Feast logo

I'm On a Peppermint Mission

Diary #3 - Finding the Perfect Peppermint Treat

By AnniePublished 8 days ago • Updated about 7 hours ago • 5 min read
I'm On a Peppermint Mission
Photo by Teresa on Unsplash

Hello! This is the third installment of my series that I am calling my "diary" where I write about things inspired by my personal life. These are just personal anecdotes, things that I reccomend, etc.

Introduction🤍❤️

How is there no candy cane or peppermint candy emoji?

I love mint flavors and it is finally peppermint season. I am a strong believer that peppermint should be a year round flavor, not only seen during the holidays. Sure, candy canes can be seasonal-- but wouldn't it be nice to enjoy some fresh peppermint flavors on a hot summer day?

My problem is that nothing is ever minty enough. I want a strong overwhelming peppermint flavor, and I struggle every year to find treats that meet my expectations.

I recently came to a revelation, though. This might be a personal problem. After trying a peppermint dessert and tasting no peppermint, a couple of my friends tasted the same thing and thought it was too minty. It made me realize, do I have some sort of peppermint tolerance?

After doing some very minimal research, I realized that it's possible that my personal threshold for detecting menthol and mint oils may be higher than average. When diluted with other flavors, like coffee, chocolate, or other ingredients in treats, it causes the mint flavor to fall below my threshold.

So... I'm going to log every peppermint item that I try and rate it on a minty scale and on a yummy scale. Because, it may not be minty, but it can still taste good. I also should preface that I love chocolate and will be biased towards that in my ratings.

I'll be updating this periodically throughout the season and hopefully we come across the perfect pepperminty treat. The following ratings are what I have had this holiday season only.

Please feel free to comment recommendations!!

The Ratings - Most to Least Minty

🥇 Current Winner - Haagen Dazs Peppermint Bark Ice Cream Bars

Haagen Dazs Peppermint Bark Ice Cream Bars

These have been my favorites for years and continue to beat out everything else. The peppermint chunks within the chocolate carry the strong peppermint flavor, and the vanilla ice cream within is so light that it assists with emphasizing the peppermint flavor. The chocolate shell on the outside melts perfectly on the tongue.

My only critique is, while I do appreciate it's ability to emphasize the peppermint flavor, I am not a fan of vanilla ice cream and would love to try a version with chocolate ice cream. A personal preference.

🍬Minty - 9/10 / Yummy - 10/10

🥈 Current Runner Up - Iced Peppermint Mocha, Starbucks

Starbucks makes an excellent peppermint mocha. It has the right amount of coffee, chocolate, and peppermint flavor. I also love the additional chocolate shavings that they add. The cold from the iced version emphasizes the peppermint flavor.

My only qualms is that they do too much ice, and I am not a big fan of their whipped cream. This opinion does not effect the rating though, as it is a personal preference.

🍬Minty - 8/10 / Yummy - 10/10

🥉 Current Third Place - Peppermint Baking Chips, Trader Joe's

Peppermint Baking Chips, Trader Joe's

Trader Joe's makes baking chips that are a great minty substitute for chocolate chips in any recipe. We made them in a chocolate based cookie. While warm, the mint flavor did not shine through. However, when cooled down, the peppermint smell was overwhelming (in a good way). Unfortunately, the level of flavor didn't have the same impact as the smell, but they were still surprisingly minty.

The rating below is an average of the scores standalone, warm cookie, and cooled down cookie.

🍬Minty - 7/10 / Yummy - 9/10

🏆Current Fourth Place - Chocolate Peppermint Stick Granola Bars

Chocolate Peppermint Stick Granola Bars

Luna Bars are good and they do a chocolate granola bar base well. The icing on top is where the peppermint is and I like how it is almost an equally noticeable flavor to the chocolate. However, it is not enough peppermint. And, I also am looking for a treat, while this is more of a snack you have when you're hungry and need something small.

🍬Minty - 4/10 / Yummy 6/10

🏆Current Fifth Place - Peppermint Crunch Cracker Cookies (Legally Addictive)

Peppermint Crunch Cracker Cookies (Legally Addictive)

I will be honest. I did not like them. They are crackers that seem to have been carmelized with chocolate and peppermint candies on top. The only reason that they're this high on the minty rating is because of the candies themselves.

But, I dislike the cracker flavor and the cracker texture for this particular treat. I don't like how they claim to be cookies when that's just simply not what they are. I want a dessert, not a cracker with chocolate on top.

🍬Minty 3/10 / Yummy 2/1o

🏆Current Sixth Place - Trader Joe's Peppermint Brookie

Trader Joe's Peppermint Brookie

I love a brookie and I was thrilled when I saw these at Trader Joe's, but the peppermint flavor is not there. If I were blindfolded and someone put these in my mouth, I could tell you that something was different, but would not be able to pinpoint that it was peppermint. It is very subtle.

Having to rate this so low, while it tasted so good otherwise, is sad but it must be done.

🍬Minty - 1/10 / Yummy 9/10

🏆Current Seventh Place - Paris Baguette's Peppermint Hot Chocolate

I do love Paris Baguette, but I don't like their peppermint syrup. It doesn't taste like peppermint, it takes like the essence of toothpaste.

I was disappointed by their peppermint hot chocolate, but the mint was still present. It was just fighting for its life to be there.

🍬Minty - 1/10 / Yummy - 5/10

🏆Current Eighth Place - Paris Baguette's Peppermint Mocha Supreme Croissant

Paris Baguette's Peppermint Mocha Supreme Croissant

This had so much potential. I love Paris Baguette and I love peppermint mochas. But when I tried this, it had absolutely zero peppermint or mocha flavor. Maybe my taste buds were acting up-- because I was so genuinely surprised and disappointed that I couldn't taste either of those flavors (even though I tasted the croissant and chocolate parts perfectly fine).

I did still thoroughly enjoy eating this, as I do love the chocolate shell and the crunch of the candy cane sprinkles on top. But, the filling tasted like nothing and was minimal on the inside.

🍬Minty - 0/10 / Yummy - 7/10

Stayed tuned, as I will keep returning to this post and updating with all of the new things that I try!

Thank you for your time <3

If you want to stay updated:

Subscribe

Holidaylist

About the Creator

Annie

Hello! 🫶 This space is my digital notebook and creative playground. Thanks for stopping by!

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Annie