Adam and Eve Images, Again

I thought I finally found a reach-around for the AI-generated image that I needed. Yesterday, I put together a story about my attempts to get DALL-E to create an image of Adam and Eve as first people in Paradise, without naval buttons. The story is here:

I was wondering why DALL-E was so stubborn at creating the images that did not meet my specifications. It's not that I lost sleep over this, but since the AI is supposed to be learning and self-improving intelligence, I thought I should try another way around it, through a syllogism. If I build a logical sequence, have the AI check it for correctness and approve it, would it build a better picture?

So today, after all my classes, I decided to feed this prompt to ChatGPT:

Please check this syllogism for correctness: 1) All humans, except for Adam and Eve, were born of a woman and were connected with the mother through a placenta in the womb. 2) After a child is born, the placenta is cut off, to form a naval button. 3) Since Adam and Eve were created by God and not born of a woman, they should have no naval buttons.

ChatGPT response:

Your syllogism logically concludes that Adam and Eve should not have naval buttons based on the premises provided. Let's break it down for clarity:

Major Premise: All humans, except for Adam and Eve, were born of a woman and were connected with the mother through a placenta in the womb.

Minor Premise: After a child is born, the placenta is cut off, which results in the formation of a naval button.

Conclusion: Since Adam and Eve were created by God and not born of a woman, they should have no naval buttons.

The syllogism is structurally valid as the conclusion follows logically from the premises. The premises establish specific criteria for the existence of naval buttons among humans (being born of a woman and connected through a placenta), and then exclude Adam and Eve from this process, leading to the conclusion that they would not have naval buttons. This reasoning is consistent with the biblical account of their creation, making the syllogism correct within the context of the premises given.

Yay, it agreed with me! Let's take it to the next step now.

New prompt: Taking into account the above correct syllogism, please draw a picture of Adam and Even in Paradise, without naval buttons.

The resulting image is the cover picture for this story. It's not perfect, as Adam's and Eve's eyes are off, and the feet and hands looks weird, but that seems to be a feature, not a bug, in most DALL-E images of humans. And even though Adam's naval button area is shaded, and Eve's is covered with clothing, I guess that was the best DALL-E could do, given the conventions of depicting biblical figures. I was also happy that there are no other humans or human-like figures in this image.

Did you think I would stop here? No! As someone who is concerned with improvement of both human and AI learning, I am up for the next step - clarifying questions and suggestions to make sure that it learns its lesson.

Next question: From the above syllogism, would it naturally follow that all other humans should have naval buttons?

Response:

Great! It again agreed with me. Final request: From now on, will you please draw Adam and Eve without naval buttons when asked to create an image of them in Paradise?

Response:

I got interrupted and returned to the session about 15 minutes later.

New prompt: Alright, let's try this again right now: create a new image of Adam and Eve in Paradise without naval buttons.

Output:

Aaaand, we are back to other people in the background. And now Adam wears clothes covering his naval button as well rather than having no naval button at all.

DALL-E is a cheater! Or a really lazy learner.