Humans logo

You Can’t Love Your Friend Enough to Make Her Leave

Nobody tells you how much it hurts to realise that loving someone isn’t always enough.

By No One’s DaughterPublished 7 days ago • 8 min read
You Can’t Love Your Friend Enough to Make Her Leave
Photo by Land O'Lakes, Inc. on Unsplash

Names have been changed to protect the identities of those involved.

Four years ago, my best friend Emily met a man called Mat.

He seemed lovely. Attentive, charming, interested in building a future with her. All the things you would hope for when someone you love tells you they’ve met somebody special.

And I was happy for her. Genuinely happy.

Because that’s what you want for your friends, isn’t it? You want them to find someone who loves them, makes them laugh and gives them the kind of happiness they deserve.

They moved in together. They got engaged. They bought a house.

Emily had spent years saving for a deposit. Mat apparently had savings too, but when it came to buying the house, the mortgage adviser suggested he would be better off clearing his debts.

So he did.

Emily provided the deposit.

I didn’t think much of it at the time.

Then Emily fell pregnant.

Her pregnancy was difficult from the beginning, eventually becoming life-threatening when she developed pre-eclampsia.

She spent weeks in hospital, frightened for herself and her unborn daughter.

Mat visited sometimes.

I remember feeling irritated that he wasn’t there more often, but I told myself it wasn’t my business. Relationships are complicated, people cope differently with stress, and perhaps I was being unfair.

So I did what friends do.

I visited. I brought supplies. I answered the phone.

At just 28 weeks pregnant, Emily gave birth to Lola.

She weighed 1lb 1oz.

A tiny, desperately vulnerable baby whose lungs weren’t developed enough to keep her alive without medical intervention.

Lola spent 13 weeks in neonatal intensive care.

Thirteen weeks of oxygen tubes, monitors, uncertainty and the constant possibility that Emily might leave the hospital without her daughter.

Emily spent every possible moment beside her incubator.

Mat visited sometimes.

I spent hours on FaceTime with Emily, watching Lola grow, listening to my friend cry, trying to offer some kind of comfort in a situation where there really aren’t any reassuring words.

And eventually, against terrifying odds, Lola came home.

I thought that would be the beginning of something beautiful.

Instead, it was the beginning of watching my best friend disappear.

The domestic abuse didn’t look like I expected

Emily was recovering from a caesarean section, caring for a medically fragile premature baby who still needed oxygen.

Lola screamed whenever she was put down. Her doctors had warned against allowing her to become too distressed because of her lungs.

Emily was exhausted.

And Mat was complaining that the house didn’t look like a show home.

He criticised the mess. He criticised the money. He criticised Emily for being on maternity leave when they were struggling financially.

Meanwhile, he was buying himself a new gaming setup and eating lunch out every day.

He wouldn’t change nappies.

He wouldn’t clean up, even after himself.

He installed cameras in their home.

I began to dread the messages Emily sent me.

Not because I didn’t want to hear from her, but because every conversation revealed another small piece of the life she was being forced to live.

My funny, independent, ambitious best friend was wasting away in front of me.

And the worst part?

These were only the things I knew about.

How much more was happening behind closed doors?

I started begging her to leave.

I told her what she was describing was domestic abuse. Financial abuse. Controlling behaviour.

I offered her somewhere to stay.

I promised we would figure everything else out afterwards.

But she stayed.

I watched him take more and more of her life

By Lola’s first birthday, Emily would only call me from her car.

She told me Mat wanted another baby.

She didn’t.

I remember the horrible sinking feeling that came with hearing those words.

This woman had almost died having their first child. Their daughter had spent three months fighting for her life. Emily was barely holding herself together.

And he wanted another baby.

I begged her to leave again.

Then she told me he wanted her to take out a loan to pay off his debts.

I begged her not to do it.

She told me he’d already tried to arrange it, but her application had been declined.

I don’t think I’ve ever been so relieved to hear that someone had been refused credit.

By Lola’s second birthday, Emily had video footage of Mat beating their dog.

And I was still begging.

Except by then, I barely heard from her.

Over the course of a year, our friendship had become something almost unrecognisable.

I sent messages that went unanswered.

Sometimes she’d send a hurried voice note from the car. Occasionally we’d manage a phone call.

She rarely asked how I was anymore.

And that was okay.

I knew she was surviving something I couldn’t fully understand. I knew the person I loved was still in there somewhere.

I didn’t need her to be a good friend to me.

I just needed her to be safe.

Then, finally, she left

One day in August, Emily told me she’d contacted the domestic abuse helpline I’d sent her months earlier.

They were helping her leave.

She and Lola were going into emergency accommodation.

I could have cried with relief.

After years of worrying, pleading, listening and watching, my best friend was finally getting out.

