Criminal logo

A Crime?

Legally Criminal Morally Right

By Mike Singleton - MikeydredPublished 3 months ago 3 min read
An AI Nightcafe Creation By The Author

What is a crime? From Merriam Webster, I took this:

Definition of crime

1: an illegal act for which someone can be punished by the government

especially : a gross violation of law

2: a grave offense especially against morality

3: criminal activity

efforts to fight crime

4: something reprehensible, foolish, or disgraceful

This story is intended for a Vocal “True Crime” competition, but is going somewhat off track because I am going for the first option, “An Illegal Act for which someone can be punished”.

For something to be illegal, a law needs to be passed by a government to make that act wrong. Think about that. Literally, any act can be deemed illegal if the government says so.

Slavery has been, and still is in some places legal, so anyone protecting or trying to free a slave is committing an illegal act and is breaking the law and therefore a criminal.

So it’s not just murders, robberies, and the like that are crimes, there are a lot of moral “crimes” that are or have been legal. Today we see governments commit crimes but they make the laws and therefore make what they do legal. We hear time and again “But it’s legal” to which my reply is usually but is it moral? Is it right that a millionaire pays no tax but his cleaner pays 20%, no, but it is legal and therefore not a crime.

This argument and situation can be applied across the board.

So one of the greatest criminals of the twentieth century who succeeded in his crimes was Oskar Schindler who saved the lives of 1,200 Jews which was definitely illegal under Nazi law. If the Nazi authorities (and I am distinct in naming them as Nazi and not German) had found out what he was doing he would have been surely executed under their law as a criminal.

Schindler’s action continually went against the law, breaking it , and making him a criminal, but like any successful criminal he was not caught, and all this came out after he had successfully perpetrated his crimes.

There is a good article on his history here, which is far better than what I could put into words.

Admittedly Oskar Schindler's crimes were humanitarian and extremely brave, although he had been a formal member of the Nazi Party and was hardly a saint, but what they were doing completely turned Schindler, although ironically he had made is fortune on the back of appropriated Jewish business, but was arrested and questioned several times about just favouring Jews, so he was on dangerous, and under Nazi rule, illegal ground.

So Oskar Schindler’s crime actually prevented mass murder, and this story is probably the opposite of what was intended and therefore may not qualify for the challenge, but Oskar Schindler successfully perpetrated a crime, at least 1200 times and saved that many people’s lives rather than being responsible for that many people’s deaths.

There are probably many people in this world who have committed similar crimes and long may such criminality continue. It shows bravery and morality, something that is often lacking the further up the political tree that we look.

I think the point I am pushing here is that just because it is legal doesn’t make it right. You can go back in history to see these types of situations occur again and again. Someone pointed out that when Henry VIII was excommunicated he created his own church and that led to a lot of violence and destruction, but it was legal, so was it right.

What Schindler did was illegal, and criminal, but it was right.

A perfect song for this is “The Dance Alone” by Sting about the “Mothers of the Disappeared” in South America.

how toproduct reviewguiltyCONTENT WARNINGinvestigation

About the Creator

Mike Singleton - Mikeydred

Weaver of Tales, Poems, Music & Love

7(1.1m) ֎ Fb ֎ Px ֎ Pn ֎

X ֎ In ֎ YT (0.2m) ֎ Thds


Call Me LesGina LenaHeatherCaroline


DawnMisty MelissaColleenMa Coombs

Reader insights


Excellent work. Looking forward to reading more!

Top insights

  1. Expert insights and opinions

    Arguments were carefully researched and presented

  2. Eye opening

    Niche topic & fresh perspectives

  3. Heartfelt and relatable

    The story invoked strong personal emotions

  1. On-point and relevant

    Writing reflected the title & theme

  2. Easy to read and follow

    Well-structured & engaging content

  3. Excellent storytelling

    Original narrative & well developed characters

  4. Compelling and original writing

    Creative use of language & vocab

Add your insights

Comments (8)

Sign in to comment
  • Randy Wayne Jellison-Knock3 months ago

    And right now where I live the argument being made by "good Christian folk" is "but they're illegal, so by definition those people crossing the border are criminal & shouldn't be helped at all." An argument I'm sure will begin to heat up once again as we approach another presidential election year.

  • Mother Combs3 months ago

    Powerful piece. Great Points.

  • Alex H Mittelman 3 months ago

    I agree with you. Smoking weed isn’t wrong (as long as it’s done at home in a safe place) and yet it’s illegal, and what an evil German dictator did in the 30s and 40s which killed millions of his own civilians was horrible and disgusting, yet at the time was perfectly legal. So just because it’s legal doesn’t make it right, and just because it’s illegal doesn’t make it wrong. So the law doesn’t always know best and we have to use our own brains!

  • Kendall Defoe 3 months ago

    This should be put on repeat, because too many of us forget that what the powers that be want is not always what is right for society. And we have more slaves on the planet now than at any other time in human history (Iook it up):

  • Holly Pheni6 months ago

    Very good points, Mike! Nicely written, interesting article. Without "lawbreakers" like Schindler and others, even more lives would have been lost. It takes people fighting for what is right in an immoral world.

  • Leslie Writes8 months ago

    You make such a good point here. Well done!

  • Colleen Millsteed about a year ago

    I remember this challenge. Well written my friend.

  • Omg! Vocal had a true crime competition last year? That's my passion!

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

© 2023 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.