Criminal logo

“The imposter”

Where is the boy now?

By jt tohPublished 4 months ago 7 min read
“The imposter”
Photo by Chris Yang on Unsplash

Nicholas Barclay, born on December 31st, 1980, was the youngest among his two older siblings. During his early years, he had a relatively ordinary upbringing in San Antonio, Texas. However, as he entered his preteen years, Nicholas began to gain a reputation as a troubled individual.

Reports indicated that Nicholas frequently engaged in physical and verbal altercations with his mother, exhibited truancy from school, made threats towards his teachers, stole shoes, and even committed a burglary at a convenience store. Remarkably, by the age of only 13, Nicholas had already accumulated a juvenile criminal record due to his misbehavior. Additionally, it was alleged that he had acquired three tattoos at a young age, administered by his friends using unsterilized needles.

After being diagnosed with attention deficit disorder, Nicholas's mother reached a point of frustration with the demands of supervising him. Seeking assistance in caring for the young boy, she asked her older son, Jason, to come and live with them.

On June 13th, 1994, Nicholas made a phone call to his home, seeking a ride after playing basketball in his neighborhood. Jason answered the call, but he chose not to awaken their mother, who had been working late nights. Instead, Jason instructed Nicholas to walk home. Tragically, Nicholas never reached his destination.

Due to Nicholas's troubled reputation and history, many were inclined to believe that he had run away and would eventually return. Consequently, when the 13-year-old could not be located, few initially considered the possibility that something had gone awry.

Initially, the theory that Nicholas had run away seemed plausible, given the pending court hearing regarding his potential placement in a rehabilitation center. However, as time passed and Nicholas failed to return, his mother's concerns grew, leading to an eventual investigation into his disappearance.

Despite extensive efforts, months went by without any sign of Nicholas. The only puzzling development occurred three months after he went missing when Jason contacted the police, claiming to hear his younger brother breaking into their garage. However, upon the police's arrival, no evidence of forced entry or any trace of Nicholas could be found. The perplexing question arose as to why Jason would fabricate such a story.

As years elapsed, the Barclay family began to accept the harsh reality that they might never be reunited with Nicholas. However, this case would soon take an unexpected and extraordinary turn, introducing a surprising twist to the story.

In a remarkable turn of events, the Barclay family received astonishing news in 1997, three years after Nicholas's disappearance. They were informed that he had been found alive and safe, bringing immense joy and relief. However, there were certain peculiarities surrounding the phone call that delivered this news.

According to the authorities, Nicholas had been located in Linares, Spain, after being abducted by a child trafficking ring that had transported him all the way to Europe. During his time in captivity, Nicholas had been forced to speak only French and had suffered injuries. Overcoming immense adversity, he managed to escape his captors.

Carey, Nicholas's older sister, traveled to Spain with the purpose of identifying and bringing her long-lost brother back home. However, the reunion did not go as expected. Nicholas exhibited fear towards his sister, seemingly apprehensive that she might not recognize him and potentially prevent him from leaving Spain. The situation added an unexpected layer of complexity and emotional strain to their reunion.

Despite Nicholas initially showing reluctance and wearing a baseball hat and sunglasses to conceal his identity, Carey, his sister, was confident in recognizing him as her brother. They spent time together to reconnect, but Nicholas claimed to have little recollection of his life before his abduction, suggesting that his mind had suppressed those memories as a coping mechanism. However, when Carey showed him family photos, Nicholas displayed moments of recognition, such as inquiring about the well-being of their grandfather.

Before Nicholas could accompany Carey back to Texas, he had to undergo a test administered by the police. They presented him with family photos that Carey hadn't discussed with him, and Nicholas had to accurately identify the individuals depicted. Remarkably, he made only one minor mistake during the test, solidifying his identity as Nicholas. As a result, he was permitted to return home to Texas alongside Carey, bringing an end to the remarkable saga of his reappearance.

Upon Nicholas's return, the Barclay family experienced immense joy, but they were faced with certain perplexing aspects that couldn't be disregarded. The most striking difference was Nicholas's physical appearance. While he had been a blonde-haired, blue-eyed child prior to his abduction, the boy who returned from Spain had dark hair and brown eyes.

