Psyche logo

How a Waiter's Question Unveiled My Hidden Schizophrenia Shame

The minefield of small talk.

By Leon MacfaydenPublished 13 days ago 5 min read
Top Story - June 2024
Image by FG Trade on iStock

By the time I got to see a psychiatrist for PTSD, I thought a famous magician was stealing my thoughts. I’d tried to barricade my front door to stop people from getting in to kill me. I had no idea who these people were, but I was sure they worked for the government and wanted me dead.

But I couldn’t barricade the voices from my head. I spent every waking hour listening to them calling me scum and telling me to kill myself. I’d given up driving because they told me to crash the car.

I felt scared to go out but had nowhere to run. The real terror was in my mind.

I thought I would see a psychiatrist to build a case against the magician. I believed I was completely sane. I hoped the shrink could pick up that the magician was telepathically harassing me. This would help in the private prosecution I planned to start.

Instead, she diagnosed me with schizophrenia, changed and ramped up my meds, and sent me on my way.

The impact of my diagnosis hadn’t hit me, but the medication worked well. The voices quietened, and the paranoia faded.

The next time I saw a psychiatrist, and they confirmed my diagnosis, I reacted with shock. Schizophrenia is the one mental illness no one wants anything to do with. Some people find illnesses like bipolar “quirky.” They hide behind labels like “anxiety”. No one wants to be thought of as a potential axe murderer. The stereotypical mad person who sits in the corner muttering to himself.

It’s a stigma that I have against myself to this day.

The dreaded question for someone with mental illness.

Last week, me and my partner Amy went to a restaurant. When it was time to pay the bill, she went to the restroom, and I settled up. I don’t usually talk to people and hate small talk, but we had an amiable waiter this time.

He asked me if I had any plans for the rest of the day, and I said I’d be relaxing. This is usually where the small talk ends. But this waiter got more from me. He asked me the dreaded question, “What do you do?” I hate this question — it’s part of why I don’t talk to random people because it always comes up. I don’t know how to give a painless answer.

When forced, I tell people I’m medically retired from the police with PTSD. I hate calling myself a writer, as it’s so pretentious. It’s like calling yourself an artist or a singer. Most people who can’t wait to tell you they’re writers are awful at it. They make no money and self-publish everything. Instead, I say, “I write blog posts about mental health now that I’ve made a good recovery.” I also trade the stock market.

He seemed impressed that I wrote articles and called me an author. I cringed so hard I choked on my Diet Coke. But that’s not the thing that stuck out most from this conversation. I realized that I am prepared to divulge my PTSD in a way that I never would with my schizophrenia.

My PTSD is like a badge of honor. I can explain it positively. Of course, some people think I’m weak or faking it for the benefits. Most of those people also struggle to tie their shoelaces. The rest of society knows that getting PTSD from policing means I’ve seen nightmare-inducing stuff. People respect that.

I feel shame about having schizophrenia. Most people have no idea about it. They believe the old trope that schizophrenia is synonymous with split personalities.

People think those with schizophrenia are dangerous. There are high-profile cases of crimes committed in a psychotic state. But these are the exceptions. Most schizophrenics are only a danger to themselves.

They think we should be in mental hospitals because we can’t recover. Although I’m proof that isn’t true, I can’t get into such intense debates with a stranger.

The real reason for my shame.

My diagnosis of schizophrenia has left me bitter. Living in a psychotic state took a decade from my life. The medication has made me fat, slowed my thinking, slurred my speech, and gave me problems with my teeth. It gave me high cholesterol, and I’m sure it’s taken years off my life expectancy.

I lost the best years of my life to an illness that made me believe in nonsense. People say it’s all good talking to God, but watch out if he talks back.

I think of all the things I could’ve done and how much more advanced I’d be if schizophrenia hadn’t blighted my life.

I’m someone who admires courage above all else. And although I was brave in overcoming schizophrenia, I feel weak for having had it in the first place.

I know this doesn’t make sense. I know mental illness can happen to anyone, and I know it’s not a sign of weakness when it comes to other people. But I feel differently about myself.

On the positive side.

When the frustration and sadness kick in, I have to remind myself of the huge positives in my life.

The biggest positive is that I’ve recovered. I’ve had no symptoms for years, and as long as I stick to my medication regime, I have no reason to believe that will change. Many people with schizophrenia aren’t fortunate enough to find meds that work so well.

Many people with schizophrenia live sad and lonely lives. They’re shunned by society. Yet Amy has been with me for 20 years. Somehow, she stuck with me through my darkest times.

Many people with schizophrenia are poor and dependent on benefits. I saved a lot of money because the police paid me for my disability in the line of duty. I then learned to trade and invest in stocks.

I’m my own poster boy for why you SHOULDN’T feel shame for having schizophrenia. I was once diagnosed as 100% disabled for the rest of my life. I’m proof that you’re never too old or broken to recover and live your dreams. Yes, you may have lost time to your illness, but better late than never.

And yet, despite these incredible achievements, I still feel pangs of shame. I will continue working to understand my feelings and overcome them.

Maybe one day, I’ll be able to proudly proclaim that I’ve spent a decade beating schizophrenia. And on that day, it will be less embarrassing than calling myself a writer.

