Humans logo

If You See This, Forgive Me

A Conversation I've Been Meaning to Have

By M.C. Finch Published 15 days ago • 10 min read
If You See This, Forgive Me
Photo by Ivenory on Unsplash

The veins along the back of his hand bulged as he cupped it around his cigarette. The delicate crackle of tobacco catching was like a homecoming. I was always disheartened how watching Caleb light a cigarette was such a turn on for me, given how I’d always despised smoking prior to meeting him. It conjured up memories of the back seat of a Lincoln on crooked Smoky Mountain roads. A youth spent choking on my grandmother’s Salem smoke intermixed with White Rain hairspray and White Diamonds perfume. But to see him partake in an American Spirit did things to me I can’t explain.

“You look good,” he offered with a gentle exhale. His free hand drummed the white linen tablecloth. “You know…professional.” He made a flourish with the cigarette that was meant to encompass me. I felt my cheeks redden at the memory of how often I’d used the word professional as an antonym to Caleb often during our relationship. Clearly he hadn’t forgotten.

“You look the same,” I said, fighting eye contact. He made a pinched, humored face and considered his hands. “Which is very much a compliment, I assure you!” I hastily tacked onto the end. He nodded and sighed a, “Thanks,” as our waiter divvied out drinks.

“Good to know some things never change,” Caleb said with a nod towards the briny martini in front of me. “Laine and Martinis. You always knew who you were, even back then. You’re the only person I’ve met who, at twenty-two, could drink one with a straight face.” I wondered if he ever knew how painful those first few years of teaching myself to enjoy a martini were. The first brick of my worldly and austere façade.

We let an awkward silence fall over us. He indulged in another cigarette while I made a considerable dent in my cocktail.

“I should’ve said hello last night,” I gushed. I had crashed his film festival cocktail hour the night before to then fled the scene after an exchanged glance like I had stolen something other than free gin. “I—I panicked,” I offered feeling a little more confident with gin doing honest work in my veins. Caleb grinned and leaned back confidently in his chair. Pleased, I supposed that he could still physically affect me.

“I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t a little floored to see you, too. You know, I’d considered calling, but you know…didn’t know if it was appropriate. We’ve never left things on the best of terms, and I wasn’t even sure you were still in town.”

“When have we ever bothered with what was appropriate?” I asked breathlessly.

“Fair enough,” he said with his little half grin.

The last night we were together as a couple had been a martini night as well. This leads one to suspect there may be a problem on my part.  Caleb and I had been arguing more than usual. Sex had come to a screeching halt, which was odd considering his massive drive for it. So, I engaged in Stepford-like behavior. I made a good home. I met him with kind, reassuring faces and soft touches of encouragement. I made elaborate meals and pretended to ignore how he would text his high school ex-girlfriend late into the night.

Whatever support his career in film needed from me, she would provide tenfold. I knew he begrudged me my gentle goading for possible partner of a law firm. Something that would inch us towards summers in Sagaponack. God forbid a man help his partner reach for a higher, sturdier bough. How was I to know he wasn’t looking for a higher bough, but an entirely different tree.

It had been an altogether pleasant week. I’d been miserable at work but tried to put on a fighting front for him because his work was worse, and he came home late at night smelling of the bar and looking more dead behind his eyes. When he got home that night, I had a cocktail waiting. I had layered ham and Gruyère and chicken. I was thinly slicing onions for a potato gratin when he nudged in through the door with a sullen expression and reeking of weed.

I greeted him with a kiss and a cocktail as I’d been taught by southern tradition and 1950’s sitcoms was customary when dealing with a disgruntled husband. He took a swallow and said it was nice. He crossed to the island of our small starter apartment and stared at the microwave.

“I think I want an open relationship.”

I pretended not to hear him at first. I watched an olive lob around in the murky gin and took a measured breath. When I didn’t respond, I suppose he took it for idiocy on my part and then launched himself into a by-the-book explanation of opening one’s relationship. That it was just sex. He wanted variety, like gas station candy, and it didn’t mean anything except satisfying his curiosity as long as he still came home to me…which I gathered somewhere in there he might still want to do if I played my cards right.

I admittedly was insecure in my youth. He was a god, and I was me and a child of divorce and had never felt like anyone had cared to put me first in my entire life. Caleb had always made our life feel so compact and safe. The first time I had felt safe. An open relationship wasn’t just him sampling a different truck stop snack, it was the promise of eventual abandonment. I remember laying down the knife, finishing my martini in a languid swallow, and mixing up another in rapid succession. I told him politely, in a measured tone, I had no desire for that. That if we were struggling to keep it together, then putting a turnstile at the front door wasn’t going to make anything better. I said words. He said words. Then I stopped speaking. I let life happen to me and just nodded my head as it did so.

Somewhere around my third martini he declared he was bisexual, and over the course of the last two years he had forgotten somehow to mention that. He sprinkled it into his explanation of exploration as if he were adding a little salt into a soup. He wanted to explore this part of himself. It was the nail in the coffin.

Our neighbor Bob was pushing one hundred and had asked Caleb and I separately and together to come over one evening for Sunset Boulevard and craft beers on multiple occasions. I suddenly felt this was the perfect night for it. When Caleb blocked the door and told me we needed to talk this through, I said I needed some air. The next thing I remember was waking up at the apartment complex pool like a Melrose Place episode gone wrong. Caleb had packed a bag. Chicken cordon bleu had spoiled on the counter.

Now here he was, sitting across from me more beautiful than ever and more successful to boot. He’d put something of himself into the world and was receiving praise and monetary compensation for it. I was halfway to a three-figure salary and fighting for my life, though you could never outwardly tell. Over the last eight years, I’d tried to put my love for him into a little box. A manageable little box I could lift the lid from to peek at the memory of him from time to time. But seeing him then, in New York, in autumn…fuck that box. Every feeling I’d ever held for him flew all over me.

