Journal logo

Travel Insurance: When It's Worth It and When It's a Waste

Sometimes it protects thousands of dollars. Sometimes it insures a trip you could have rebooked for free. Here's how to tell the difference.

By Kody CleggPublished a day ago • 4 min read
Travel Insurance: When It's Worth It and When It's a Waste
Photo by Tom Barrett on Unsplash

Travel insurance is one of those things you buy at checkout, in a rush, because the website made it sound like skipping it would be reckless. Sometimes they're right. Sometimes you're paying $80 to insure a $200 flight you could have rebooked for free. The difference is knowing what you're actually buying, because most people have no idea.

Let's start with what travel insurance actually covers. A standard policy covers three things: trip cancellation or interruption, emergency medical costs, and lost or delayed luggage. The cancellation part refunds you if you have to cancel for a covered reason, like getting sick, a family emergency, or a natural disaster. The medical part covers hospital bills abroad, where your regular health insurance often doesn't work. The luggage part pays you for bags that never show up. That's the package. Everything else is marketing.

Now, when is it worth it? The first case is an expensive, nonrefundable trip. If you've prepaid $3,000 for a cruise or a resort and you can't get a refund if life gets in the way, insuring that trip makes sense. You're protecting real money that you would otherwise lose completely. A policy usually costs 4 to 7 percent of the trip cost, so $120 to $210 on a $3,000 trip. That's a reasonable price to protect the whole amount.

The second case is international travel, especially outside the country. Your domestic health insurance often covers very little abroad, and a hospital stay in another country can cost tens of thousands of dollars. A broken leg in Thailand or an emergency surgery in Italy can turn into a bill that ruins your finances for years. Travel medical coverage is cheap, sometimes under $50 for a short trip, and it's the best value in the entire policy. If you're going overseas, this is the part worth buying even if you skip everything else.

The third case is when you're traveling during hurricane season, to a place with unstable weather, or on a cruise. Cruises are especially worth insuring because if you miss the ship's departure, you're on your own getting to the next port, and that can cost a fortune. Weather disruptions are one of the most common claims, and they're exactly the kind of thing that's hard to predict and expensive to fix on the fly.

Now, when is it a waste? The biggest one is a cheap, refundable domestic trip. If your flight is $180, your hotel can be canceled for free up to the day before, and you're driving or flying within the country, what are you insuring? The airline will rebook you for free if they cancel. The hotel doesn't charge you. There's nothing to protect. Paying $25 for insurance on a trip where your total nonrefundable cost is zero is just throwing money away.

The second waste is buying insurance you already have. Check your credit card before you buy anything. Many travel credit cards include trip cancellation, trip delay, and lost luggage coverage automatically when you pay for the trip with the card. Some even include emergency medical coverage abroad. If your card already covers it, buying a separate policy is paying twice for the same protection. This is the single most common way people waste money on travel insurance. Five minutes reading your card's benefits guide can save you $50 to $150 per trip.

The third waste is "cancel for any reason" coverage, or CFAR. It sounds great: cancel for any reason at all and get your money back. But it costs 40 to 50 percent more than a standard policy, it usually only reimburses 50 to 75 percent of your trip cost, and you have to buy it within a couple of weeks of booking. For most people, it's a bad deal. You're paying a premium for flexibility you probably won't use, and even if you do, you don't get all your money back.

There's also a timing trap. You have to buy trip cancellation coverage before something goes wrong. You can't buy insurance after a hurricane is named, after you've already gotten sick, or after your airline announces a strike. Policies also have a waiting period, usually 24 to 72 hours after purchase, before certain coverages kick in. Buying the day before your trip is better than nothing, but buying when you book is how the coverage is supposed to work.

So here's a simple rule. Add up your nonrefundable costs. That's the number that matters. If it's under a few hundred dollars, skip the insurance, or rely on your credit card. If it's in the thousands and nonrefundable, buy a standard policy, and read the fine print on what's covered before you pay. If you're going abroad, make sure you have emergency medical coverage, whether from a travel policy or your credit card. And always check what your credit card already gives you first, because that's free coverage you're already paying for through your annual fee.

Travel insurance isn't a scam. It's a tool. Like any tool, it's great when you use it on the right job and a waste of money when you use it on the wrong one. The trick is knowing which trip you're actually on.

Disclosure: This article was drafted with AI assistance and reviewed by the author.

travel

About the Creator

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Kody Clegg