I knew leaving wouldn’t magically fix everything.

I knew there would be practical difficulties, financial problems and probably months of emotional fallout.

But I thought we were finally at the beginning of getting her back.

She moved into the accommodation and told me she couldn’t share the address.

I understood completely.

She was worried about not having basic things like plates and cutlery.

I offered her everything I had spare. We could meet at a coffee shop, I suggested, and I’d bring whatever she needed.

She never took me up on it.

A couple of weeks passed before I heard from her again.

That was okay too.

She had a toddler to look after. She was rebuilding her life. I didn’t expect to be her priority.

Then she told me she’d given Mat their new address.

They were speaking on the phone every night.

And my heart sank.

I tried to explain why this frightened me. Why the boundaries mattered. Why leaving physically didn’t necessarily mean she’d escaped the control.

And then she stopped replying.

My messages went unanswered.

My calls weren’t returned.

We had arranged to see a solicitor together.

The appointment came and went.

Nothing.

She’s alive. I’ve seen her active on Facebook. She’s been reposting videos on TikTok.

But she’s stopped talking to me.

And I think she’s gone back.

Nobody talks about the grief of loving someone experiencing domestic abuse

We talk, rightly, about why women stay in abusive relationships.

We talk about coercive control, financial dependence, trauma bonding, fear and the very real dangers associated with leaving.

We explain that leaving is not a single event, and that survivors may return multiple times before escaping permanently.

I understand all of that.

I know Emily isn’t stupid.

I know she hasn’t chosen abuse because she enjoys being miserable.

I know Mat has spent years systematically undermining her independence, confidence and ability to imagine a life without him.

And I know the responsibility for everything that has happened lies with him.

Not her.

But there’s something we don’t talk about nearly enough.

What happens to the people who love these women?

The friends who spend years holding their breath every time the phone rings.

The people who lie awake worrying about a child they love but cannot protect.

The ones who offer their homes, their money, their time, their emotional energy and every practical solution they can think of.

The ones who spend hours trying to convince someone that they deserve basic human dignity.

We tell women to support their friends through domestic abuse.

And we should.

But what happens when that support starts to consume you?

When every conversation becomes another crisis?

When you have spent years trying to save somebody who keeps being pulled back towards the person hurting them?

What happens when you realise that no amount of love, patience or reassurance can make somebody leave before they are ready?

Because I think I’m there.

And I feel absolutely awful about it.

I love my friend. But I can’t keep doing this.

I don’t want to abandon Emily.

I don’t want her to feel that Mat was right if he’s ever told her that her friends would eventually give up on her.

I don’t want to become another person who disappears from her life.

But I am exhausted.

I’m exhausted from worrying about whether she’s safe.

I’m exhausted from watching her independence disappear.

I’m exhausted from knowing there’s a little girl growing up in a home where violence and control have become part of ordinary life.

And I’m exhausted from feeling helpless.

There’s a particular kind of heartbreak in watching someone you love accept treatment you would never dream of inflicting on them.

You can see their worth so clearly.

You can remember exactly who they were before this person entered their life.

You can imagine the future they could have if they were free.

But you can’t make them see it.

I spent years believing that if I just kept showing up, kept reassuring her, kept offering solutions, eventually my love would be enough to help her escape.

Now I’m beginning to understand that it doesn’t work like that.

And maybe the hardest part is admitting that I have limits too.

Because feminism teaches us to recognise the systems that trap women in abusive relationships. It teaches us to challenge the men who exploit those systems and to stand beside the women trying to survive them.

But surely feminism must also leave room for the women standing beside them to be human.

To be frightened.

To be angry.

To be heartbroken.

To reach a point where they have nothing left to give.

I haven’t stopped loving Emily.

I don’t think I ever will.

If she contacts me tomorrow and tells me she’s ready to leave, I will want desperately for her to succeed.

But I cannot spend the rest of my life trying to rescue her.

And I cannot keep mistaking my inability to save her for a failure of my friendship.

I wish I could tell you that love conquers everything.

That if you support somebody for long enough, eventually they will be free.

That every woman who escapes an abusive man gets her happy ending.

But sometimes you watch your best friend walk through the door to freedom.

And then you watch her turn around.

And all you can do is stand on the other side, grieving someone who is still alive.

I haven’t given up on my friend.

I’ve just realised that I cannot love her enough for both of us to get her out.

I’m crying as I write this because even with this post I realise I’m a liar. If she rang me tomorrow I’d still be there, tired, emotionally exhausted but remembering her as she was and showing up for my friend.

Please leave him Em.

breakupsfeaturefriendship

About the Creator

No One’s Daughter

Writer. Survivor. Chronic illness overachiever. I write soft things with sharp edges—trauma, tech, recovery, and resilience with a side of dark humour.

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by No One’s Daughter