Looking for the right therapist can feel overwhelming. If you’re in search of guidance, consider downloading my free checklist, ‘Finding the Best Therapist: Your Essential Guide.’ Click here.


About the Creator

Leon Macfayden

From a police officer to a psychiatric ward and recovery.

Grab my new FREE checklist for the top 5 books that will change your life starting today.

From fear and worry to courage and success.

Turn adversity into advantage.

Reader insights


Excellent work. Looking forward to reading more!

Top insights

  1. Expert insights and opinions

    Arguments were carefully researched and presented

  2. Eye opening

    Niche topic & fresh perspectives

  3. Heartfelt and relatable

    The story invoked strong personal emotions

  1. On-point and relevant

    Writing reflected the title & theme

Add your insights

Comments (20)

Sign in to comment
  • Esala Gunathilake9 days ago

    Congrats on your top story.

  • Anu Mehjabin9 days ago

    Your battle with PTSD and schizophrenia has been tough, but your resilience is inspiring. And congrats on your top story🎉

  • Karen Cave9 days ago

    Thank you for writing this and for sharing. For what it's worth - as a person with mental illness and complicated needs myself - I respect you hugely. You have achieved much to be proud of :)

  • Andrea Corwin 9 days ago

    Sorry, I forgot to congratulate you on the TS!🥳🥳🥳

  • Andrea Corwin 9 days ago

    It is very difficult to find the best doctor, psychiatrist, etc. No shame for you. Mental illness is difficult and I'm glad Amy has stayed the course with you. Congrats on success with stock market and being able to talk about this. I wish you wellness. Medicine can help, and also hinder or create another issue for another med but it sounds like they have yours balanced! Yay...👏

  • Sarah Wilcox9 days ago

    Happy I was on and saw this while reading tonight! Thank you for sharing this! I’m excited to read more of your pieces but this hit home and definitely deserves top story, congrats!

  • I can't imagine going through that. I can't stand hearing nonsense. It would be he'll to be thinking it. Glad it went away. But this illness did not take away your abilities and unique qualities

  • BrettNotGreg9 days ago

    Wow. So great to see how far you’ve come! Very inspiring! Thank you for sharing your story!

  • Picsart Mod APK10 days ago

  • JBaz10 days ago

    Mental health is, in my opinion, just being delved into as a serious actual ailment. My daughter has suffered most of her life and it has taken me years to realize it is more than a "just focus on the good" to help assist. Thank you for writing this.

  • shanmuga priya10 days ago

    Congratulations 🎉

  • This is such a brave story to share. I think we all carry some secret shame or other, and it’s only through sharing it that we realize how very common that awful feeling is. I was in a Reddit group on shamanism, and someone with schizophrenia started a thread about if it would be a safe form of alternative therapy. Out of genuine curiosity I asked them how they can know for sure that they’re schizophrenic and not just some mystic like the shaman. Not that I didn’t believe their diagnosis, but I wanted to understand how they get themselves to believe it. I mean there are alcoholics who do not believe they have an addiction. I can’t imagine wrapping my head around my reality not being other people’s, and the amount of trust I’d need in what they’re saying for me to accept help. But what ended up happening was a bunch of people who don’t even have schizophrenia interjected with their opinions based on Google searches. And I said wait, I’m not talking to you. Then they downvoted me to hell. The hubris was astounding, and I’m so glad you are speaking up! For yourself and others who do live with schizophrenia.

  • Awesome writing, keep it up!

  • Selina DeCarles10 days ago

    I always talk to my friends about how much I hate small talk with strangers. I have my reasons, of course, but you've given me a new perspective on it. As someone who aspires to be a mental health advocate, thank you so much for sharing your experience. The world has a lot of catching up to do with these topics. I hope your journey with Schizophrenia continues to be peaceful, and congratulations on your Top Story!

  • Babs Iverson10 days ago

    Congratulations on Top Story!!! Your personal story was insightful.

  • I'm proud of your growth you have brought a very important voice to mental illness, great & inspired personal narrative

  • Christy Munson10 days ago

    You've given me a great deal to think about. Thank you for that. Congratulations on Top Story. 🥳 I agree with Vocal's curators that this article deserves a wide audience. There is such stigma around mental health, and that is heartbreaking. I can only speak to it from an outsider's perspective, as someone who has known others who've worked through it. So it is crucial that someone who knows firsthand can give voice to the experience and help to humanize it.

  • The Dani Writer11 days ago

    Way to connect from the first line Leon! You're a gifted and skilled writer and this is a much-needed topic to focus on. There are these silent "societally-acceptable" mental illnesses, and there are also those with tons of misinformation and unrealistic drama attached to them that are treated like the plague. A demystification is necessary so that we can all get over ourselves and learn something so that people can be treated like people. You're a great teacher. Please keep teaching! Top Story Kudos!

  • ROCK 11 days ago

    Newly subscribed. I learned a lot and felt very moved by your candidness.

  • Joe O’Connor13 days ago

    This is really powerful Leon, thank you for sharing. Shame is a nasty piece of work but it sounds like you are well on your way to putting it in its place.

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

© 2024 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.