Robinson Crusoe
Critique
Defoe's eighteenth century classic tells of a young man who leaves home on a sea-borne adventure that sees him overtaken by pirates, kept as a slave, and eventually marooned for decades on a desert island.
A tale of survival, spirituality, and self-reliance amidst the cruelest elements of nature and humanity.
About the Creator
Cathy holmes
Canadian family girl with a recently discovered love for writing. Other loves include animals and sports.
Reader insights
Outstanding
Excellent work. Looking forward to reading more!
Top insights
Excellent storytelling
Original narrative & well developed characters
Expert insights and opinions
Arguments were carefully researched and presented
Eye opening
Niche topic & fresh perspectives
Heartfelt and relatable
The story invoked strong personal emotions
Keep reading
More stories from Cathy holmes and writers in Critique and other communities.
Every Reality Show Ever
Season after endless grueling season, groups of self-important, horny arrogant brats fight to stay alive in dumbass competitions for the love of money. Yes, money. They don’t really give a damn about the bachelor/bachelorette. They just want to get laid - and to win.
By Cathy holmes9 months ago in Critique
Paddington IV
Michael Bond wrote a fourth in this series entitled 'Paddington At Work' where Paddington learns about various occupations and how to earn some money when he needs it. He visits several locations in order to learn these lessons. Again, in reading this series of children's novels one will see that mistakes will be made but given a chance one will learn and correct what is wrong if given a chance to explain.
By Mark Graham4 days ago in Critique
Vocal & my relationship to publishing traditionally
Ever since my small writing beginnings, when I started writing on Vocal in February 2021, I had been in a truly terrible slump & funk when it came to my writing. I had so many unfinished projects, ideas, half finished manuscripts and first chapters that were going nowhere.
By Melissa Ingoldsby3 days ago in Motivation
Comments (24)
A wonderful critique. You managed to incorporate the themes so well. This book messed me up when I first read it. I was not really a fan, lol.
What did you think of it? 😁
Perfectly done.
Spot on!
Really nice summary and critique! Nicely done!
Great critique...!
Cliff notes of the cliff notes. Well done.
Concise Synopsis , well done
Haven’t read this one yet, but good work. 😊
I can't recall if I actually read the book or if I just know the events that happen 😅 This was an excellent review!
Wonderful work!
Fantastic 💯❤️📝👌
Well done!
Bravo!!! Your critique is fabulous, my friend!!!❤️❤️💕
Thank you. I haven't read that one. I must check it out.
Great critique on on a great book! My favorite Defoe is Roxanne.
Very insightful :) I love this book!
Love your critique, well done!
Very Good Work!! 😊💕
Definitely one of the best critiques I've read, Cathy.
Nice summation!
Honestly, this is a really great description in so few words. Great job.
Haven't Seen this, But Great Job on This Critique❤️💯👌🎬😉😊
Love this novel. Just reread it last month.