Disabled Enough for a Walking Stick, Not Disabled Enough for Support
Living with Multiple Sclerosis has taught me that having a disability and being recognised as disabled by the benefits system are two very different things. When your independence is already being challenged by illness, why should you have to fight so hard for the support intended to protect it?
There is something profoundly frustrating about standing in front of a mirror, looking at the walking stick you now rely on to get around, and knowing that somewhere in a government office, somebody has decided you are not disabled enough to qualify for the support you need.
I have Multiple Sclerosis. I experience fatigue, pain, balance problems, weakness and difficulty walking. My legs can shake, my foot can drop, and activities that once seemed perfectly ordinary can now require hours of recovery. I have fallen in public, struggled to navigate pavements and had to reconsider how I work, travel and manage my everyday life.
Yet, according to the Department for Work and Pensions, the support I was awarded through Personal Independence Payment was based on my anxiety rather than the physical impact of my MS.
I want to be very clear that anxiety is a legitimate condition that can have a significant impact on someone’s daily life. I am not suggesting that support awarded for mental health difficulties is somehow less valid than support awarded for physical disability. What I find difficult to understand is how a condition that has fundamentally changed my mobility and independence can seem to carry so little weight in the assessment of the support I need.
I was diagnosed with MS in January 2025. Receiving that diagnosis finally gave me an explanation for symptoms that had been affecting my life, but it also marked the beginning of an entirely new relationship with my body. I had to learn to recognise fatigue before it became overwhelming. I had to accept that walking was no longer something I could take for granted. I had to begin using mobility aids, plan journeys around accessible routes and understand that being physically capable of completing an activity did not necessarily mean I could do it safely, repeatedly or without consequences.
The diagnosis changed the way I lived. It did not, however, automatically change the way the benefits system viewed me. That is where one of the most exhausting contradictions of disability begins.
There is a detail that makes this experience particularly frustrating, and it is something many people may not realise. Multiple Sclerosis is one of just three medical conditions specifically recognised as disabilities from the point of diagnosis under the Equality Act 2010. Alongside cancer and HIV, MS is explicitly named in Schedule 1 of the Act. This means that, for the purposes of equality law, I was legally recognised as disabled from the moment I received my diagnosis in January 2025. I did not have to wait until I needed a walking stick. I did not have to experience a certain number of falls or demonstrate that my symptoms had become severe enough to interfere with my daily life. The law already recognised my disability.
That legal protection is important. It acknowledges that MS is a lifelong neurological condition and that its impact cannot always be measured by what somebody can see on any given day. Yet there is a remarkable contradiction between being automatically recognised as disabled under equality legislation and having to fight for financial support through a separate government assessment.
I understand that the Equality Act and PIP serve different purposes. Being legally disabled does not automatically mean somebody meets the criteria for a particular benefit. PIP considers the practical impact of a condition on daily living and mobility. However, I cannot help finding it extraordinary that the law recognises the seriousness of my diagnosis without demanding that I prove how badly it affects me, while another part of the system requires me to describe, document and defend the difficulties I experience.
I did not have to prove I was disabled to be protected by the Equality Act. Yet I am still having to prove how my disability affects me to access the support intended to help me live with it. That is the contradiction I find so difficult to reconcile.
Personal Independence Payment, or PIP, is intended to help with the additional costs of living with a disability or long-term health condition. It is not supposed to be awarded simply because somebody has a particular diagnosis. Instead, the assessment considers how their condition affects specific daily living and mobility activities.
In principle, I understand that approach.
Two people with MS can experience completely different symptoms. One person may have relatively little difficulty with mobility, while another may need significant assistance. A diagnosis alone cannot tell an assessor everything about somebody’s needs.
The difficulty comes when the system designed to measure those needs fails to capture the reality of living with a fluctuating condition.
MS does not operate according to a convenient timetable.
I might manage a short walk one morning and struggle to cross a room later that afternoon. I might appear reasonably steady when I first stand up, only for my legs to become increasingly unreliable as I continue moving. I might be capable of preparing a meal but then need to rest because the activity has exhausted me.
The fact that I can do something once does not mean I can do it reliably.
