Feast logo
Content warning
This story may contain sensitive material or discuss topics that some readers may find distressing. Reader discretion is advised. The views and opinions expressed in this story are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Vocal.

Make a Wish

T. Holy

By Tristan HolyPublished about 18 hours ago • 13 min read

It was the first birthday cake I had ever attempted. It consisted of six slices of white sandwich bread, ridiculous little gobs of chocolate pudding from the last few cups in the fridge, and lastly, for some reason, a generous sprinkling of crushed potato chips.

Though really every element of the cake could single-handedly garner a raised eyebrow, there was only one that sparked my brother’s suspicion - and that was the fact of it being three weeks early. I had hoped his numerical ineptitude might help me out, but he had remained keenly certain of which box on the calender bore the candle sticker signifying his eighth birthday, and that this empty box in November was not it.

“Ahh, Monsieur! Behold!” I affected my attempt at a French Aristocrat’s accent, “Le Birthday…Surprise!”

He stared up at me with a dubious look. “My birthday isn’t til’ December…” he said, his arms limp at his side.

I gasped, covering my mouth. “Oh no, Monsieur, are ye deaf??”                                                                  ‘Ye’ seemed French to me at 15. I crouched down to speak directly into his ear, “Le birthday…SURPRISE! If it was on your birthday… you would surely expect it. Where’s ze fun in zat?”

He scratched his head.

“You’re lucky we have a table for you, monsieur!” I sang, pulling out the singular barstool by the counter, “we are, after-all, very very popular. Famous even!”

“Then why is nobody here?” he asked plainly, climbing up onto the rickety barstool.

I took in the ambience of our little kitchen. The wallpaper was peeling. Water stains decorated the ceiling. “Because monsieur, zis is a very expensive establishment!”

He accepted this explanation.

I laid a dish cloth over his lap and presented him a menu written on the back of an overdue bill.

“It only has one thing on it,” he said.

“Naturally. Ze dish of ze day, monsieur. Chef’s feature.”

“‘Ze…birthday cake… what’s the next word?”

“Magnifique.”

“You spelled it funny.”

“Monsieur!” I snatched the menu from him, “I’m beginning to suspect you cannot afford to eat at zis establishment!”

His composure crumbled into a bubbly fiz of laughter.

“I’ll have the cake.” He said seriously.

“The only respectable choice, monsieur!” I vanished into what had been mom’s bedroom and re-appeared with a plate, upon which my sat my abomination of a cake.

“What is that?” He asked, not looking particularly impressed.

“Le cake magnifique, of course!”

“Not like mom’s cakes.”

“Better, monsieur! Zis is Chef Élisabeth’s Birthday Cake manifique!”

“Mom makes really good cakes.”

“But monsieur, Chef Élisabeth makes ze best cakes…in ze world!”

He stared blankly at it as I placed it on the counter.

“Is that pudding?”

“No, zat is Crème de chocolat.”

“It looks like pudding.”

“Monsieur please, I am the professional.”

“Are those potato chips?” He giggled.

“It is I who should be laughing at you, monsieur! Zat is a garnish de la…potato.”

“That’s not French.”

“You are not French!” I pointed my wooden spoon at him, and he was overtaken by violent giggles.

He picked up his fork and reached for the cake.

“Not yet, monsieur!” I waved his hand away with my spoon.

We had a kitchen drawer that could never stay closed. In it, was a little yellow flashlight. I flicked it on, and held it up behind the cake.

“Make a wish, monsieur.”

He accepted my attempt at a candle surprisingly eagerly. He squeezed his eyes shut, his intensely thoughtful face beamed warmly in the flashlight’s glow. The image broke me slightly. I turned my face, wiped a stubborn tear from my eye, and regained composure so he would be opening his eyes to Chef Èlisabeth, because regular Elizabeth wasn’t doing too well. When I looked back, his eyes were still squinted shut. He looked deeply serious. Finally, he blew.

