The Immutable Playlist
But, there are methods for crossover

I either love a song, or hate a song.
There is very little middle ground in the soundscape of my music tastes, and the chasms that separate Love and Loathe are deep, spanned by rickety bridges, and there are nasty-type demons waiting below, with sharp pointy teeth. Rahr.
If you think it’s hard to get off of Santa’s Naughty List, that’s nothing compared to my Music Loathing List. Two ways to get there, and stay there:
Firstly, the screachy screamies. The outro in Vampire by Olivia Rodrigo, the sound effects in You Dropped a Bomb on Me by The Gap Band. (Yes, I am old. Hush.) Sorry, my ears can’t stand it. Why? Why would you do that to a perfectly decent song? Even the screaming in Hey Jude by the Beatles, and Prince’s proclivities in Kiss and When Doves Cry make me turn down the volume towards the end.
Secondly, awful lyrics. I don’t care how popular the tune is, if they lyrics are demeaning, degrading, or outright outrageous, then they’re off my list.
Easy, right? Except, the rickety bridges exist for a reason, and there are a few that have managed to make the trek into the Acceptable in Small Doses category.
What does that?
A driving beat.
Until a few years ago, that was the only way.
Your Love by The Outfield? Insidious little earworm, misogynistic lyrics, but bleep it that beat! Sigh. The One I Love by R.E.M. can gleefully stay on the Loathe side of the bridge, because it doesn’t possess that driving beat. Phew!
A few will always stay on the bridge, literally, because the only part I like is, in fact, the bridge. Jack and Diane by John Mellencamp, and Red Red Wine by UB40, are two of them. A more recent one is As It Was by Harry Stiles. The bridge is cool, the rest of the song suuucks, for one reason or another.
Another reason to stay on the Loathe side is stupid repetition. (It’s my list, my opinion, I’ll be the arbiter of what defines “stupid” in this particular situation.) Give me a song with clever lyrics, or why did you even release it to an unsuspecting public, and how the heck did it become popular? Like Cheap Trick’s I Want You to Want Me, and the beat isn’t driving enough to save it. Hanky Panky, by Tommy James and the Shondells? Ugh. Stick to Crimson and Clover, folx, still repetitive, but at least there’s a semblance of lyrics in there, somewhere.
Yes, give me clever lyrics! Which is why just about everything that Paul Simon ever did is on the Love side, even if the lyrics themselves are mystifying. Or depressing. Or make me sad. Just call me Al…
But lately, I’ve found myself rocking out to two songs, that beforehand, I couldn’t stand. What gives? Did someone mess with my list… or my head?
Come here, Mr. Brightside, by The Killers. Into the light, where I can examine you minutely.
Repetitive, check. Awful situation, check, but the lyrics aren’t horrible, though the situation described certainly is. Driving beat, okay, I can see how you got onto the bridge. I used to really hate you. Why am I suddenly all okay with you?
Oh, yeah. I may have written a story…
Well, that’s interesting, apparently my writing a fan fic about the plot has changed something in my perspective. Fan fic? No, that’s not quite right. And I’m not justifying it, either. Fixing the plot? Giving it a better conclusion? Perhaps it’s just as simple as I no longer feel guilty about enjoying the song? Or maybe, the tension provided by the song’s story was just too much for me to take, and I want some revenge to go with the tragedy of the situation? (Very likely, that last one, because dangit I want revenge. Don’t you, after seeing all the dumpsters on fire, all around us?)
But that doesn’t explain why I Write Sins Not Tragedies by Panic! At the Disco, has crept onto my Love list.
Horrible story. Awful choices. The beat is okay, I guess, but not enough to get it onto the shaky bridge over the chasm. All you’re left with, is a person who married the footloose chick anyway, and is now getting shih-tzu-faced drunk at the reception. No justice, no revenge, no satisfaction. I don’t want a happy conclusion, but dangit, I want closure.
Why is it suddenly okay enough for me to have it on my Love list?
I mean, come on, Disco Duck by Rick Dees and His Cast of Idiots shows up on my Love list. Barbie Girl by Aqua was on the list long before the movie was even a blip on the horizon. And, surely, not everybody was Kung Fu Fighting, Mister Carl Douglas, yet that song shows up as well…
I can give those a pass, because silly. Add in Pac Man Fever by Buckner & Garcia for the absurdity quadrifecta. What’s my hangup with this one song, whether it’s pro- or anti-?
(Obligatory Chess the Musical reference, it’s a moral imperative. The Broadway Love List is a completely different list, and includes the whole album of each musical. There are a few crossovers if they made the top ten list – looking at you, One Night in Bangkok by Murray Head – but I very much enjoy Broadway in full album doses. Now, back to the essay at hand, because, like Hairspray, You Can’t Stop the Beat…)
Now, this is where it gets weird.
I found the clue in this story.
Ah. It’s about my discomfort with the lyrics, and my attempt at rectifying my love for something about the song, with the questionable morals of the story.
(Can I be any more demisexual? I mean, really!)
I do love Joan Jett and the Blackheart’s I Love Rock ‘n’ Roll. But the lyrics are quite questionable, so much so, that I wrote a closure.
Also on the Love list is Stevie Knicks’ Edge of Seventeen, yet I felt the need to pull this thing from the oblivion of my mind?
So, it’s about my discomfort, not the song. I can’t deal with screeching, no matter how good the song, because it just bleeping hurts my ears. But questionable scenarios, or morals, and I get a strong gut reaction.
Writing stories, or parodies, has given me a way to reconcile my queasy feelings, and at least settle them to a point where I can enjoy the song.
Sorry, Lady Gaga, but Poker Face, for all your driving beat, is not going to make the cut.
Wait a minute...
https://vocal.media/poets/dealt-this-play
Gorammit.
I see. And yes, it’s already sitting there, on my Love list. How. Quaint.
Anyways...
Because I have a germ of an idea floating around my head, for a story based on I Write Sins Not Tragedies. And that’s why I suddenly love the song, because my brain’s working on the rectification. Or parody. It could go that way, maybe? Because sometimes I can’t tell, and something weird but delightful pops out, and now I have to figure out which community to post this strangeness in, without getting laughed off the platform.
Good luck if you stumble across some of them, because I don’t know what to do with my strange children, either.
Don’t worry about me till I do a parody of Walk the Dinosaur, by Was Not Was, okay?
About the Creator
Meredith Harmon
Mix equal parts anthropologist, biologist, geologist, and artisan, stir and heat in the heart of Pennsylvania Dutch country, sprinkle with a heaping pile of odd life experiences. Half-baked.
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.