Fiction logo

If the Shoe Fits

Twisted Tango of Moonlight Avenue

By MoonPublished 3 months ago 3 min read

In the heart of a forgotten town, nestled among misty hills, there stood an old cobblestone street called Moonlight Avenue. A place where time seemed to stand still, and where the shadows whispered secrets only the night dared to hear.

At the very end of Moonlight Avenue lived a woman named Agatha. She was known as the "Shoe Witch" by the townsfolk, for she had an uncanny gift for crafting the most exquisite shoes. However, her shoes came with a sinister reputation. Legend had it that if Agatha crafted a pair of shoes for you, you would soon meet a terrible fate.

Despite the ominous tales, there were those who coveted Agatha's shoes. They would come to her door in secret, whispering their desires for the most beautiful, enchanting footwear they could ever dream of. And Agatha, with her piercing eyes and bony fingers, would oblige.

One evening, a curious young woman named Eliza knocked on Agatha's door. She had heard the stories, but she believed she was different, that she could escape the cursed fate that befell others. She yearned for a pair of shoes that would make her the most graceful dancer in the world.

Agatha welcomed Eliza into her dimly lit parlor. With each tap of her fingers on the table, a pair of shoes materialized before them. Eliza's heart raced as she gazed upon the shimmering shoes, intricately detailed and tempting beyond measure.

"Ah, my dear, these shoes will grant your wish," Agatha crooned, her voice like a whisper carried by the wind. "But remember, if the shoe fits, the path you tread will forever change."

Eliza slipped on the shoes, and they fit perfectly, as if they were made for her feet alone. A tingling sensation coursed through her veins, and she felt as though she could dance through the stars themselves.

But with each graceful step, the night grew darker, and the air grew colder. Eliza's laughter turned into pained gasps as she realized that she was dancing not on the ground, but on a thin line between reality and the unknown. Shadows danced around her, and the whispers of the past enveloped her senses.

As the moon reached its zenith, the shoes tightened their grip on Eliza's feet, as if they had a life of their own. She screamed in agony as the ground beneath her turned to shifting sands, and the once-familiar street transformed into a sinister labyrinth.

Agatha watched from the shadows, her eyes gleaming with eerie satisfaction. "If the shoe fits," she muttered, "the path you tread will forever change."

Eliza's desperate cries echoed through the night, but her fate was sealed. The shoes had consumed her, and her dance had become an eternal torment.

From that night on, the townsfolk avoided Moonlight Avenue even more fervently, for they knew that Agatha's creations were not to be trifled with. The chilling tale of Eliza and the cursed shoes served as a haunting reminder that some desires come at a price too steep to bear.

The legend of Agatha and her cursed shoes persisted through the years, a cautionary tale for those who dared to seek their desires at the expense of their souls. Moonlight Avenue remained cloaked in shadows, a silent witness to the twisted tango of fate that had played out on its cobblestone streets.

And Agatha, the enigmatic "Shoe Witch," continued her craft in the darkness, knowing that there would always be those who, despite the warnings, would knock on her door, lured by the allure of beautiful shoes and the promise of their deepest desires.

In the end, it was a dance of temptation and consequence, a dance as old as time itself, where the rhythm of desire led the way, and the footsteps echoed in the eternal night of Moonlight Avenue.

HorrorShort StoryFantasy

About the Creator


Reader insights


Excellent work. Looking forward to reading more!

Add your insights

Comments (1)

Sign in to comment
  • Carol Townend3 months ago

    Beautiful, warm, and affectionate work. This is a very warming read.

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

© 2023 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.