Second 2020 Democratic Presidential Debate, Part 1 of 2
Winners and Losers
I thought the first part of the second 2020 Democratic Presidential Debate, on CNN last night, was much better than the first part of the first 2020 Democratic Presidential Debate on MSNBC last month. By "much better," I mean that almost every candidate on the stage expressed her or himself better than what we saw last month.
Among the highlights:
- Bernie and Elizabeth Warren were clear, passionate, and outstanding on their view that the avarice of private health insurance means that the best path forward is the government provides all of it. As Bernie said, health care is a human right. (I would add, the government protects us from human parasites, so why not from micro-parasites and lethal cells?) And as Warren said, private insurers are all devoted to maximizing profits, which means taking in as much money as possible in premiums, and keeping expenditures for health care to a minimum. Later in the debate, Rep. Delaney's equation of private pensions and private health insurance was wrong: there is no immoral profit-motive in companies providing pensions for employees.
- Amy Klobuchar was outstanding on the need to finally stand up to the NRA as the only way to get sensible gun reform in America, and stop the massacres.
- Back to Bernie and Elizabeth Warren: Bernie was better than Warren in wanting to cancel all student debt, in contrast to Warren, who wants to cancel 95% of that debt. But good for Warren for being better than everyone else on that stage on that issue, other than Bernie.
- Good for Pete Buttigieg for insisting that all U. S. military engagements (i.e. wars) get Congressional approval, and that approval have a three-year sunset clause. Here's a better idea: how about we follow the Constitution, and insist on a Declaration of War (but also with a sunset clause)?
- Buttigieg also put out an important challenge to all Republicans in Congress: do you want to be remembered as someone who didn't speak up about the racism of Trump?
- Bernie's denunciation of Trump as a "pathological liar" is always good to hear.
- Especially powerful closing statements by Buttigieg, Warren, and Bernie.
As to everyone else in the debate, I thought that Rep. John Delaney spoke the best, and offered the best arguments against Bernie and Warren. But I didn't agree with him. And as for the rest, well, I look forward to not seeing them on stage in the third debate, in September.
See you here tomorrow