Lifehack logo

The Side Hustles We Look Down On (And Why That's Getting Harder to Justify)

The Side Hustles We Look Down On

By Anniey MillerPublished 7 months ago • 6 min read

There's a version of "making money online" that gets celebrated on LinkedIn. And there's another version that makes people change the subject at dinner. The gap between those two things is mostly performance.

A few months ago, a friend of mine mentioned that she had left her marketing job. Not downsized out — left. Voluntarily. She was vague about what she was doing instead, which is usually code for something she expected me to have an opinion about.

Eventually it came out. She was running a subscription content business. Had been building it on the side for about a year before she felt confident enough to quit. She was making more than her old salary. She was working fewer hours. She was, by every measurable standard, doing well.

My first instinct — and I am not proud of this — was to search for a polite way to seem supportive while mentally filing it under something I would not bring up at a work function.

That instinct is what I want to talk about, because I have been thinking about it since, and I think it says something genuinely unflattering about how most of us have decided to categorize work.

We Have a Respectability Problem

There is a version of "making money on the internet" that has been fully absorbed into professional culture. Shopify stores. SaaS products. Content marketing agencies. SEO consulting. Drop shipping, if it is framed correctly. These things get talked about at business networking events. They get written up in Forbes. The people who do them get described as entrepreneurs.

Then there is another category that produces real income, real businesses, real tax returns — and gets treated like something we collectively agreed not to name directly. Subscription content platforms. Fan communities. Adult content, yes, but also the enormous adjacent universe of fitness creators, culinary educators, independent journalists, and lifestyle documentarians who use the same infrastructure and get tarred with the same brush because the infrastructure has an association people find uncomfortable.

The line between these categories has very little to do with the economics and almost everything to do with aesthetics. What we consider a legitimate hustle is mostly about what kind of person we imagine doing it.

I do not think that is a defensible position anymore — and I think AI is the thing that is finally forcing the question.

What Actually Separates "Real" Business from "That Kind of Thing"

Let me be specific about what my friend was actually doing, because the specifics matter.

She was managing subscriber analytics, tracking retention curves, making pricing decisions based on audience behavior data, producing content on a publishing schedule, handling customer communication at scale, and reinvesting a portion of revenue into content quality. She was running a small media business. The content happened to be personal and lifestyle-focused, distributed through a subscription platform, but the operational structure was indistinguishable from any other direct-to-consumer content business.

The reason she was vague about it is not because the business was doing anything wrong. It is because she has correctly internalized that people in her social circle apply different standards to different industries based on associations rather than substance.

This happens everywhere in the online economy. A man who sells fitness programs through a personal brand and a man who sells fitness programs through a subscription platform with a personal following are doing essentially the same thing. One of them gets to call himself a health entrepreneur. The other one gets the look.

What AI has done to this space is make the operational gap between "legitimate" and "not legitimate" even harder to articulate. The same machine learning tools now running subscriber retention and content performance analytics for a respected independent newsletter are running the same functions for every other kind of subscription content business. The tools do not know or care about the respectability hierarchy. They just optimize for what works.

The Conversation Nobody Wants to Have About Online Income

Here is the part that actually interests me.

The creator economy is now large enough to have genuine income data behind it. Not testimonials — actual research. When you look at that data, the picture that emerges is one where the categories we use socially to rank different types of online business map almost perfectly onto the categories our class assumptions would have predicted — and almost perfectly onto nothing else.

The subscription content platforms that make people uncomfortable at dinner parties are producing, in measurable terms, comparable or better income outcomes than many of the "respectable" online business models. The operators who run them seriously — treating subscriber retention as a metric, thinking about pricing strategy, using the available tools — are building businesses with the same structural characteristics as any other direct-fan revenue model.

The 2024 Creator Economy Annual Report from Influencer Marketing Hub tracked this across categories. Creators using AI-integrated platforms were seeing monthly retention rates around 83% and revenue-per-subscriber figures that would be competitive in any subscription media vertical. The tools that enable this — the same ones that power a mainstream podcast's subscriber analytics — work identically across content categories. Someone building what the industry calls an ai onlyfans business is using the same operational infrastructure as someone building a paid newsletter, because at the business level, those things are the same structure.

The discomfort is not about the economics. It is about the content. And whether content discomfort is a good enough reason to pretend an entire category of legitimate work does not exist is, I think, a question worth sitting with.

What We Lose When We Refuse to Look Clearly

Here is what bothers me most about the respectability hierarchy around online income.

It hits the same people hardest that most economic hierarchies do. The people most likely to be earning real income through subscription content platforms — and most likely to be quiet about it — are people without existing professional capital. People who do not have a network that gets them into consulting roles, or a resume that opens the doors to the "legitimate" version of the same work, or access to the capital that starts a Shopify store the right way. They found a business model with a low barrier to entry and real income potential and they built something with it.

Treating that as something to be vague about at dinner parties is a class position, not a moral one. It benefits the people who already have access to the respectable versions of the same basic economic activity.

This is not an argument that all content is equal or that no distinctions are worth making. There are real differences between types of content and the ethics of various approaches to producing and distributing it. But those conversations are different from the one we usually have, which is closer to reflexive dismissal of an entire economic category based on association.

My friend is not doing anything that requires a polite subject change. She left a job where someone else decided what her time was worth, built something that reflects her actual skills and work ethic, and made more money doing it. That is a success story by any reasonable standard.

The fact that I had to talk myself into seeing it that way is, I think, the more interesting part of the story.

Where This Is Actually Going

The scale of the creator economy makes the respectability question increasingly untenable. We are not talking about a niche anymore. The number of people earning meaningful income through direct-fan subscription models — across every content category, not just the ones that make people uncomfortable — is large enough that pretending the category does not exist requires real effort.

What I suspect will happen, and what is arguably already happening, is that the tools and the income data will force a gradual reclassification. When the operational infrastructure is identical, when the business metrics are comparable, when the income is real and documented — the rationale for maintaining a social hierarchy between "entrepreneur" and "that kind of thing" gets thinner every year.

The AI integration accelerating across these platforms is part of that story. It is much harder to dismiss something as illegitimate when the person doing it is managing subscriber analytics, running A/B tests on content strategy, and optimizing pricing based on behavioral data. Those are the activities we associate with serious business. The discomfort tends to quiet down a little when the vocabulary is right, which tells you something about where the discomfort was coming from in the first place.

My friend, for what it is worth, has stopped being vague about it. She started being specific when she realized that vagueness was protecting other people's comfort at the cost of her own, and that the trade was not worth it.

I think she is right about that.

tech

About the Creator

Anniey Miller

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Anniey Miller