That word, reliably, is enormously important.
Under PIP rules, the ability to complete an activity is supposed to be considered in terms of whether it can be done safely, to an acceptable standard, repeatedly and within a reasonable time.
That is not an insignificant technicality.
It is the difference between asking whether somebody can walk a certain distance and asking whether they can walk that distance without risking a fall, becoming overwhelmed by fatigue or being unable to repeat the activity when necessary.
It is the difference between managing to cook dinner and being able to prepare food safely on a regular basis.
It is the difference between being able to get dressed and being able to do so without pain, difficulty or excessive time.
It is the difference between existing and functioning.
For people with fluctuating conditions, that distinction can be the foundation of an accurate assessment.
Yet the experience of applying for disability support can make you feel as though you are constantly having to prove that the difficulties you describe are real.
I have found that particularly difficult.
Before MS, I was already somebody who struggled with anxiety. I worried about how other people perceived me, whether I was doing enough and whether I was meeting the expectations placed upon me.
Then I developed a condition that made some of those expectations physically impossible to meet.
Suddenly, I was not simply trying to adjust to a disability. I was also trying to explain that disability to a system with the power to decide whether I deserved financial support.
There is something deeply uncomfortable about having to describe your worst days to a stranger.
Most of us spend our lives trying to present ourselves as capable. We are taught to be independent, hardworking and resilient. We learn to say we are fine even when we are struggling. We minimise pain, push through fatigue and apologise when we need help.
Then a disability assessment asks us to do the opposite.
We are expected to explain every difficulty, every limitation and every occasion when our bodies fail to cooperate.
We have to describe the things we cannot do.
We have to acknowledge the help we need.
We have to put into words experiences we might still be struggling to accept ourselves.
For somebody newly adjusting to a diagnosis, that can be extraordinarily painful.
I had spent so much time trying to convince myself that I could still live a relatively normal life. Suddenly, I was being asked to explain all the ways in which my life was no longer normal.
It can feel like being forced to confront your disability before you have fully come to terms with it.
Then comes the decision.
When the outcome does not reflect your experience, it can feel as though somebody has looked at everything you have been through and decided it is not enough.
Not enough difficulty.
Not enough pain.
Not enough fatigue.
Not enough evidence.
Not disabled enough.
Of course, that is not the wording used in the decision. PIP is a points-based assessment of particular activities, not an official judgement of whether somebody is sufficiently disabled as a person.
Emotionally, however, that is exactly how a disappointing decision can feel.
It is difficult not to take it personally when the subject being assessed is your own body.
I know how far I can walk before my legs become unreliable. I know what happens when fatigue takes over. I know how frightening it is when my foot catches the ground unexpectedly or my balance disappears.
I know the difference between a good day and a bad day.
I know how much planning goes into leaving the house.
I know what my body costs me.
Yet the assessment process can leave you feeling that your own experience is somehow less authoritative than somebody else’s interpretation of it.
That feeling becomes even harder to manage when your disability is not consistently visible.
I do not look like a different person because I have MS.
My face has not changed. My personality has not disappeared. I can still laugh, hold conversations, work and enjoy myself.
Sometimes I can walk a short distance without my stick.
Sometimes I can stand for a while.
Sometimes I can have a wonderful day out.
None of those things means my disability has disappeared.
Yet I am acutely aware that these moments can be misunderstood.
A photograph of me smiling does not show the fatigue I might experience afterwards. Seeing me walk across a room does not reveal how difficult it might be to walk back. Watching me manage an activity once does not establish that I can manage it repeatedly.
The problem with invisible and fluctuating disability is that people often judge what they can see rather than what the person is actually experiencing.
That can happen in everyday life, but it becomes especially concerning when the same assumptions influence decisions about financial support.
I have already experienced how quickly independence can become expensive.
A walking stick or crutches might help me get around, but they do not remove the need to consider accessible transport, parking, rest breaks and additional assistance.
Driving an automatic car makes travelling more manageable for me than relying on buses, but maintaining a vehicle is expensive. When I was without my car, I was reminded just how physically demanding public transport could be.
