressants.

However, newer doesn't automatically mean better for a particular person.

Each approach has its own potential benefits, risks, eligibility considerations, and practical requirements. A clinician must evaluate the person's history and circumstances before determining whether either treatment is appropriate.

For someone who hasn't found sufficient relief from previous treatments, the value of exploring these options lies in understanding whether they make sense for their situation, not in assuming they are the answer.

The Conversation We Have at Marpa Minds

At Marpa Minds, some of the most important conversations begin with people trying to understand what they should consider after previous treatments haven't helped enough.

We approach these conversations by looking at the person's treatment history, current symptoms, medical background, and goals before discussing possible next steps.

Our Clinical Director, Amy Della Rocca, MSN, MPH, PMHNP-BC, brings extensive experience in mental health care and Spravato treatment. Our team also includes Nathan Levitt, MSN, FNP-BC, who brings over 20 years of healthcare experience, including experience at NYU Langone Health, along with a background in integrative mental health and trauma-informed care. 

These different professional backgrounds help inform discussions about a person's treatment history and the options that may be appropriate to consider next.

For some patients, traditional psychiatric treatment remains appropriate. For others, options such as Spravato or ketamine-assisted psychotherapy may be considered following a comprehensive evaluation.

The recommendation should follow the clinical assessment, not precede it.

I think this distinction matters because people who have tried several treatments often arrive with understandable questions about whether anything else could help. 

They deserve an honest discussion of the available options, including their limitations, rather than another promise that the next treatment will finally solve everything.

When You've Tried So Much, It's Okay Not to Know What's Next

One thing I wish more people understood is that they don't need to arrive at an appointment knowing which treatment they want.

They don't need to have researched every available option or decided whether they are ready to try something new.

They can start by explaining what they've experienced.

What helped, even briefly? What didn't? What became difficult to tolerate? What are they still struggling with?

Those questions can provide a more useful starting point than simply asking what treatment to try next.

And if depression is affecting everyday life, continuing to struggle without support isn't something a person has to accept indefinitely. A qualified mental health professional can help assess the situation and discuss appropriate next steps.

And when someone is experiencing thoughts of suicide or feels unable to stay safe, immediate support is extremely important. In the United States, always call or text 988 for crisis support, or call 911 in a life-threatening emergency.

So far, I've come to believe that trying several treatments without enough relief doesn't mean you've reached the end of the road.

At Marpa Minds, these conversations often involve looking beyond what hasn't worked and considering what might make sense next. For some people, that may include exploring treatments such as Spravato or ketamine-assisted psychotherapy after a comprehensive clinical evaluation.

Always reach out! as every person's story deserves to be heard, understood, and met with care.!


recoveryanxietytherapyadvicedepression

About the Creator

Chesky Breuer

Founder of Marpa Minds. Writing about mental health, treatment-resistant depression, ketamine-assisted psychotherapy, and the science behind innovative approaches to emotional wellness.

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Chesky Breuer