Criminal logo

A Packed Suitcase, a Hotel Key Card, and the Question a Jury Has Not Answered

Prosecutors say a 23-year-old yoga instructor was lured to a Hong Kong hotel room. The defence does not dispute the killing. The trial now turns on premeditation, and on what a story can prove.

By JinPublished 11 days ago • 8 min read

The last ordinary detail is a suitcase. Chow Wai-yin, a 23-year-old yoga instructor known as Aqua, was due to fly to the United States early on 30 June 2022 to study yoga. The night before, two friends came to her flat in Sham Shui Po to help her pack. She seemed excited. One friend left at about 11pm. Another left at about 1am and saw the defendant downstairs. Chow spent that night at her new boyfriend’s home. He left for work the next morning. She left at about 11am, went to a yoga class, had lunch with a classmate, and arranged to meet her boyfriend for dinner before he drove her to the airport. At 4.52pm, she stopped responding.

By then, prosecutors allege, she was inside a room on the 106th floor of The Ritz-Carlton, Hong Kong, in Tsim Sha Tsui, with her former boyfriend, 28-year-old Lo Chun-ming, also known as Alex. The prosecution’s opening statement in the High Court sets out a timeline that turns ordinary city movements into an alleged plan: checking into a hotel, buying a knife, photographing a handbag, ordering takeaway, leaving a room in different shorts. Lo denies murder. The case is being heard by a jury of five men and two women. Prosecutors told the jury that the defence does not dispute that Lo unlawfully killed Chow. The issue, they say, is whether the killing was premeditated.

That distinction is the centre of the trial. It also shapes how the evidence should be read. An opening statement is a map, not proof. The prosecution’s version is not a verdict. The jury will hear the evidence, the defence case, and the judge’s directions before deciding whether the prosecution has proved murder.

The discovery

Chow’s mother reported her missing the next afternoon. She had not boarded the flight. Police went to Lo’s home at 2.43pm on 30 June. He said Chow was not at his residence and that he did not know where she was. At about 9pm, he attended Wong Tai Sin Police Station with a lawyer. The lawyer handed over a key card for a room on the 106th floor of The Ritz-Carlton.

Police went to the room. Outside the bathroom, there was a pool of blood on the floor, bloodstained pillows and bedding, and cabinet doors open on both sides with blood inside and out. Blood was on towels and on the glass door of the shower. The bathtub was half full of bloody water. When officers lifted a towel in the water, they found Chow face down. She was fully clothed and wearing shoes. There were multiple knife wounds on her left hand and back. In the water was a 34cm Victorinox bread knife. In the bin were packaging from Chan Chi Kee Knife Shop, newspaper, Lo’s Louis Vuitton shoulder bag, Chow’s Hermes handbag, and two toothbrushes. DNA from the toothbrushes matched the defendant and another woman, according to the reported evidence. There were shoe prints in blood in the room.

Lo was arrested that night. Under caution, he said, “I understand.” He had a cut on his right index finger. Police found bloodstained Gucci sneakers at his home.

The forensic account is central to the prosecution’s case. A pathologist found at least 42 knife wounds from head to foot, mainly on the left side and back, with wounds penetrating the torso. One wound ran from the lower left back to the left chest and was 15cm deep. The pathologist inferred that Chow was first attacked from behind while standing, then struck while lying on her side. She died from massive blood loss within a day before she was found. A government chemist analysed the scene and concluded that the attack began outside the bathroom, that Chow touched the cabinet doors before falling, and that she was later dragged into the bathroom and placed in the bathtub.

The prosecution’s timeline

The prosecution’s opening statement does not rely on the room alone. It builds a sequence.

On 29 June, the day before the alleged killing, Lo checked into the room at about 1pm for one night. Two hours later, he went to a wine shop in a mall with a woman friend and returned to the room. They left together before midnight. Lo then went to Chow’s Sham Shui Po residence. At about 1am, he and Chow left the lobby. Chow went to her new boyfriend’s home. Lo returned to the hotel.

The next morning, Lo asked the hotel to extend his stay to 30 June. He then went to Chan Chi Kee Knife Shop on Shanghai Street in Yau Ma Tei. Prosecutors say he first asked for a cleaver, then changed his mind and asked for a narrower knife. In the afternoon, he went to Delvaux and Hermes stores. Inside, he took photographs of a handbag and a scarf. Prosecutors describe his manner as calm. They allege that he used the photographs as bait to draw Chow to the room. He then bought McDonald’s takeaway and returned to the hotel with the knife.

