I Can't Quit You (And God Knows I've Tried)
For L.C.’s ROGUE CHALLENGE - A Wanky Song

A Power Ballad for My Beautifully Dysfunctional Self
(To be performed beneath a single spotlight, preferably with a wind machine and absolutely no self-awareness.)
Verse I
I met you in the wreckage
Of another grand mistake.
You whispered, "Just one more time,"
And I gave you all you'd take.
They told me you were trouble,
That loving you was wrong.
But I've been making bad decisions
For so fucking long.
You held me through the deadlines
I pretended didn't exist.
You kissed me with anxiety,
And I couldn't resist.
Pre-Chorus
They say that I could change,
That I could walk away.
But every time I find some peace,
You find a reason I should stay.
CHORUS
(Cue the key change that absolutely nobody asked for)
OH, I CAN'T QUIT YOU, BABY!
YOU'RE THE CHAOS IN MY SOUL!
YOU'RE THE REASON I KEEP DIGGING
WHEN I'M ALREADY IN A HOLE!
You're my beautiful disaster,
My favorite tragedy!
And if there's one thing I do perfectly,
It's fucking up imperfectly!
Verse II
Oh, Procrastination, darling,
How you take my breath away.
You promise me tomorrow
When I needed yesterday.
And Overthinking, sweet obsession,
How you keep me up at night.
You turn a simple conversation
Into seventeen reasons I'm not right.
Then there's my old friend People-Pleasing,
With your soft and tender lies.
You tell me everybody loves me
If I just apologize.
Pre-Chorus
I've tried to set some boundaries,
I've tried to let things go.
But then somebody seems upset,
And suddenly I need to know—
Was it me?
Was it something that I said?
Should I send another message?
Or just rehearse it all in bed?
CHORUS
(Louder, with unnecessary guitar solo)
OH, I CAN'T QUIT YOU, BABY!
YOU'RE THE FIRE AND THE RAIN!
I COULD LEAVE WELL ENOUGH ALONE,
BUT WHERE'S THE ROMANCE IN BEING SANE?
You're my midnight indecision,
My catastrophic flair!
If there's a problem I can't solve,
I'll invent one out of thin air!
Bridge
(The music drops. One tear rolls down a heavily powdered cheek.)
They say love is knowing when to leave.
But darling...
I've never known when to leave.
A conversation.
A bad situation.
A perfectly good argument
That ended three days ago.
I keep your old mistakes in boxes,
Each one labeled with a date.
I take them out at two in the morning
Just to sit and ruminate.
And when the world grows quiet,
When everything is fine,
I whisper, "Surely something's wrong."
And you say, "Of course, my Valentine."
FINAL CHORUS
(Full orchestra, lightning, hair blowing horizontally)
OH, I CAN'T QUIT YOU, BABY!
YOU'RE MY ONE TRUE FATAL FLAW!
I'VE TRIED TO FIND A BETTER VERSION,
BUT I KEEP RETURNING TO THE ONE I SAW!
You're the doubt behind my triumph,
The apology in my kiss,
The voice that says, "You could do better,"
While insisting I deserve all this!
Outro
(A single piano. Bell collapses dramatically onto a velvet chaise.)
So stay with me, my darling.
My beautiful mistakes.
I'll love you through the consequences
Of every choice I make.
And if tomorrow brings redemption,
If I finally learn to grow...
I'll probably overthink it.
And tell myself no.
(One final, impossibly sustained note.)
(Fade to black.)
About the Creator
A. Bell
I write about the things we don't always know how to say out loud: grief, love, fear, hope, and all the messy spaces in between.
If something here makes you feel, I'm glad you found me.
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.