Feast logo

Recipe Disaster!

Fortunately, you’ll never find this one on a menu.

By Liz MontanoPublished 2 days ago • Updated 2 days ago • 5 min read
Image created with Gemini

I wanted to bake a cake.

I was eight years old and at my mother’s house for one of my infrequent visits. She lived in a trailer so tiny that, to get to the back bedroom, you had to walk through one postage-stamp-sized bedroom and a bathroom so small you could use the toilet, soak your feet, and wash your hands all at once. By the way, in case you were wondering, the reason for visits with my mother is another story altogether.

My mom planned to host a dinner for some guy she hoped to get to know better. She didn’t tell me she had her sights set on him as a future husband. She didn’t need to. I could read the room pretty well even at that young age, and we’d already been through the routine a time or two before.

It was easy to see she was especially excited about her dinner date. She’d gone all out for the occasion. She'd purchased real meat from the grocery store instead of our usual fare of commodity canned meat. Who knew what all went into that stuff! She’d also made a trip to the thrift shop before I’d arrived, buying a new (to her) dress. She’d even bought one for me. 

They were both pretty, if you were a girly girl, which I was not. I’d wrinkled my nose in disgust when she presented it to me. Showing my distaste wasn’t a particularly smart move; she lectured me about being grateful for what I had. I was lectured further when I proclaimed I hadn’t wanted anything in the first place. (Yes, I was a mouthy kid.) 

I could see the itch to smack me across the mouth was about as intense as my need to scratch the itch caused by the pink lacy dress. I hated that dress. But since I didn’t particularly want to be smacked, I stopped arguing. (I was also a fairly smart kid most of the time.) 

While the bread dough rested, we stayed busy. We spent the day cleaning every little corner of the oversized bread box. We even washed the windows with some kind of vinegar solution that smelled to high heaven. I wondered if she were trying to prove she was Miss Susie Homemaker and Julia Child all rolled into one.

Rolling out the bread dough for homemade rolls, prepping the roast for the oven, and making some kind of pasta with canned tomatoes, Mom told me to gather the ingredients for a cake. Dutiful daughter that I occasionally was, I got everything out: flour, baking powder, sugar, salt, vanilla, butter, eggs, and milk.

After getting what the recipe called for, I stood back, looked it all over, and announced, “I want to make the cake, Mom. I know how to read the recipe and measure it all out, and you’re busy, anyway.”

She shot me a dubious look, blew a strand of hair from her face, and then, after several long moments of thought, agreed. “Just let me know when it’s mixed together, and I’ll pour the batter into the pan. But read the recipe carefully, you hear? And don’t spill anything. I don’t have time to clean up a mess.” 

I nodded enthusiastically, feeling quite grown up. Hoping this date would be worth all the trouble she was going to, I ran to the bathroom to get a hair tie. With my hair back in a ponytail, I scrubbed my hands nearly raw before tackling the job my mother had entrusted to me. 

I read through the recipe twice to make sure I hadn’t forgotten anything. Then, to make doubly sure, I read it again as I carefully measured out the ingredients. One thing looked a bit odd to me, but hey, that's what it called for, so I measured that ingredient out, too. 

I stirred for what felt like forever since Mom instructed me to keep stirring until she told me to stop. Finally, she took the bowl, poured the batter into a big cake pan, and popped it into the oven alongside the roast. 

I peeked when my mother took it out of the oven about 35 minutes later. It looked perfect.  I literally preened at my accomplishment.

The entire meal was ready and waiting when Bernie knocked on the door. I was actually impressed. He seemed super nice and was, as I whispered to Mom, a cutie pie. He’d even brought her a bouquet of flowers. 

Everything went exactly as Mom had hoped. A dynamite meal, good conversation, and a daughter who’d been on her best behavior. I hadn’t made one snarky remark. Everything, that is, until she served dessert. 

Bernie took the first bite, only for his face to turn a sickly shade of green. He grabbed his napkin, spit the bite into it, and coughed as if he were choking to death. He then grabbed his glass of ice water and chugged it in one big gulp.

“A bit salty,” he rasped, and held the glass out for more water.

Mom apologized profusely, explaining I’d made the cake while she was busy preparing the rest of the meal. Naturally, she blamed me after taking credit for it earlier. Although it hurt my pride, that was fine. I had been the one to mix it.

Bernie left shortly afterward, promising to call the next day (he didn’t), and Mom ripped me a new one. My eyes stung like crazy as I tried to hold back tears, but I didn’t let a single one fall. I didn’t bother to tell her I had not purposely sabotaged the dinner after she accused me of it. 

Once she’d gone to bed (possibly to cry herself to sleep over the disaster), I snuck back into the kitchen and looked at the recipe again. I was so sure I’d followed every instruction right down to the letter. I gasped when I saw where I’d gone wrong. I’d put two cups of salt into the batter instead of two cups of sugar. 

I didn’t make that mistake again. However, I couldn’t have, since Mom never let me make another cake when I visited. And Bernie never came back around. She always reminded me of that whenever I asked to try again. 

That recipe, or the way I made it at least, was one you’d never find on a menu. 

Just to regain a tiny ounce of that lost pride, I must say I do make some pretty darn good cakes now, with the right amount of sugar and very little salt.

satirehow tocuisinerecipediy

About the Creator

Liz Montano

Former news reporter, now a multi-genre novelist who's indie-published out of impatience. I'm much happier now writing stories and endings that touch and make readers feel. I can be contacted at elizabethmontano.com or #newsbizlizzy on X.

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Liz Montano