Criminal logo

Unveiling the Horror: Inside the Chilling Case of the Scream Killers

A Story Of Murder and Young Warped Minds

By Matthew JackPublished 4 months ago 6 min read
Unveiling the Horror: Inside the Chilling Case of the Scream Killers
Photo by Nik on Unsplash

Let’s explore The Case of the Scream Killers and the shocking murder of Cassie Stoddart. We will delve into the meticulous planning and execution by Brian Draper and Torey Adamcik, drawing parallels to the infamous Columbine High School massacre and raising questions about the influence of the media on impressionable young minds. I have also included the video of the chilling interviews and admissions of these young perpetrators, which will strike a level of fear and amazement in those who watch them.

Overview of the Scream Killers Case

In Bannock County, Idaho, events that seemed torn from the darkest script of a horror movie unfolded. The brutal murder of Cassie Stoddart by Brian Draper and Torey Adamcik not only shattered the serenity of this small community but also cast a long, ominous shadow over the nation’s consciousness. Dubbed the Scream Killers, Draper and Adamcik harbored a sinister fascination with the horror movie “Scream,” drawing a perverse form of inspiration from its narrative to commit their real-life atrocity. Their crime was not an impulsive act but a meticulously orchestrated event, chillingly captured on video as if they were directors of their own horror film, aiming to immortalize their names in the annals of killers.

Also, the parallels drawn between this case and the infamous Columbine High School massacre were not coincidental but rather a disturbing insight into the minds of Draper and Adamcik. They idolized Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold, the Columbine shooters, not as the villains of a tragic crime but as heroes in their twisted narrative, aspirational figures who had achieved the notoriety they so desperately craved. This emulation went beyond mere admiration, reflecting in the cold-blooded planning and execution of Cassie Stoddart’s murder. The Scream Killers case is a harrowing example of the influence of media on impressionable minds and the devastating impact of dark obsessions.

Victims, Perpetrators, and Setting

In the tranquil and remote stretches of Bannock County, Idaho, 16-year-old Cassie Jo Stoddart became the unsuspecting victim of a murderous plot meticulously orchestrated by two of her high school classmates, Brian Draper and Torey Adamcik. The picturesque landscape of the county, known for its quiet life and scenic beauty, provided a stark, almost cinematic backdrop to a real-life horror story that unfolded one fateful evening in 2006. Stoddart, who was house-sitting for a family at the time, found herself at the center of a nightmarish scenario that seemed ripped from the pages of a horror script, transforming an ordinary weekend into a scene of unspeakable terror.

The perpetrators, Draper and Adamcik, were seemingly average teenagers to the unsuspecting eye, blending into the fabric of their community without raising suspicion. However, beneath this veneer of normalcy lurked a dark and disturbing fascination with violence, which ultimately led them down a path of no return and murder. The duo had been planning their heinous act with chilling precision, drawing inspiration from the notorious Columbine High School shooters and the fictional world of horror movies. Their choice of the isolated setting for their crime was strategic, exploiting the solitude and vulnerability of the house’s remote location. This calculated decision amplified the horror of their actions, leaving an indelible mark on the community of Bannock County. Once taken for granted, the tranquility of the area was irrevocably shattered, forever altering the lives of those touched by the tragedy and casting a long shadow over the community’s sense of security and peacefulness.

Planning and Execution of the Murder

The meticulous orchestration behind Cassie Jo Stoddart’s murder by Brian Draper and Torey Adamcik reveals a harrowing level of premeditation that is as shocking as it is appalling. The duo not only compiled a “death list” but also chose Stoddart as their primary target, showcasing a sinister fixation on realizing their gruesome ambitions. Their strategy was chillingly calculated: inviting Stoddart to a seemingly innocuous setting and then severing the power to the home. They manufactured a scenario rife with vulnerability and fear. In the darkness that ensued, they launched a brutal onslaught, stabbing Stoddart approximately 30 times in a relentless attack. This act was not one of impulse but of detailed planning, underscoring a terrifying commitment to their macabre objectives.

