
He would be a man on death row.
I wouldn’t know much about him initially, only that he had committed some unspeakable crime and that, for reasons unbeknownst to me, he hated me.
I would visit him to ask why.
He would sit across from me, separated by a thick pane of glass, and offer little more than a look of contempt.
“Have I done something to offend you?”
He wouldn’t answer.
I would spend the drive home dissecting our interaction, wondering whether I had said something insensitive or whether my very presence had offended him.
By the time I arrived home, I would have found several things to apologize for.
I would return the following week.
I would bring him books and ask about his childhood. I would make an effort to understand the circumstances that had led him here, careful not to pass judgment. Perhaps there were things about his life that, if I understood them, would help me understand his feelings toward me.
He would accept my kindness without ever acknowledging it.
I would convince myself that his silence was progress. Perhaps he was beginning to trust me. Perhaps my persistence was making a difference. I would mistake the absence of outright hostility for something resembling acceptance.
Occasionally, he would smile at another visitor. I would watch from a distance, taking note of the things they said and the manner in which they carried themselves.
What did they possess that I didn’t?
I would begin to alter my behavior accordingly.
Some days, I would be quieter. On others, I would try to make him laugh. I would carefully consider every word before speaking, searching for anything that could be misconstrued.
Still, he would hate me.
People would begin to question why I continued to visit him.
“Do you even like this man?”
I wouldn’t know how to answer.
It would never have occurred to me that my opinion of him was of any consequence.
One afternoon, I would read the details of his crimes. I would learn the names of his victims and the horrendous things he had done to them. I would read accounts of the suffering he had inflicted without remorse.
And somewhere between the descriptions of his atrocities, I would find myself wondering what kind of person I must be to have earned the contempt of someone like him.
I would visit him again.
“Please,” I would say. “I can’t fix it if you won’t tell me what I’ve done.”
He would look at me with the same indifference I had come to anticipate.
I would apologize anyway.
I always did.
As the date of his execution approached, my desperation would grow. I would write him letters, some several pages long, attempting to explain myself without knowing what I was defending.
I would apologize for my shortcomings, my insensitivity, my tendency to say too much or too little. I would acknowledge every conceivable flaw in the hope that one of them might be responsible for his disdain.
I would promise to do better.
He would never write back.
On the day of his execution, I would beg for one final conversation.
I wouldn’t ask him whether he regretted what he had done or whether he was afraid to die.
I would ask him whether he could forgive me.
“For what?” he would ask.
And I wouldn’t know.
He would die that evening.
I would spend years trying to understand why a man whose own actions had warranted a death sentence had found something so objectionable in me.
His punishment would be over.
Mine would continue.
About the Creator
A. Bell
I write about the things we don't always know how to say out loud: grief, love, fear, hope, and all the messy spaces in between.
If something here makes you feel, I'm glad you found me.
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.