Milkshakes and Heartbreak
A Millennial Love Story
It’s been over 10 years since I’ve seen your face and yet sometimes it feels like yesterday.
And while most days I don’t think about you anymore, here I am writing about you like I’ve done so many times before.
Do you remember when we skinny dipped?
Do you remember our first kiss?
Do you remember when we held each other in the rain?
You whispered, “Why does it always storm when I’m around you?”
Our love was so wild that lightning lit up the sky when the Earth answered you.
In our cold Michigan cabin, we held each other tight.
In a makeshift room in Tennessee, we snuggled through the night.
You said let’s get married.
You said let’s start a family.
You wanted it all so much it scared me.
I wasn’t ready to have a baby.
But with you the idea didn’t sound so crazy.
Remember when you carved our names under the stairs?
Sometimes I want to go back to see if it’s still there.
I’d trace my fingers against the grain just to see if it still felt the same.
Sometimes we were shy.
Sometimes we didn’t know why.
Sometimes we laughed so hard we cried.
Sometimes we kissed when we should have said goodnight. The circles under our eyes at dawn betraying another sleepless night.
Late night drives, inside jokes, we even had a college radio show.
Late night walks and late-night talks.
Watching Lord of the Rings and Friends reruns in matching socks.
I loved you at concerts, your arms a protective barrier around my waist, pulling me closer the moment the lights dimmed and the crowd began to cheer in waves.
I loved you during comedy shows, I loved you during plays, each reaching for the other’s hand as we watched the stage.
I loved you when you were sick, I loved you when you were healthy.
I loved you through ups and downs and didn’t care that we might not ever be wealthy.
I loved you when I couldn’t sleep, shivering as your beloved fan blew cold air into the room and onto the sheets.
I loved you when you were wrong, I loved you when you were right.
Sometimes I wonder if our love burned too bright.
Like a shooting star racing across the night.
Is that why we ended without a fight?
No screaming match, no grand betrayals.
The night was unremarkable until you left me. Unexpected. Abruptly.
You walked away as if it was a small thing, unlike the suffocating pain that almost destroyed me.
My friends tried their best to console me.
Midnight milkshakes and fancy dinners dressed to the nines left me feeling lonely.
And yet, my shattered heart continued to beat, betraying me by loving you despite everything.
We got back together, we drifted apart. Each time I wrapped the bandages tighter around my heart. Until it all blurred together and then it fell apart.
I had to move on even though I didn’t want to.
You hadn’t chosen me and now I had to un-choose you.
It was one of the hardest things I’d ever had to do.
Admit defeat and close the door on you.
I’d held it open long enough and yet you hadn’t walked through.
I’d hoped you’d miss me.
I’d hoped you’d realize you couldn’t live without me.
But you didn’t.
I hope it hurt when you noticed I’d gone.
When you realized I hadn’t said goodbye. When you realized I hadn’t bothered with why.
It was an unremarkable day until I realized I could no longer stay. So I closed the door and walked away.
And now time has passed, and you have everything.
With someone who looks a little bit like me.
I wonder if you ever think of me.
If I ever stumble unexpectedly into your dreams.
Do you smile when a song comes on the radio that we used to sing?
Or when a storm blows in and the trees change their leaves?
Do you ever hear my name whispered in the breeze?
Like a barn owl flying through the autumn wheat.
Searching for another heart that beats.
About the Creator
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.