Geeks logo

Book Review: "The Book of Guilt" by Catherine Chidgey

5/5 - one of the finest novels of the year...

By Annie KapurPublished about 10 hours ago • 3 min read
Photograph taken by me

Now and then I try to look for a book where I cannot possibly guess what's going on and for about half of the book I was in a strange fugue state of imagination. I had a ton of theories mainly because I couldn't trust anyone in the novel with the information at hand. Catherine Chidgey writes this book with a cross between the atmospheric and the existentialist, a voice that speaks with a distrust and a shrouded perspective even when it is in first person. We learn as Vincent does in some ways, phrases that show us that something is very wrong within the Sycamore House and perhaps, the children won't be going to Margate after all. But who are these children and why do they live such strange and separate lifestyles to others their own age?

Vincent, Lawrence and William are triplets who live in the Sycamore House. They are raised by three women: Mother Morning, Mother Afternoon and Mother Night. Why are they there? We don't fully know yet. Who are these 'mothers'? At the start of the book, we aren't sure. But there are three books that record the behaviours of these boys and the three different sections of the book are named after these books. The boys' only knowledge is basically reading an encyclopaedia and their dreams are recorded plus a bunch of other weird things that twisted my brain. Oh, and they aren't supposed to interact with anyone outside of the house. This makes it weird when they go outside for 'errands' like buying bread and end up seeing people staring at them with both pity and abject fear. At one point in the book, one of the bakers tells one of the boys that the boy's story has saved the baker's grandchild. But the boy has no idea what he is talking about.

From: Amazon

Catherine Chidgey definitely writes this as a weird line between the conspiracy theorist's idea of what goes on behind closed doors and something that could actually take place and that is what is frightening. There is a character called 'The Minister of Loneliness' who turns up at the Sycamore House to tell the women that the house will be shutting down and the boys will be moved elsewhere. The lack of fight they put up against this immediately raises questions in the minds of the boys, one of which has stopped taking their medication. Well, at least they think it's medication. I'm not going to lie, there's something really dark underneath this book, like something secret is lurking just out of sight, an ethical shadow or a philosophical monster.

Whilst I was reading this book there was something inside of me wondering what was going on for a lot of it. It felt almost creeping and wrong. It was that emotion of dread that underscores the novel, one where the children finally start to catch on to what is wrong, when they start socialising and don't really know how and finally, when the adults around them start to suspect that some of the children may have found out what they are really doing at these houses all over the country. Every now and then, through the haze of these perfectly raised children you will find one or two of them act out and that is when the atmosphere gets thrown off course a bit - it is something worth paying attention to when you finally start to see where the book is going. It feels like a big jigsaw in which you're trying to piece together bits of information from every angle. What is the house at Margate all about? Why are these children here? Where are their parents really? What is being done to them and what are they being raised in this strange way for?

From talks of drug trials to bugs, from violence to allegory, from whispers about keeping the children sick to questions about what happens when one of them stops taking their medication - there are a bunch of questions left unanswered that slowly fold open as the book goes on. It is a deeply unsettling narrative and if you're going to read a psychological horror this year then I think you should read this one. Conceptual and distressing, it preys upon our want to keep children safe - but at what cost do we do that?

literature

About the Creator

Annie Kapur

"Et in Arcadia Ego"

***

I am:

🙋🏽‍♀️ Annie

📚 Avid Reader

📝 Reviewer and Commentator

🎓 Post-Grad Millennial (M.A)

***

I have:

📖 300K+ reads on Vocal

🦋/X @AnnieWithBooks

📸 ThePrancingPonyBakery

🔗 PrancingPonyBakery.com

***

🏡 UK

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Annie Kapur