Nicholas provided an extraordinary explanation for this discrepancy. He claimed that the individuals who had abducted him had conducted experiments to alter his hair and eye color, intending to ensure that he would not be recognized as Nicholas. Furthermore, his heavy French accent was attributed to the prolonged period during which he was forced to exclusively speak French.

Despite concerns raised by authorities regarding these inconsistencies, the overwhelming relief of having Nicholas home led the Barclay family to actively overlook these discrepancies. In fact, they requested that investigators close the case, prioritizing their joyous reunion over further investigation into the unusual circumstances surrounding Nicholas's appearance.

The involvement of a film crew, documenting Nicholas's adjustment to reuniting with his family, marked a turning point in the unfolding events. It was during this period that suspicions began to arise.

A local private detective, working in collaboration with the film crew, grew increasingly skeptical of the French-speaking, dark-haired Nicholas. Conducting his own investigation, he compared a photograph of Nicholas's ears to earlier pictures and discovered that they did not match. Ears, being a distinctive feature that remains unchanged over time, provided compelling evidence for the detective's concerns. Acting upon his suspicions, he reported his findings to the authorities.

In February of 1998, five months after Nicholas had returned to live with the Barclays, the FBI became involved in the case. They obtained a court order to initiate a thorough investigation, recognizing the need to delve deeper into the perplexing circumstances surrounding Nicholas's identity.

The revelation that the man believed to be Nicholas Barclay was actually Frederic Pierre Bourdin, a 23-year-old French con artist, was a shocking turn of events. Frederic was known for assuming multiple identities and had gained a notorious reputation as "The Chameleon," having adopted over 500 different personas throughout his criminal career.

Despite overwhelming evidence proving that the person living with the Barclays was an impostor, the family staunchly refused to accept the truth. Even in court, when Frederic confessed to his deception and pleaded guilty to passport fraud and perjury, the Barclays remained convinced that he was their long-lost son. Frederic was ultimately sentenced to six years in prison for his crimes.

The revelation raised numerous perplexing questions. The whereabouts of the real Nicholas Barclay remained a mystery, and investigators were baffled by how the Barclays could be so easily deceived. Additionally, suspicions arose regarding the family's behavior throughout the entire incident, with authorities questioning their willful acceptance of Frederic's false identity.

The case presented a multitude of shocking twists, making it a complex and intriguing investigation for those involved.

Frederic's assertions further deepened the controversy surrounding the Barclay family's involvement in the case. According to Frederic, he found it difficult to comprehend why the Barclays had readily accepted him as Nicholas, despite his stark differences in appearance and identity. He claimed that the family was fully aware of his true identity but chose to participate in his ruse, pretending that he was their missing son.

Frederic specifically pointed out Carey's role in providing him with information about the family, including names and details to help him navigate the test conducted by the police. He alleged that Carey had facilitated his passage to the United States. In contrast, Frederic stated that Jason had not accepted him and had shown no pretense, merely wishing him good luck upon their meeting.

These revelations added another layer of suspicion surrounding the Barclays' behavior and their motivations throughout the entire incident. It raised questions about their possible involvement or knowledge of Frederic's deception, prompting investigators to delve deeper into the complexities of the case.

The new perspective provided by the private investigator and Frederic Bourdin added a chilling twist to the case. They believed that the Barclays, particularly Jason, may have been responsible for Nicholas's disappearance and subsequent death. The phone call made by Jason, which initially seemed insignificant, now appeared to be a deliberate attempt to create the illusion that Nicholas was still alive.

However, before investigators could fully explore this lead, Jason tragically passed away due to a drug overdose, which ended any possibility of questioning him further. With no concrete evidence to support the theory of foul play by the family, the case eventually went cold.

Frederic Bourdin, having served his prison sentence, continued his life of identity theft and deception across Europe, leaving a trail of fraudulent activities in his wake.

The real fate of Nicholas Barclay remains unknown, and his disappearance remains a haunting mystery. His story gained significant attention and became the subject of the popular Netflix documentary "The Imposter," shedding light on the intricate layers of deception and manipulation surrounding the case.


About the Creator

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights


jt toh is not accepting comments at the moment

Want to show your support? Send them a one-off tip.

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

© 2023 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.