Why I Will Never Sugar Date Again

by Evie Donovan 7 months ago in dating

A true account of realizing my self-worth.

Why I Will Never Sugar Date Again

“So, what do you, you know, like?”

“Um, Netflix.”

I stared at him from across the small table, unsure of what else I could say. Did I understand the question? Of course. I’m a thirty-one-year-old woman. I was on a date with a man forty years my senior, with five hundred dollars cash stuffed in my purse. I knew his exact intentions, and yet, I found myself taken aback.

We had discussed payment and boundaries, and a bar on anything sexual was my first stipulation. Throughout the night, he continued to repeat that “he expected nothing but my company.”

We were good.

All clear.

Right?

The bartender must have sensed my distress because within moments he was at our side. I ordered water rather than a jack and coke, a decision prompted by my discomfort. My date noticed.

“I’m sorry, I really don’t expect anything,” he tried, “I just figured you might want to have a few drinks and then, I don’t know, play.”

Play. The images that forced their way into my brain after hearing such words were not for the faint of heart. I could feel the bile rise, and for a brief, glorious moment, I fantasized about projectile vomiting exorcist-style all over the table.

I could feel the bartender’s pity stare from across the bar.

Was it supposed to be so humiliating?

I took a breath.

“I don’t think so,” I spoke in a firm tone. “We made an agreement beforehand.”

“Yes,” he countered, “and I paid you $500. You wouldn’t be here if you didn’t want to be a sugar baby.”

He wasn’t wrong, not in the slightest. I could have said no when I met him. He had found me, as men such as him often do, in a bar. I deal Bar Blackjack for a living, and that night was no exception.

When I caught him watching me as I worked, I could have ignored him.

When he came over to play, I could have been cold.

When he wasn’t subtle about looking at my breasts, I could have done more than button my shirt.

When he feigned interest in my differences, I could have not believed him.

When he asked if I minded older men, I could have said anything but what I did say:

“That depends.”

Don’t ask me why I did. I was newly divorced, and summer in North Dakota means that people are out living rather than playing Blackjack, so work had been slow. I needed the cash, and I had heard of Sugar Babies being successful without so much as allowing their date to hug them goodbye. $500 a day to get leered at as we engaged in pleasant conversation? That’s a no brainer.

When he asked for my number, I could have said no. I imagined a different reality, and now, here I was. I was facing the truth that I, no matter how I tried, could not be a Sugar Baby. Some women ooze sexuality, a talent I wholly admire, but I was just an awkward girl in an even more awkward situation. If I said I wasn’t utterly disappointed, it would have been a bald-faced lie.

I needed out.

I picked up my phone and pretended to scroll as if I had received a notification while covertly ordering a Lyft. I took the time to scramble for something, anything believable enough to save me.

“Oh, no,” I gave my best frown, “I have to go home early. My dog sitter needs me to pick up my dog before she goes to sleep. Her cut off is at eleven, so…”

I doubled-down and locked eyes, praying he would buy it. Judging by the slow nod he gave, and the way his eyes drifted down to the tabletop, chances are he didn’t.

My phone chimed, signifying a real notification this time.

Your driver is ten minutes away!

I sipped my water and attempted to get the conversation rolling once more. One thing I pride myself on, and what I thought I was getting paid for, is being easy to talk to. I studied him.

He seemed to have crumbled, and I felt my heart twinge a little. He had been an absolute gentleman up until tonight, perhaps I had judged him too soon and he was just nervous. We had another date tomorrow, so I tried my best to salvage what could be a great afternoon, and an extra $500.

“So, movies tomorrow? We’re seeing The Kitchen, right? I love horror.”

“You know when I saw you I just thought you had the prettiest mouth.”

Oh, God.

Your driver is five minutes away!

My eyes darted past the uncomfortable bartender and to the door, and I wondered if I made a break for it right then if I could meet the driver halfway down the road.

My date could sense I was two seconds away from fleeing into the night, and it was then he threw all caution to the wind.

“What if I used my mouth or touched your breasts, somethin’?” He reached out and touched one of the tattoos on my forearm, and I recoiled as if I’d been burned.

“Those are pretty. You sure I can’t persuade you to let me see the rest?”

I was done. I could hitchhike if I had to. I stood without a word and thanked him for the evening, immediately cursing myself for thinking he deserved a shred of politeness.

As I headed out the door, grateful to recognize the Lyft driver from my previous ride, I felt a tug on my hand.

Within a second of turning around, his hand was on the small of my back. I was thrown into him, and soon after we clashed, his tongue found its way down my throat.

Since this is a public admission of one of the most mortifying and degrading experiences I’ve ever experienced, I wish I could paint a picture of someone else to hide my shame.

I wish I could say that I emerged a superwoman, and that his ass hit the pavement moments after he dared touch me.

Or maybe a cunning fox, much like the women who do this job on the regular, who could use her charms to turn the tables in her favor.

Whenever I imagined a situation like this, I liked to think of scenarios such as those would play out, and I could walk away feeling empowered. Instead, I froze.

Did I deserve this?

Once he decided he’d had enough, he let me go, and I ripped open the door to the car and stuffed myself inside. I looked up into the rear-view mirror, my lipstick smeared across my face, eyes wet with oncoming tears.

“Well, I can never go to that bar again,” I joked, seconds before the tears overwhelmed me and I sobbed, alone, a complete stranger as my only friend. He said nothing but instead showed his support by stopping by a McDonalds and buying me a McFlurry.

5 stars.

My tears had already started to cease, aside from the occasional sniffle, when a text lit up my phone. It was from him.

No movie tomorrow. Doctor called in sick. I have to go back and cover for him. You are a beautiful and intelligent young lady.

When I arrived home, I replied to the man who had violated my trust and made me feel small in the best way I knew how. I blocked his number, because I knew I didn’t owe him anything at all, and I never did.

I turned on my TV, and with a smile, I queued up Netflix.

I really wasn’t lying when I said I liked Netflix.

dating
Evie Donovan
Evie Donovan
Read next: 'Chocolate Kisses'
Evie Donovan
See all posts by Evie Donovan