I flicked the candle off. “Well done, monsieur!” I applauded ceremoniously.   The first bite made him twist his face. I asked for his strictly professional review.

“One star.”

I clutched my chest. “One singular little star?? For ze MAGNIFICENT Chef Élisabeth??”

“Ok you can have five.”

“Oh merci. Merci.”

“But just because I like you.”

“I like you as well, Monsieur.” The words caught in my throat a bit and I hoped he hadn’t noticed.

Despite his initial expression of digust, he went on to eat all that was on his plate. I had taken a courtesy slice, or heap rather, of my lackluster creation and been moving it around the plate with my fork rather than eating it.

“Can I have yours?”

“Oui.”

“So, you like it, monsieur?”

“Oui, madame.”

His sudden French pulled a genuine chuckle from somewhere inside my chest, then another started up after the first, then another. Before I knew it, I was laughing harder than I meant to. And I just kept laughing. I couldn’t let myself stop. Every laugh was a slipping grip on a fleeting moment. Soon he was laughing at my laughing, next neither of us could stop and neither of us knew why. Finally, it dwindled, like a wave washing ashore.

“Well, can I?” he asked, his words coasting shakily on the inertia of laughter.

“Oh, right…”

I had forgotten his request. This time I couldn’t muster up a laugh. I found myself stalling. I could barely bring myself to pass it to him. Deep down, I think I knew as soon as I passed him the last bit of cake, it would be the end of tonight, and the beginning of tomorrow. I tried to speak, but choked on my words. I turned my face from him again.

“Oui, oui,” I said; my face turned as I parted with my plate, and with it, so much more than I understood.

Our mom had died fourteen days earlier and I lacked the strength to tell Nate. He got scared at night when mom was “away”, and had slept in my bed every night since she’d “left”. That night, when I was tucking him in, he asked why I wore my day clothes. I had said it was because my pajamas needed washing, but the truth was my pajamas were under my bed, already packed, in a bright red suitcase that had been mom’s. Nate fell asleep quickly, still holding onto the yellow flashlight. And because the words had proven too painful to say, he had no idea that in the morning, two strangers were coming to take us to different homes.

I’d already pleaded with the social worker. There was no one willing to take both of us. I’d written down the names of people who’d known our mother. I’d even offered to quit school and get a job. She was exceedingly kind about it all, which somehow made it all worse.

I’m grateful to have since blocked out much of the following morning, but I remember them pulling him from my arms, attempting to comfort us with words that meant nothing. I remember tears. I remember promises we were both too young to know how to keep. And I remember the hall - the hall in which I was led, in one direction, by a woman I didn’t know; and Nate, by another, was taken in the opposite direction. I held mom’s red suitcase. He held the yellow flashlight. I hated my tears because they clouded my eyes and had taken him from my sight before the social workers could. By the end of that hall, everything was blurry, but I could still hear him; an experience that would replay in dreadful dreams for many years.

Twenty-four years later, I was living in Tennessee with a man who had once promised me the world, but with time, apparently decided I was worth considerably less.

His name was Garret. He had once been romantic, once been head over heels for me, once been many things. Now, he went to work and came back; over and over again.

He was also, I suspected, sleeping with a woman named Allison. Or Addison. Something beginning with an A. I would have asked him, but I didn’t care enough anymore to compete with her. To me, she was lipstick stains on laundry; and occasionally a few extra hours to myself. I didn’t prefer it, but I had learned I could endure anything. And in the same way that I contented myself with closing the pornographic websites he routinely left opened on our computer, I could content myself with this.

He would not have considered himself an especially violent man. Somehow, neither did I. In fairness, he had never struck me with a closed fist. As for his fits of weakness, he called them accidents, and to make the marriage easier to justify, I did too.