“I think about that night a lot…” I said softly after some time. “I wish so badly we could go back and take a breath and…I don’t know. Say what I meant. I felt I couldn’t get a word in edgewise. You were so defensive.” My hands were shaking and I topped off my martini with the little sidecar that came with it. Caleb’s expression contorted and he coughed into his elbow.

“I was defensive? Jesus, Laine. You threatened to kill me.”

“I did NOT threaten to kill you, Caleb! I might’ve asked if you thought it was the best time to have that conversation while I had a knife in my hand. It wasn’t a threat, just an assessment of your overall judgement.” Caleb became serious, and his eyes drifted across Bedford Ave.

“You shut the lights off, Laine. The minute I said I was bi and wanted you to know, you just went blank. Slinging martinis, and pacing the floor. I’m pretty sure you said being bisexual was having a bad case of fence-riding. I guess I just didn’t think there was much left to fight for at that point.” He toyed with the ice block in his negroni with a well-manicured finger.

“I did not say that!” I countered. Jesus… did I say that? “I…I have great respect for all members of our community. I don’t have qualms with THE bisexuals! I had reservations about you being one. That’s entirely circumstantial.” Caleb stared at me for a moment, his jaw slacked and then he laughed audibly and clapped his cigarette pack on the table.

“You’re a piece of work, Laine.” He lit the cigarette and peered across the table at me. “You made me feel like a lesser thing…with a knife in your hand. Then you just sat everything down and said you were going to the pool. I said you were going to drown. You said I wouldn’t give a god damn if you did and gave me a good old-fashioned Scarlett O’Hara slap to drive it home. You always were so dramatic. Someone should’ve restricted your access to soaps as a child.”

It was like reading a bad review of a movie you had seen a thousand times. I frantically ripped through the last eight years to examine that night, but Caleb seemingly remembered it like a historic text. I felt my face flush. How do you go back and offer the twenty-two-year-old you a slap in the face rather than Caleb? The embarrassment was enough to turn my stomach, and I pushed my martini away.

I remember being at the kitchen island. God, I’m remembering that stupid floral apron now…I was dicing the onions and remember being thankful for the cover as tears began to spring to my eyes. I remember trying to process it all so quickly—open relationship; bisexual; the crumbling of a life I was certain had everything to do with that grungy concert he had taken the high school girlfriend now wife to. I don’t remember slapping him, but in hindsight it does sound like the kind of camp I would bring to the situation. I really was allowed to watch too much Desperate Housewives and Dynasty growing up. I remember him following me to the pool. I never made it to Bob’s. I still haven’t seen Sunset Boulevard to this day.

“It’s funny…” I said, my voice catching in my throat. “I remember myself trying to hold it together and handle it with dignity…or so I thought.” His face softened and he ashed his cigarette into the street.

“If that was dignity…I’d sure as hell hate to piss you off in an undignified state.” He nodded to the waiter for another round of drinks.

“For what it’s worth, I’m so sorry. I hope you know I said those things out of anger. Looking back, I obviously knew that what was about to transpire would hurt me. I guess I wanted to make sure I hurt you first.”

“We both wanted it to be over…you know that. You wanted me to be something I wasn’t, and I wanted you to be something you’d never be, and we loved each other so much that we just kept trying to make the pieces fit.” He frowned, as if saying it aloud was the first time he’d understood our situation himself. He let out a rugged breath that fogged on the chilly Brooklyn air and reached out for his negroni with his left hand. I noticed in an instant the absence of his wedding band. I felt my heart twinge that possibly he had left it behind to spare me some pain.

“We were perfect for each other, Caleb. That’s what I remember.” My throat felt tight and I swallowed the cool fresh martini as tears stung in my eyes.

“You romanticized it all too much, babe. Maybe that’s the writer in you. You beat us to a pulp with a Jane Austen novel. You never could see us for what we were. I’m a realist. I remember it exactly as it was.”

“You’re right…I can’t remember it being this forced arrangement, because it was never that to me, Caleb. You and I…well I haven’t found anything like it since. So, there had to be some part of it that was real. Some part of it that was good. No matter how it ended.” Caleb examined me for a moment and smiled softly; he hung his head over his negroni and took another drag.

“We’re all allowed our own versions of the past, Laine. And you’re right, it wasn’t all bad. I won’t deny you that. I did love the hell out of you once.” His hand found its way across the table and fell heavily on top of mine. “It was real. But we weren’t the fucking Cleavers, either.”

We laughed and I dabbed my eyes with a rattling exhale of my own. The past faded as it does into the present. He asked about my novels that were withering in the shadow of corporate ladder climbing, and I him about his next three documentaries he had planned. Time lulled as we talked. There was an eeriness to it I couldn’t shake.

When we finally settled our tabs and readjusted our coats, we stood on the sidewalk looking at one another as if we had stumbled in front of a mirror that boasted the wrong reflection. Each of us allowed the other a moment to let our eyes create a memory of the other to last another eight years.

“Don’t be a stranger,” he said, opening his arms for a hug. My embrace was a surge of remorse and regret I hoped he’d understand and accept.

Don’t be a stranger. How funny, I thought as I let him go. We had just spent the last hour and a half trying to convince ourselves that wasn’t exactly what we were.

breakupsdatingfact or fictionlovelgbtq

About the Creator

M.C. Finch

North Carolina native. Writer of Fiction. Working on several novels and improving my craft. Romance, history, family dynamics, LGBTQ+, and sweeping dramas are what I love most.

Writing Instagram: @m.c.finchwrites

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by M.C. Finch