At about 3pm, prosecutors say, Lo drove a Mercedes to Sham Shui Po to pick up Chow. At 4.54pm, CCTV showed the two stepping out of the hotel lift. They appeared calm. Chow followed his pace. She stood outside the room for tens of seconds, then went in. Prosecutors say this was the last trace of her alive. At 5.31pm, Lo left the room alone, having changed into another pair of shorts. Prosecutors allege that Chow was already dead. He went out several times: to deposit money, to a convenience store, to a rice-ball shop, and to a bar and restaurant upstairs. He returned to the room twice overnight. In the morning, he asked for another extension. At midday, police questioned him at his home in Lam Tin.

The sequence is built to make calm actions look like steps in a plan. A man photographs a handbag in a luxury store. A man buys takeaway. A couple steps out of a lift and walks to a door. A man leaves in different shorts. These are not dramatic scenes. The prosecution asks the jury to see them as parts of a plan.

The relationship background

The trial has also heard evidence about the relationship. A friend, Elaine, told the court that when Lo and Chow were together, Lo dressed in branded clothes and watches, drove a Porsche and an Aston Martin, and appeared to come from a wealthy family. She also said that after the two broke up in March 2022, she accompanied Chow to hospital for an abortion. She heard Lo say he would cover the HK$40,000 cost but did not have enough money, and Chow advanced it.

A yoga classmate testified that after class on the day of the alleged killing, she had lunch with Chow. Chow was chatting on Telegram with “Alex Lo.” He sent photographs of a Delvaux handbag and a Hermes scarf. Chow said, according to the witness: “Yes, he said he went to buy it for me, and asked me to choose another scarf.” They parted at about 2.30pm.

These details do not by themselves prove motive. They form part of the background against which the jury will assess the prosecution’s allegation of premeditation. Prosecutors say the luxury items were not gifts but a lure. The defence has not yet set out its full account in the reported opening. The jury will have to weigh the evidence.

The legal question

The jury must decide whether the prosecution has proved murder as charged. Prosecutors say the defence does not dispute unlawful killing. The disputed issue is premeditation. In simple terms, the jury must decide whether the killing was planned and intentional in the way the law requires, or whether it was something else. The prosecution’s opening statement points to the purchase of the knife, the extension of the hotel stay, the photographs in the luxury stores, the pickup, the lift, the room, and the defendant’s movements afterwards. It says this was “not a sudden loss of control.”

That phrase matters. The trial will turn on how the jury reads a sequence of actions. A knife bought the morning of the meeting. A room extended for another night. A handbag photographed in a store. A scarf mentioned in a message. A car driven to Sham Shui Po. A lift ride. A door. A man leaving alone. Prosecutors ask the jury to read the sequence as a plan. The defence will ask the jury to read it another way, or to find that the prosecution has not proved its case to the required standard. The court has not ruled on that dispute.

The language of a pending case

Writing about a running trial requires discipline. The prosecution’s opening statement is an allegation. The defence’s case is not complete in the reported account. The jury has not returned a verdict. The defendant denies murder. The presumption of innocence applies.

That discipline also affects how the violence is described. Chow suffered at least 42 knife wounds, mainly on the left side and back, with wounds penetrating the torso. One wound was 15cm deep. The pathologist inferred an attack from behind while she was standing, then further wounds while she was on her side. The chemist inferred that she was attacked outside the bathroom, fell against the cabinet doors, was dragged into the bathroom, and placed in the bathtub. These details are necessary to understand the prosecution’s case. They do not need to be turned into a spectacle.

The same discipline applies to the luxury items. Prosecutors describe the Delvaux handbag and Hermes scarf as bait. That is their characterization. The jury will decide what weight to give the Telegram messages, the store photographs, and the witness accounts. The handbag and scarf are not proof in themselves. They are part of a story that prosecutors are asking the jury to accept.

The tension in the opening statement

The opening statement works through juxtaposition. A young woman packs for a flight. A man checks into a hotel. A yoga class ends. A knife is bought. A handbag is photographed. A car is driven across the harbour. A lift rises. A door closes. A man leaves in different shorts. A bathtub is found half full of bloody water. Prosecutors need the jury to see a chain rather than a series of isolated moments. The defence will test that chain.

The tension sits in the gap between the ordinary and the alleged. Chow’s last day, as described by prosecutors, is filled with the small routines of a life about to change: packing, a class, lunch, messages about a scarf, a dinner plan, a lift to the airport. Prosecutors allege that another routine was being arranged around her: a room, a knife, a pickup, a door. The jury must decide whether the prosecution has proved that arrangement was a plan to kill.

The trial continues. The suitcase was packed for a flight to the United States. The flight left without her. The jury has not returned a verdict.

how toguiltyincarcerationfact or fictionjuryinnocenceinvestigation

About the Creator

Jin

Writer of reamstories

https://reamstories.com/jin

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Jin