One particularly miserable Thursday evening while Garret was away, either on business or Allison, I found myself in the bathtub, neck deep in water that had long since gone cold. At my feet, near the faucet, there was a bottle of pills and a razor. I stared at them for a long while. There was nothing tumultuous about this scene. No storm outside. No internal battle. Just cold water, and two ways out of it. Like everything else in my life, I had contended myself with this. I leaned my head back on the tub and spoke plainly to the ceiling.

“Well?” I asked. I don’t know who or what I expected to answer. God? Definitely not. The universe? Since when. Perhaps it was just a cynical invocation for some awesome, ridiculous magic to happen so that it’s failure to do so could be my excuse. “Well? Anything?” I asked the ceiling. “Just one reason?”

 

Silence. Then the faucet dripped. Then more silence. “I didn’t think so.” It was time enough to decide. I chose both. First the pills, then the razor.

 

There was a string of knocks. Then another. From the front door.

I sighed. Garret earlier than expected was not the awesome ridiculous magic I had wished for. “Unbelievable.” I groaned, climbed out of the bath, and clothed myself in a bathrobe. I didn’t bother to dry my hair. The spill of water from it trailed from the bathtub to the front door. There was no more knocking. I looked out the peephole. It was blank. As though it’d been taped over, or something had been left propped against it. My stomach tightened a bit.

“Who is it?”

No answer. An uneasy dread settled in my stomach.

I secured the chain and opened the door a few inches.

There, on my doorstep, stood a man I did not recognize, in an enormous white chef’s hat. He wore a black waistcoat, white shirt, and a spectacular red bow tie.

“Bonsoir, Madame!”

I stared. I knew the voice. Of course I knew the voice.

“Nate?”

“Madame, please. I am Chef Natanaël,” he corrected, drawing out every syllable, “Nat-ta-nyel.”

My mouth fell open.

“Well? Must I prepare your dinner on the porch?”

 I fumbled with the chain.

He entered with the pomp of a king entering a palace.

I just stood there, dripping water.

“Nate, what on earth are you doing here?”

He regarded me gravely. “Madame, it is CHEF. NA-TA-NAËL. I have been informed that you are celebrating a birthday.”

“My birthday isn’t for another three weeks.”

“Oh no, Madame, are ye deaf??” He quoted, directly into my ear, “Le birthday…SURPRISE! If it was on your birthday… you would surely expect it. Where’s ze fun in zat?”

I covered my open mouth.

He winked.

For one bizarre moment, I was fifteen again.

He marched into the dining room, where he set down the silver dome and surveyed his surroundings with exaggerated disdain.

“Oi, putain! The atmosphere is appalling.”

“Well, I’m sorry.” I think I laughed; I was still in shock.

“Merci. You are forgiven.” He drew up a chair for me, “Fortunately, madame, I am prepared to overlook the shortcomings of the establishment.”

“Oh, how generous.” I laughed, taking my seat. When I looked back up, his expression had changed. His eyes had settled upon the fading bruise just beneath the collar of my bathrobe.

I saw him notice. I saw him understand. I knew the question was coming; but he neither acknowledged nor asked. He looked into my eyes and resumed his ridiculous accent.

“Now, madame. I trust you are prepared for the finest dining experience of your miserable little life.”

He lifted the dome. Beneath it was a cake. Six pieces of white sandwhich bread topped with heaps of pudding.

I pressed both hands over my mouth.

“Nate…”

“Patience! It is not yet complete.”

From his coat pocket, he produced a little bag of potato chips. He opened the seal and breathed in the scent theatrically. “Manifiqué.” He sang, rolling his eyes back. He proceeded to dramatically crush the bags of chips with all the ostentatious pageantry of a carnival magician. He then put the bag to his ear and listened. “… tis perfect,” He confirmed. He poured them evenly over the cake and kissed the air. “Voilà!”

I laughed. Then I began to cry. He pretended not to notice.

“Our signature dessert. A recipe passed down through generations of distinguished European chefs.” He bragged, taking his seat.

I laughed harder, wiping my cheeks.

“One star.” I laughed. He recoiled.

“Madame! I have trained for twenty-four years to master this dish!”

