Journal logo

UEFA has temporarily suspended the use of VAR following controversy surrounding a penalty awarded to PSG for a handball incident against Newcastle.


By Ahnaf Published 5 months ago 3 min read
VAR benched by UEFA after PSG's hotly debated handball penalty vs. Newcastle. 🔴🚫⚽

Title: Deciphering the VAR Conundrum: Unraveling the PSG vs. Newcastle Penalty Controversy

In the fast-paced world of football, where every decision can shape the destiny of a match, the recent Champions League clash between Paris Saint-Germain and Newcastle United has ignited a fiery debate on the use of Video Assistant Referee (VAR) technology. The focal point of contention? A late-game penalty awarded to PSG, propelling the encounter into the spotlight of controversy.

At the center of this storm is Polish VAR official Tomasz Kwiatkowski, whose involvement in the 96th-minute decision to award PSG a penalty has not only stirred emotions but has also prompted UEFA to take swift action. Kwiatkowski, having played a pivotal role in the outcome of the PSG-Newcastle clash, has been relieved of duty for a subsequent Wednesday night match involving Real Sociedad and FC Salzburg. This move by UEFA raises intriguing questions about the acknowledgment of potential errors in VAR decisions and the accountability of officials.

The incident itself unfolded in the dying moments of Tuesday's game, as Kwiatkowski urged referee Szymon Marciniak to consult the pitchside monitor following an apparent handball by Tino Livramento. The subsequent penalty awarded to PSG resulted in a 1-1 draw, significantly impacting the dynamics of the match. However, UEFA's decision to replace Kwiatkowski for a subsequent fixture suggests a recognition of the need for accountability in the aftermath of controversial decisions.

One of the critical aspects under scrutiny is the consistency in VAR decisions. The spotlight intensifies when comparing Livramento's handball to a similar incident earlier in the game involving Newcastle's Lewis Miley. Surprisingly, VAR did not intervene in Miley's case, despite both situations sharing the commonality of deflections off the body onto the arm. This lack of uniformity in applying VAR rules raises legitimate concerns about fairness and the reliability of the system.

Adding another layer to the debate is UEFA's strict enforcement of handball rules, a stance that seemingly differs from approaches in domestic leagues. While deflections off the body onto the arm do not automatically translate to penalties, UEFA's Champions League statistics reveal a markedly higher frequency of such decisions compared to LaLiga and the Premier League. The question emerges: does UEFA's stringent handball enforcement align with the broader objectives and guidelines set by football's governing bodies?

In April, the UEFA Football Board proposed a more lenient approach to situations involving deflections off the body, emphasizing that such incidents should not result in penalties. However, this proposal faced a roadblock due to conflicts with guidelines established by the International Football Association Board (IFAB). The clash between proposed leniency and the established rules underscores the complexity of finding a harmonious balance in officiating the beautiful game.

Delving into the statistical realm, the numbers further illuminate UEFA's distinctive stance on handball penalties. The Champions League exhibits a frequency more than twice that of LaLiga and almost four times that of the Premier League. This stark contrast raises eyebrows and prompts a deeper exploration into whether the higher frequency is a result of more rigorous officiating or if it signifies a departure from the established norms seen in domestic competitions.

As the controversy surrounding the PSG-Newcastle match reverberates through the footballing world, it amplifies the ongoing challenges and debates surrounding VAR decisions. The technology, introduced with the intention of reducing errors and enhancing the accuracy of decision-making, finds itself entangled in a web of complexities that extend beyond the confines of the pitch.

In conclusion, the PSG vs. Newcastle saga serves as a microcosm of the broader issues surrounding VAR implementation. From questions of consistency and accountability to debates on handball enforcement, the incident casts a spotlight on the need for continuous refinement and standardization in VAR protocols. Football authorities face the delicate task of balancing technological assistance with maintaining the essence and integrity of the game. As discussions continue, finding common ground becomes paramount to ensuring that VAR enhances the sport rather than overshadowing its essence.


About the Creator

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights


There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2024 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.