Humans logo

Your Turn or Mine

36 questions built for strangers, asked by two very tired new parents in an Auckland hallway, one night feed at a time.

By Gautam AtmakuriPublished a day ago • 4 min read

At 2:47am our Auckland hallway smelled of warm milk and the dish rack. The baby was heavy on my shoulder, his breath damp against my neck, and the lino was cold enough to make my toes curl. The only light came from the fridge, which my wife had opened so she could read the back of a takeaway menu.

"Right," she said. "Question one. Anyone in the world, over for dinner. Who."

He was nearly gone when I shifted him higher. "Says who."

"Whoever's awake asks. I found the menu, so I'm awake first."

For months we'd spoken almost entirely in logistics. Did he feed. Which side. Where's the cream. Your turn or mine. It was efficient, and it was lonely, and neither of us had said so out loud. Then that evening I'd come home to 36 questions in her handwriting, stuck to the fridge with the magnet shaped like a kiwi.

"You first," I said.

No hesitation. "The woman who ran the tuckshop at my school. You could get a pie and a chocolate milk for two dollars if you said the password before half nine. I never knew the password. I want another go."

Laughing woke the baby a little, so I walked him in small circles, the way we'd learned by accident in week three.

"Your turn," she whispered.

"My mum."

"Obviously," she said.

"She'd hold him for longer than a phone screen allows. She'd tell me everything I'm doing wrong in person, instead of down a crackling line." I stopped walking. "But I'd have to cook. That's the horror. She'd watch me chop one onion and I'd be twelve again."

My wife smiled, the first proper one in a while. Then she shut the fridge, and we were both in the dark.

* * *

I looked it up the next afternoon, while the baby slept in his bouncer and I ate cold noodles out of the pot.

In 1997 the psychologist Arthur Aron and his colleagues published a paper in a journal called Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. Pairs of strangers spent about 45 minutes on 36 questions, in three sets, each set more personal than the last. Afterwards they felt closer than pairs who'd only made small talk. The famous bit, four minutes of staring into each other's eyes, isn't in the study at all. That came from Mandy Len Catron's Modern Love essay in The New York Times in 2015. People mix the two up all the time.

And to be honest, the study was about strangers, and about how close they felt straight after one conversation. Not two people who already share a fridge, who know each other's sighs before getting up at night, who once argued for ten minutes about whether the thing in the freezer was chicken or fish. We were running an experiment with bad controls and no ethics board.

Mr. Mummu from next door would have approved of the paperwork. Last year he bought a big whiteboard for his kitchen and ruled it into neat 45 minute blocks for quality time with his partner. Tuesday, 7pm. Thursday, 6:30pm. Sunday, a double. He wrote "Urgent" at the top, the same word that's on his notebook, which is mostly shopping lists.

None of the blocks ever happened. His partner wrote on the board exactly once, in small blue letters: "Dry the dishes with me."

That one happened every night. I'd see them through the window, him washing, her drying, hardly talking. In spring he wiped the red blocks off and didn't put them back.

Closeness doesn't arrive in the block you book. It comes in small turns, taken by both people.

* * *

The questions got harder. That was the design.

We lost count somewhere around twelve. The baby started teething, which turned him into a small creature of pure grievance, and we weren't much better. Some nights we skipped the question. Some nights we snapped about whose turn it was to be awake, as if either of us was sleeping anyway. The menu fell behind the fridge for three days. I found it when I dropped a cucumber and heard paper slide against the wall. It came out creased and soft at the corners.

By the night we reached the crying one, she was on the couch and I was back in the hallway, the baby finally down after ninety minutes of laps. I read it out, more or less. When did you last cry in front of someone.

Long enough passed that I thought she'd fallen asleep.

"The supermarket," she said. "Last Tuesday. He smiled at the checkout lady. Before he'd ever smiled at me. I stood there holding a pack of nappies and I couldn't stop."

Anything I said would have made it smaller, so I kept quiet.

"Go on. You."

"Video call with Mum," I said. "She was singing to him, a lullaby I half remember from when I was little. The connection went bad and the picture froze on her open mouth, halfway through a note. But the song kept going. I could hear her. I just couldn't see her finish it."

From the couch, in the dark, a hand found my ankle and stayed there.

* * *

On the last night there were no questions left. Only the four minutes from the essay, the part that wasn't in the study. We sat on the couch at 3am with the baby asleep in his cot, and we looked at each other.

It was awkward. I could feel myself blinking. There was a dried patch on her shoulder where he'd been sick, and the fridge hummed through the wall like it was keeping time. At about minute two the baby woke. Not crying, just awake, making the small creaky sounds he makes before he decides how he feels about things.

Both of us turned and looked at him instead.

As far as I'm concerned, that counted.

Next morning the menu was back under the kiwi magnet. She'd added a 37th question at the bottom, the letters cramped from writing in the dark.

"Your turn or mine?"

Over at the bench, with her back to me, she waited for the jug, still in the grey cardigan with the milk stain on the sleeve. I took the pen off the top of the fridge and wrote one word underneath.

Mine.

humanitylovefamily

About the Creator

Gautam Atmakuri

I once spent seven days blindfolded, silent and without food to see what my senses were hiding. I write about that, my baby boy, barefoot running, Tirupati to Auckland life, and the business, marketing and tech I build at AumnI digital.

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Gautam Atmakuri