Picture Or It Didn't Happen
No One Remembers It That Way
I remember very little from the time we lived in Spokane, Washington. I remember the neighbor owned a Doberman Pinscher, and I remember knowing I needed to be afraid of this dog. I remember my preschool teacher's wave: her hand folding in on itself in a gesture that struck me more than anything I learned that year about numbers or letters. I remember getting frostbite on my feet on Halloween because Sleeping Beauty didn't wear sneakers, so I took my shoes off and walked barefoot in the frosty evening.
I remember a boy lying on the pavement with his face bashed in, adults crowding around in hushed panic. My sister, Jaimee, remembers this, too.
Mother says it never happened.
We did not have much money in those days. I don’t remember this specifically, but the stories confirm it: one car, shared bedroom, baby clothes handed down. Both my sister and I were born medical emergencies (hers far greater than my own), and those emergencies cost money.
Father was working for the Spokane Chiefs. He would have the car during the day, so we would pack up in a red wagon, towels lining the bottom, and walk to the grocery store. Maybe the towels were for our comfort, but more likely they were to protect the food.
I remember one summer day, the food piled into the wagon, when screaming adults stopped us and asked for our towels. A group of kids had been playing on the school playground near our house, and the small one had gone under the playground bars with ease. The older boy, caught up in his chase, had crashed his face directly into the bar, the force shattering bones. I remember Mother screaming. She is not good in panic situations, and she has a shrill, loud sound of fear, anger, or agitation. I remember we couldn't get the towels fast enough, and I remember a stranger laying a towel over the older boy’s face. I wanted to get closer and see the carnage up close.
My sister and I brought this up to our Mother.
She said this did not transpire.
We made it up together.
Picture or it didn’t happen.
Jaimee and I were close. She was the oldest. I am the middle. Nikki came last. Nikki didn’t have any complications at birth, and Mother got to hold her right away. Jaimee and I both agree this is why she is loved the most.
I sometimes think my family operates on separate axes because we never felt at home in the same place. We moved frequently and have different experiences of where we lived. I loved Kansas City and felt like a burgeoning flower. Mother and Jaimee were miserable. Raleigh felt like home to both of them. I started binge eating in my large, barn bedroom.
At different latitudes and longitudes, we became disparate people.
I don’t remember when, in adulthood, Jaimee and I confirmed the playground story with one another. My family has many stories no one speaks of.
Did I become a writer to make sure my narrative wouldn't die?
I have never been a reliable narrator. My flair for the dramatic has always threatened the truth. Maybe, at my behest, Jaimee and I turned this memory into a playground game. Maybe the wagon wasn’t even real. Maybe we always had loads of money. Maybe we were taking a walk, and the Doberman was a Pomeranian and that neighborhood boy, because it is always a neighborhood boy, didn’t insert himself where he didn’t belong. That time. Or the next time. Or the time after that. Maybe if I never started talking about the things we don’t talk about, Mother and I would not have gone more than a decade without speaking. Maybe this memory is safer than the truth.
This essay is not about what happened in Spokane. It is about three girls in one family, with the same parents, who had three separate childhoods under one roof.
We all believed in Santa Claus, until we didn’t. We all believed we were safe, until we weren’t. And two of us remember a boy lying bloody on the playground. Adults know nothing; the towels were just bloody show.
About the Creator
Cali Loria
Over punctuating, under delivering.
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.

Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.