“I’m sorry. I’m sorry.”

“But you’re right…it is missing something…” he frowned, “Ah! Yes!”

He produced, from his pocket, a little yellow flashlight.

My heart stopped. My mouth opened, but no words came out. It was old now, its plastic casing worn smooth and cracked along one side. First; he slapped at the switches of several lights along the wall, leaving only the glow from a few lamps. He stood the yellow flashlight behind the cake. Click. It lit up, as it had twenty-four years ago, perhaps with a bit more flicker.

“Make a wish, madame.”

I squinted my eyes shut. My face trembled with the effort of withholding tears. I was back in our old apartment. I could see it, the glow on little Nate’s face as he concentrated on a wish.

“Come now,” he said softly. “We haven’t all night.”

And for the first time in my life, I found myself making a foolish wish with the confidence of my young self. The real me. I didn’t concern myself with practicality. I wished to go back in time. And I blew. And he clicked the flashlight off.

“Well done, madame!” He applauded. I began to sob.

He came around the table and wrapped his arms around me. For a long while, neither of us said anything. Then, against my hair, he whispered in that perfectly dreadful accent: “Madame, you are getting tears in ze ganache.” and I laughed into his shoulder.

We ate the cake. It was bad, but not as bad as I remembered.

“I would like to change my rating.”

Nate gasped, “Please Madame, do not lift my hopes only to shatter them on the ground. Tell me, what is your verdict?”

“Five stars, but only because I like you.” There was a beat of silence as I swallowed a sob and laughed.

“I like you as well, Madame.” He tipped his head on my shoulder.

“Shame about our mutual afflictions…” he continued.

“What?”

“I married a man who turned out to be an asshole. You married a man who turned out to be an asshole. It is a most distressing coincidence.”

I gave a small, embarrassed laugh. “Garret’s not—”

He raised a finger. “Please, madame. I am French. We are experts in matters of love, romance, and the identification of assholes.” I smiled.

“For what it is worth, my own divorce has been delightful. I highly recommend it.”

I didn’t answer. He glanced at the bruise again, but his voice remained light.

“In fact, I have opened a restaurant in New York. I truly am quite the chef. I’ve made nearly enough to furnish my apartment. At least a chair or something.”

“Quite the chef indeed.” I was unsure if he was still in character.

“Indeed. Unfortunately, I find myself in desperate need of a business partner.”

I looked up. He shrugged.

“Indeed… Though, I’ll be needing someone also experienced in the culinary arts.”

He glanced at the cake and back. I laughed.

“Are you asking me to come to New York?”

“Only if madame’s schedule permits.”

I stared at him. At his stupid hat. His ridiculous bow tie. And suddenly, with a terrible clarity, I understood that I did not have to spend another night in this house.

“I’ll go,” I said. He smiled.

“Splendid. We shall make arrangements.”

“No.”

His smile faded.

“I mean now.”

He sat very still, visibly contemplating breaking character.

“I want to go right now, Nate.”

For the first time that evening, he seemed to abandon the performance. His gaze moved from my wet hair to my trembling hands. He understood, I think, that if he asked too many questions, I might lose my nerve. He nodded. Then he stood, and offered me a courtly bow. “Very well, madame. We shall depart immediately.”

I went upstairs. There were a hundred things I could have taken. I wanted none of them. From the back of my closet, I retrieved a battered red suitcase. I packed quickly. Wallet, some clothes, mom’s picture. Then, for the second time in my life, I left a home with nothing but my mother’s red suitcase. But this time, my brother and I were going in the same direction.

I don’t remember much of what we spoke about on the car ride to the airport. All I remember is eventually begging him to break character, and later, asking him if he remembered what he wished for on his early eighth birthday.

“Yeah,” he laughed, “it was silly. I don’t think I really even knew. I just wished for some like, awesome ridiculous magic to happen.”

Holiday

About the Creator

Tristan Holy

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Tristan Holy