The selection of a knife as the instrument of death was not arbitrary. It was a calculated decision aimed to maximize both the physical harm and psychological terror inflicted upon their victim. This choice speaks volumes about the killers’ mindset, revealing a deep-seated desire not just to kill but to instill fear and suffering in their victims. The execution of their plan was not merely a crime; it was a statement — a morbid demonstration of their ability to impose control and exact pain with chilling efficiency. This level of premeditation and the sheer brutality of their actions reflect a disturbing detachment from the sanctity of human life, highlighting the killers’ descent into a realm where fantasy and reality horrifically converge.

Media Influence and Cultural Impact

The haunting shadow cast by the movie “Scream” over the actions of Brian Draper and Torey Adamcik speaks volumes about the powerful sway of the media on young minds. This case brings to light the unsettling reality that the distinction between the fictional world of horror movies and the natural world can become dangerously blurred for some. The killers’ deliberate choice to model their heinous act after the film’s masked murderers, coupled with their admiration for the Columbine shooters Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold, illustrates a disturbing confluence of fiction-inspired violence and real-life atrocity. Their actions thrust into the spotlight the urgent need for a societal reckoning with how violent media might shape the behaviors and thoughts of its audience, particularly those as impressionable as teenagers.


The investigation into the brutal murder of Cassie Stoddart unfolded under the supervision of seasoned law enforcement officials, Lt. Robert Rausch and Capt. John Ganske. Utilizing cutting-edge forensic techniques and relentless detective work, the team unearthed a trove of damning evidence. The most chilling of these were the videotaped confessions and detailed plans of the murder, recorded by Brian Draper and Torey Adamcik themselves. These recordings, where the teens spoke with a chilling lack of remorse and a disturbing excitement about their plans, were a pivotal piece of evidence that led to their swift arrest. Their fascination with becoming infamous, akin to their idols, the Columbine shooters, was laid bare for the courtroom to witness.

Trial and Sentencing

During the trial, the community and the nation watched in horror as the depth of the killers’ premeditation and the cold-blooded nature of their crime were revealed. The evidence presented painted a vivid picture of how Draper and Adamcik had not only plotted the murder with chilling precision but had also sought to document their descent into infamy. Both were convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. As severe as it was, this sentence underscored the gravity of their actions and the irrevocable loss and anguish inflicted upon Cassie Stoddart’s family and friends. The case was a grim reminder of the potential for evil in pursuing notoriety, leaving an indelible mark on the community and the legal system.

Impact on Families, Community, and Mental Health

The ripple effects of the Scream Killers case on the community of Bannock County and particularly on Cassie Stoddart’s family were profound. The community grappled with shock, fear, and a sense of betrayal, prompting discussions on the necessity of mental health support and early intervention for troubled youth. Mental health professionals emphasized the importance of vigilance and support to prevent future tragedies, advocating for a community-wide effort to recognize and act upon potential warning signs in youth.


The Scream Killers case, with its chilling blend of real-life horror, media influence, and the tragic loss of a young life, will continue to haunt us. This case again serves as a grim reminder of the need for awareness, intervention, and the cultivation of empathy to counteract the darkness that can reside in the human psyche and young developing minds.

Interviews By Police

Link to the chilling interview of the killers by police.


About the Creator

Matthew Jack

My 30-year law enforcement career fuels my interest in true crime writing. My writing extends my investigative mindset, offers comprehensive case overviews, and invites you, my readers, to engage in pursuing truth and resolution.

Enjoyed the story?
Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also pledge your support or give them a one-off tip, letting them know you appreciate their work.

Subscribe For FreePledge Your Support

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments (1)

  • Test4 months ago

    The Scream Killers case is a haunting reminder of the need for societal awareness, intervention, and empathy to counteract the darkness that can lurk within the human psyche and to prevent tragedies like this from happening again.

Matthew JackWritten by Matthew Jack

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

© 2024 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.