Trader logo

Your Savings Rate Is a Psychological Number

Why good intentions fail, and the simple design change that nearly quadrupled people's savings

By Kris TPublished 2 days ago • 3 min read

Most money advice treats saving as arithmetic. Work out what you need, divide by the months, put that much aside.

If saving were arithmetic, most people would already be doing it. They are not. The research says the savings rate is set less by calculation than by habit, comparison and the way choices are put in front of us.

Meaning to save is not saving

In one study cited by the economists Richard Thaler and Shlomo Benartzi, employees who said they were saving too little were followed up. Thirty-five per cent said they would raise their savings rate in the next few months. Four months later, 86 per cent of them had changed nothing.

These people were not ignorant. They knew they should save more. They meant to act, and they did not.

The experiment that worked

Thaler and Benartzi then tried something different. Instead of asking employees to save more now, they asked them to commit part of their future pay rises to saving.

The results, published in 2004:

  • 78% of the employees offered the plan joined it.

  • 80% of those who joined were still in it after four annual pay rises.

  • Their average savings rate rose from 3.5% of pay to 13.6% in about forty months.

Nothing about their income, investment options or knowledge had changed. Only the design of the decision had. Each increase came out of a raise they had not received yet, so nobody ever felt their take-home pay drop.

The quiet drift that eats raises

The opposite happens by default. Spending rises with income, and with the spending of the people around us, and absorbs each raise before it can be saved.

Take a worker who starts by saving 5% of pay, gets a 2% real raise every year and spends every raise in full. The amount saved stays fixed while income grows, so after 35 years the savings rate has slipped to about 2.6%. At a 5% real return, they end up with about 4.5 times their starting salary.

Now let the same worker save half of every raise. Their savings rate climbs to about 27%, and they end up with about 18 times their starting salary — four times as much. They never once spent less than the year before.

Why the rate matters more than the return

The savings rate works twice. A higher rate puts more aside each year, and it also means you live on less, so the pot you need is smaller.

Using the common 4% withdrawal rule and a 5% real return, starting from zero:

  • 10%: years until savings can cover spending about 52

  • 20%: years until savings can cover spending about 37

  • 30%: years until savings can cover spending about 28

  • 50%: years until savings can cover spending about 17

At a 50% savings rate, the difference between a 3% and a 7% real return is only about four years. At 10%, it is almost three decades. The higher your savings rate, the more of the outcome is in your hands. These are illustrative calculations, before taxes and pensions, and the 4% rule itself is debated.

More money alone does not fix this. A study of Florida lottery winners by Hankins, Hoekstra and Skiba found that people who won large sums were, within five years, as likely to go bankrupt as those who won almost nothing.

Three ways to go around the decision

You cannot out-will your own psychology every month. You can design around it.

  1. Save half of every raise, automatically. Set it up the day the raise is announced, before the money reaches your account.

  2. Move the saving to payday. An automatic transfer on the day you are paid beats whatever is “left at the end of the month”.

  3. Measure the rate, not the balance. Once a year, divide what you saved by what you took home. A rising balance can hide a falling rate.

The question is not how much you earn. It is what share of it you keep — and whether you have made keeping it the default.

This article is for education only and is not personal investment advice.


Kris Trufev writes practical books about money for ordinary readers. This article draws on his book The Psychology of Wealth.

personal finance

About the Creator

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Kris T