There are days when ordinary household tasks require more energy than I have available. There are times when I need adaptations, assistance or a different way of doing something.
Disability can create costs in money, time and energy.
Those costs do not disappear because an assessment fails to recognise them.
That is why the name Personal Independence Payment matters so much to me.
The purpose of this support is connected to independence.
Not luxury.
Not convenience.
Independence.
It can help disabled people manage some of the additional costs that come with living in bodies that do not always work in the ways society expects.
It can help make everyday life more manageable.
It can help people maintain their participation in work, family life and their communities.
Yet accessing that support can become another exhausting responsibility.
When I challenged my PIP decision through Mandatory Reconsideration, I hoped that providing further information would help the decision-makers understand the impact MS has on my life.
My reconsideration was unsuccessful.
Now I am facing the tribunal process.
There is something incredibly demoralising about that.
I am already managing a neurological condition. I am already navigating symptoms, appointments, medication, work adjustments and the emotional consequences of becoming disabled.
Now I also have to gather evidence, explain my limitations again and prepare to challenge a decision about the support I believe I need.
I have had to think carefully about the evidence that demonstrates my everyday reality, including medical information, accounts from people who know me and records of how my symptoms affect my life.
I am grateful to have people around me who are willing to help.
My husband sees the reality of my MS in a way that an assessor meeting me briefly never could. He knows what happens when I have pushed myself too far. He knows when my legs are struggling, when I need to rest and when something that looks simple from the outside has become difficult.
My MS nurse understands the medical reality of the condition and how its symptoms can affect everyday functioning.
These perspectives matter because disability is not something that can always be understood from a single conversation or a snapshot of one day.
It exists in the routines, adaptations and compromises that make up everyday life.
There is also a psychological cost to appealing.
Every new stage means returning to the same painful questions.
What can I no longer do?
How far can I walk?
How often do I fall?
What help do I need?
What happens when I try to manage without that help?
It can feel as though you are being asked to turn your most vulnerable experiences into evidence.
You begin to question whether you have explained yourself properly. You wonder whether you have forgotten something important. You worry that the person reading your evidence will misunderstand your words.
Eventually, you can find yourself feeling like a liar simply because somebody else has questioned your account.
That is a horrible position to be in.
Nobody should have to feel ashamed of describing their disability accurately.
Nobody should have to exaggerate their difficulties to be believed.
Equally, nobody should feel pressured to minimise them because they are frightened of appearing incapable.
There should be room for the truth, including the contradictions.
I can work and be disabled.
I can have ambitions and need support.
I can be independent in some areas of my life and require assistance in others.
I can have good days and still experience significant limitations.
I can use a walking stick and still occasionally walk without it.
These things are not mutually exclusive.
They are the reality of living with a fluctuating condition.
One of the most frustrating aspects of the benefits conversation is the assumption that receiving disability support means somebody is somehow taking advantage of the system.
There is a persistent suspicion surrounding disability benefits, as though every applicant must first prove that they are not trying to obtain something they do not deserve.
That suspicion can make an already difficult process feel hostile.
It can also discourage people from applying for support in the first place.
I wonder how many disabled people decide that the emotional cost of applying is simply too high.
How many people read the forms and feel overwhelmed?
How many receive an unsuccessful decision and assume there is no point challenging it?
How many are living without support because they do not have the energy, confidence or knowledge to navigate the appeals process?
I do not believe that every unsuccessful application is evidence of deliberate unfairness. Assessments involve rules, evidence and judgements, and disagreements about how those rules apply can occur.
There is a difference, however, between acknowledging that a system needs eligibility criteria and accepting that disabled people should have to endure an unnecessarily distressing experience to access it.
We should be able to have a benefits system that is both accountable and compassionate.
We should be able to assess people’s needs without making them feel that their integrity is on trial.
We should be able to recognise fluctuating conditions without expecting somebody to be visibly incapacitated every day.
Most importantly, we should be able to acknowledge that independence and disability can exist together.
I have worked hard to maintain my independence since my diagnosis.
I have adapted how I travel. I have accepted mobility aids. I have sought adjustments in employment. I have learned to recognise when my body needs rest.
