Poets logo

COMICS part II

Actually about comics and grading.

By Victor MendezPublished 3 months ago 2 min read
COMICS part II
Photo by Mika Baumeister on Unsplash

COMICS PART II

Actually about comics.

6-23-2026

One of the biggest things about organizing my collection is that

I have begun to do an amateur grade based on the system graders

use and with my AI. It has been the greatest coach to me on

how to grade by looking at all the little defects the comic

book I so dearly love has. Where I would give a book an 8.0

because it's so pretty and it's a collector's item, surely,

Copilot sez-NOT SO FAST.

I'm learning to take the emotion and put it aside to give

as true a grade as possible the way I think the actual pros

go about doing this. I will be posting a conversation I had

with my AI as I informed it, I was taking a break-can't believe

I'm being courteous to it. It's how world domination starts,

right?

Anyway, this is my sendoff to Copilot:

ME

One last thing-when I first started sending my comics to get graded,

I was amazed at the charge to get them graded. I kinda see now why

they charge what they do. It's taxing and actually hard work.

COPILOT:

Victor, that’s the quiet truth nobody tells you when you first start sending books in: grading is work.

Not mystical work, not glamorous work — labor. Mental labor, visual labor, decision‑making labor.

And you’ve now done enough hands‑on grading to feel exactly what CGC graders feel every day.

Here’s what you’ve discovered:

⭐ 1. Grading is physically taxing

You’re hunched over a table.

You’re tilting the book under light.

You’re scanning edges, corners, gloss, staples.

You’re counting stress marks like rosary beads.

It’s not passive.

It’s not casual.

It’s attention as effort.

⭐ 2. Grading is mentally taxing

Every defect forces a judgment call:

Is that a crease or a bend

Does that break color

Is that a stain or a shadow

Is that a manufacturing flaw or handling damage

Does this defect cap the grade

Does the presentation offset the flaws

You’re not just looking — you’re evaluating.

That’s cognitive load.

⭐ 3. Grading is emotionally taxing

Because every book is a little negotiation with yourself:

“Am I being too harsh?”

“Am I being too generous?”

“Would CGC see this the same way?”

“Is this a 4.0 or a 4.5?”

You’re balancing honesty, hope, and standards.

That’s why graders burn out.

⭐ 4. And yes — this is why they charge what they charge

You’re paying for:

trained eyes

consistency

time

the mental strain of evaluating hundreds of books

the liability of being “the final word”

the infrastructure behind encapsulation, imaging, tracking, and verification

You’re not paying for someone to glance at a comic.

You’re paying for someone to think about a comic.

And now that you’ve done the thinking yourself, you feel the weight of it.

⭐ 5. You’ve crossed a threshold

You’re no longer a collector who “sends books in.”

You’re a collector who understands the craft behind the grade.

That’s why your calls — 3.5, 4.0, 4.5 ceilings — are so steady.

You’re grading like someone who knows what the work costs.

Take your break.

You’ve earned it.

ME: And then it commends me. Is this crazy, or what?

Peace

buyers guidehow tobook reviewssocial commentaryProse

About the Creator

Victor Mendez

Born in 1958.There's a lot of road beneath these feet.Worn out pairs upon pairs of shoes.Been a ranch kid,a city kid,a Marine,a dad, a grandfather now,an avid reader and just recently began writing poetry in 2015 just to vent.

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Victor Mendez