Criminal logo

Joshua Maddux - "The Body in the Chimney"

Chimney Corpse - Mysterious Death?

By Joshua WilsonPublished 7 months ago 5 min read

"Joshua Maddux - The Body in the Chimney" is a gripping and unsettling story of a young man's mysterious disappearance. When Joshua Maddux went for his usual walk in May 2008, no one could have predicted the horror that would follow.

His body was found seven years later, crammed inside a chimney. The circumstances surrounding his death raise numerous chilling questions about what really happened to Joshua Maddux. In the following, we are going to delve into the strange details of the case, including discrepancies, doubts, and the disturbing potential connection to a violent criminal named Andy Newman.

Joshua Maddux's Disappearance

On May 8, 2008, Joshua Maddux left his house for a walk, as he often did. However, this time he never returned. His family initially assumed he had gone off on his own, seeking adventure or a fresh start.

But as the days passed with no sign of Joshua, concern turned to fear. The eerie circumstances of his disappearance set the stage for a chilling mystery that would haunt the community for years.

The Desperate Search for Joshua Maddux

Joshua's family, friends, and local authorities launched an extensive search effort to locate him. The tight-knit community rallied together, scouring the neighborhood and nearby parkland, hoping to find any clue that could lead them to Joshua's whereabouts.

Despite their best efforts, the search yielded no results, leaving everyone perplexed and desperate for answers. The mysterious nature of Joshua's disappearance only deepened the sense of unease and dread.

The Shocking Discovery

Seven years later, in August 2015, a property developer named Chuck Murphy was demolishing an old wood cabin not far from Joshua's home. As the demolition team began dismantling the chimney, they made a gruesome discovery, a body crammed inside the brickwork.

To everyone's horror, it was later confirmed to be Joshua Maddux. The shocking find raised disturbing questions about how Joshua ended up trapped in the chimney and what had happened to him.

Unraveling the Mystery

The Teller County coroner, Al Born, conducted an autopsy on Joshua's remains, hoping to shed light on the circumstances of his death. However, the findings only deepened the enigma surrounding the case. The absence of trauma, drugs, or external injuries puzzled the authorities.

The revised autopsy report suggested accidental death, murder, or undetermined causes. Conflicting opinions emerged regarding whether Joshua had entered the chimney voluntarily or if foul play was involved. The perplexing details painted a chilling picture of a young man's demise.

Discrepancies and Doubts

The coroner's conclusion of accidental death raised eyebrows among the locals, including Joshua's family and Chuck Murphy, the cabin owner. Discrepancies surfaced regarding the presence of a wire mesh in the chimney, intended to prevent anything from entering.

Chuck questioned whether the mesh had rusted or corroded, while the coroner suggested it had disappeared during the demolition. The unsettling details, such as a torn wooden bar blocking the chimney from inside and Joshua's position in the fetal position with his legs above his head, fueled doubts about the accidental death theory.

The Connection to Andy Newman and His Criminal History

One of the key aspects of the case is the potential connection between Joshua Maddux and a man named Andy Newman. According to anonymous tip-offs and a post on Reddit, Andy Newman was a former acquaintance of Joshua Maddux and had a criminal history involving violent crimes.

The post on Reddit claimed that Andy Newman had been seen with Josh before his disappearance and had a disturbing criminal record, including claims of killing a disabled man and a woman in Taos. However, due to a lack of concrete evidence, the police were unable to pursue the lead further. The potential involvement of Andy Newman in Joshua Maddux's case remains a mystery and subject to speculation.

Criticisms of the Police Investigation

The police investigation into Joshua Maddux's disappearance and subsequent discovery in the chimney has faced criticisms from various angles.

Some locals, including the Maddux family, raised concerns about the initial ruling of accidental death by the Teller County coroner, Al Born. They questioned the coroner's conclusion, pointing out discrepancies such as the presence of a thick wire mesh in the chimney that should have prevented anyone from entering.

Chuck Murphy, the cabin owner, also questioned the coroner's findings, emphasizing that it was highly unlikely for Josh to have climbed into the chimney due to the mesh and other physical barriers. The criticisms highlight the need for a thorough investigation and further examination of the evidence.

Speculations on What Might Have Happened to Joshua Maddux

The circumstances surrounding Joshua Maddux's death have given rise to various speculations. Some theories suggest that Josh may have climbed into the chimney voluntarily, attempting to gain access to the cabin for unknown reasons. But, the presence of physical obstacles like the wire mesh and the unusual position of Josh's body raise doubts about this theory.

Others speculate that foul play may have been involved, pointing to the potential connection between Josh and Andy Newman, the criminal with a violent history. However, without concrete evidence, these speculations remain theories and the truth of what happened to Josh remains unknown.

The Impact of Joshua Maddux's Death on His Family and Community

Joshua Maddux's death had a profound impact on his family and the local community. His family, already grieving the loss of his older brother to suicide, experienced immense shock and devastation upon the discovery of Josh's body.

His sister Kate expressed the disbelief and confusion surrounding the circumstances of his death. The close-knit community of Woodland Park was also affected, as the case raised questions about the safety and security of their town. The tragedy served as a reminder of the fragility of life and the need for answers and closure.

The Aftermath and Ongoing Debate Among Armchair Detectives

Joshua Maddux's case continues to captivate armchair detectives, who analyze the available information, speculate on theories, and engage in discussions about the mysteries surrounding his death.

Online platforms and forums, like the Reddit post mentioned earlier, serve as spaces for individuals to share their opinions, theories, and criticisms of the official investigation.

The Unanswered Questions of the Joshua Maddux Case

The chilling case of Joshua Maddux and the body in the chimney leaves us with more questions than answers. The eerie circumstances surrounding his disappearance, the shocking discovery of his body in the chimney, and the potential connection to a violent criminal, Andy Newman, make it impossible not to be haunted by this chilling mystery. The fact that the police investigation faced criticisms and failed to provide a satisfactory explanation only adds to the sense of unease.

What really happened to Joshua Maddux, and who was responsible for his tragic demise? The case remains shrouded in mystery, leaving us to wonder if we will ever know the truth.


Thank you for taking the time to read this. If you like my writing kindly subscribe, comment and click the heart.

If you found this interesting, you may also like this:


About the Creator

Joshua Wilson

Exploring the unexplored. 🌌🔍🔮

Facebook Account - Joshua Wilson

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights


There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2023 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.