I am still trying to build a life that includes work, education, creativity, relationships and the things that make me happy.
I do not want MS to dictate every decision I make.
That does not mean I can simply ignore it.
My independence requires effort, planning, adaptation and sometimes support.
It should not be used as evidence that I do not need assistance.
There is a particularly cruel irony in the idea that disabled people can become less eligible for support because they have found ways to cope.
If I use a walking stick to reduce my risk of falling, that does not mean the underlying difficulty has disappeared.
If I drive rather than take the bus because walking to and from bus stops is exhausting, that does not mean I have no mobility problems.
If I manage to work because adjustments have been made, that does not mean those adjustments are unnecessary.
If my husband helps me manage daily activities, that does not mean I would be able to do those activities without him.
Adaptation is not the absence of disability.
It is often evidence of how much work goes into living with it.
I think that is something the wider public needs to understand.
When people see a disabled person working, travelling, socialising or enjoying themselves, they often see the result rather than the effort involved in making it possible.
They see somebody getting on with life.
They do not see the calculations, the compromises or the recovery.
They do not see the support systems that allow that person to participate.
Then, when the same person asks for assistance, their visible achievements can be used to question their needs.
It creates an impossible expectation.
We are encouraged to remain independent, but our independence can make our disabilities seem less significant.
We are encouraged to participate in society, but our participation can be mistaken for proof that we do not need support.
We are encouraged to remain positive, but our positivity can make our struggles easier to overlook.
It sometimes feels as though we cannot win.
I do not want to spend my life proving how disabled I am.
I want to spend my life living.
I want to work, teach, create theatre, write, study and spend time with the people I love.
I want to be able to leave the house without worrying whether my legs will manage the journey.
I want to be able to enjoy a day out without spending the following day recovering from it.
I want to have the freedom to make choices based on what I want to do rather than constantly calculating what my body can afford.
That is what independence means to me.
It does not mean never needing help.
It means having the support and resources to participate in life as fully as possible.
I will continue challenging the decision because I believe the impact of my MS deserves to be properly considered.
I know that the tribunal may or may not agree with me. I know that an appeal is not a guarantee of a different outcome.
What I also know is that the decision does not define my disability.
A points score cannot tell the whole story of my life.
An assessment cannot erase the falls I have experienced, the fatigue I manage or the adjustments I have had to make.
A letter cannot change what happens when my legs become unreliable.
The support I receive may be decided through a formal process, but the reality of my condition exists independently of that process.
I wish more people understood that.
I wish we could move away from the idea that disability has to look a certain way before it deserves recognition.
I wish we could stop treating disabled people as though they should be grateful for whatever support they receive rather than recognising that assistance exists to address real barriers.
I wish the process of asking for help did not so often leave people feeling smaller, weaker or less believable than they did before they began.
Above all, I wish the system understood that disabled people are not asking to be defined by their limitations.
We are asking for those limitations to be acknowledged accurately.
I do not want to be reduced to my walking stick.
I do not want to be reduced to my diagnosis.
I do not want to be reduced to a collection of symptoms, medical records and assessment descriptors.
I am a person who happens to live with MS, and that condition affects my life in ways that deserve understanding.
Some of those effects are visible.
Many are not.
I am still learning to accept the changes in my body, and I am still fighting for the support I believe reflects those changes.
I should not have to choose between being proud of what I can do and being honest about what I cannot.
I am disabled enough to need a walking stick. I am disabled enough to have to plan my life around fatigue, balance and mobility. I am disabled enough to have had my independence fundamentally changed by MS. The law recognised my disability the moment I was diagnosed. I only wish accessing the support I need did not feel like having to prove that diagnosis matters all over again.
Whether the benefits system recognises the full extent of those difficulties is still being decided.
My disability is not.
I should not have to prove that I am incapable of living my life in order to receive support that helps me live it.
About the Creator
Millie Hardy-Ashton
I’m Millie Hardy-Ashton, writer, theatre practitioner and PhD researcher. Through personal reflection, humour and honest commentary, I explore disability, accessibility, creativity, popular culture and the beautifully messy business of life
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.