The Two Annes: Heresy, Witchcraft, and the Proof That Wasn't There
Sovereign Chronicles · History — Anne Hutchinson and Goodwife Glover: heresy, witchcraft, and the proof that wasn't there.

By Sovereign Chronicles
Two women named Anne stand at either end of the seventeenth century in New England. One was banished for heresy in 1637. The other was hanged for witchcraft in 1688. Between them runs the whole Stuart century — civil war, a king executed, a republic, a restoration, and a revolution. Read the records of their two cases side by side and a pattern emerges that neither charge sheet explains: in both cases, the proof was not the point.
THE FIRST ANNE — BOSTON'S HERETIC
Anne Hutchinson was baptised at Alford, Lincolnshire, on 20 July 1591. A midwife and a follower of the preacher John Cotton, she crossed to Massachusetts Bay and held meetings in her Boston home — sixty to eighty people, twice a week — expounding the week's sermons. In November 1637 the General Court put her on trial at Newtown.
What is striking, reading the trial today, is that there was no indictment. Governor John Winthrop opened with a bundle of accusations: that she had troubled the peace, traduced the ministers, countenanced the petitioners of her brother-in-law John Wheelwright, and held meetings "not tolerable nor comely in the sight of God nor fitting for your sex." She demanded specifics. She cited Titus 2 for the women's meetings. She held her ground through the first day. On the second day she said the thing that ended it: that she knew by "an immediate revelation — by the voice of his own spirit to my soul" — and she warned the court of a curse on it and its posterity.
The sentence was banishment, "as being a woman not fit for our society." Her answer has outlived the court: "I desire to know wherefore I am banished?" The reply: "Say no more, the court knows wherefore and is satisfied."
What was really behind it? Three things, and the record supports all three. A genuine theological split inside Calvinism — whether a person's sanctification could evidence their justification; Hutchinson and Cotton's free-grace party said no, and Winthrop's journal lists the "errors" plainly. Party politics: her patron Governor Henry Vane the Younger had been beaten by Winthrop in the May 1637 election, Wheelwright was convicted of sedition and banished days before her trial, and after her sentence her supporters — fifty-eight in Boston alone — were disarmed. And fear of England: Archbishop Laud's commission was demanding the colony's charter back, and a colony under scrutiny for heresy was a colony in danger. That anxiety is never named in her trial, but it hangs over everything Winthrop later wrote about it.
One label deserves unpicking. Winthrop's account of the controversy brands her party "Antinomians, Familists and Libertines" — and "Familist," a member of the Family of Love, has stuck to her name ever since. There is no evidence Anne Hutchinson belonged to the Family of Love or held its doctrines. The court's own theologians argued that her premises led toward Familist conclusions while conceding she had not lived them. The word was a weapon, not a description.
Cotton, her mentor, reconciled himself with the synod, admonished her at her church trial, supervised her recantation — and then let her be excommunicated in March 1638. She settled at Portsmouth on Aquidneck Island, and, fearing Massachusetts would swallow Rhode Island, moved in 1642 into Dutch territory at Pelham Bay. In August 1643, during Kieft's War, Siwanoy warriors killed her, six of her children, and her household. Only her nine-year-old daughter Susanna survived, taken captive and later returned.
THE SECOND ANNE — BOSTON'S WITCH
Fifty-one years later, Boston hanged another woman — and Boston had not executed a witch in thirty-two years.
The first correction is her name. No contemporary source calls her Ann. She is Goodwife Glover, the widow Glover, in every record of her own time. The name "Ann" — and much of the story now attached to her, including her transportation from Ireland to Barbados in Cromwell's time — enters print centuries later: speculation in 1872, converted into certainty in 1905 by a writer who fabricated quotations to support it. Cromwell's transportations of the Irish to Barbados were real. Her place in them is not documented anywhere in the sources of her own century. There is no trial record of her case at all.
The second correction is her part in it. On Cotton Mather's own account, the Goodwin family's washerwoman was Glover's daughter. Martha Goodwin, thirteen, accused the daughter over missing linen in the summer of 1688. The mother came in and, in Mather's words, "bestow'd very bad Language" — and Martha fell into fits "beyond epilepsie or catalepsie." Within weeks her sister and two brothers were seized too, and the family physician declared it "nothing but an hellish witchcraft."
What did the court actually have? Mather himself concedes that "Goodwin had no proof that could have done her any Hurt." The rest of the package, item by item: a confession that survives only in Mather's paraphrase, taken through two unnamed interpreters — the court, he writes, "could receive Answers from her in none but the Irish," though he claims she understood English well. A Lord's Prayer test, prompted clause by clause, in which she stumbled — while reciting the Pater noster in Latin "very readily," missing only a clause or two, in the manner of Catholic devotion, not ignorance. Rag puppets found in her house, which Mather says she acknowledged using to torment. A deathbed accusation some six years old, relayed at second hand. And a board of physicians appointed to test whether she was "craz'd in her Intellectuals" — they returned her sane, compos mentis, which settled only that she could be executed, not that she was guilty.
Twelve years later Robert Calef wrote the verdict the evidence deserved: "The proof against her was wholly deficient. The jury brought her guilty. She was hung. She died a Catholic." Calef also charged that Mather — who visited Glover in prison, took Martha Goodwin into his own home, and published the case in 1689 as a weapon against doubters — was "most active and forward" in matters that "conduced much to the kindling those flames" of 1692.
Judge Samuel Sewall's diary is the only source that dates her death: 16 November 1688. "The Widow Glover is drawn by to be hang'd." She was tried under the Dominion of New England, Governor Edmund Andros's charterless royal government — eleven days after William of Orange landed in England to take James II's throne, though no word of it could yet have crossed the Atlantic. The regime that hanged her fell the following April, when Boston rose and arrested Andros. Historians still argue the weighting — whether she was destroyed mainly because Boston sincerely believed her a witch, or because every trait that made her readable as one was the trait of an Irish Catholic servant-class outsider, a widow with no defender. No historian defends the verdict.
WHAT CHANGED BETWEEN THEM
In 1637 a self-governing Puritan colony banished one of its own — a high-status insider, a minister's protégée — to prove to England that it could police its orthodoxy. In 1688 a royal government imposed from London hanged an outsider under an established capital statute, on evidence assembled from afflicted children, physicians ruling by exclusion, and a confession no one could independently check. The machinery had professionalised; the standard of proof had not.
And the two cases are joined by a book. Mather's Memorable Providences of 1689 — the Glover case, published to "confute the Saducism of this debauched Age" — became the template: the afflicted children, the fits, the instrument of the devil identified and destroyed. Four years later Salem ran on it, in a colony once again between charters. Anne Hutchinson was accused of knowing too much by revelation. Goodwife Glover was accused by children in fits, in a language her judges could not understand. The charges differ. The structure is the same: a woman whose knowledge, faith, or tongue sat outside the sanctioned frame — and a court that knew wherefore, and was satisfied.
This study began with the House's name research — a Jane Martin, a miller's wife, hanged for witchcraft at Newcastle in 1650, her name preserved in the parish register — and the names have a way of leading where the charges do not. The Gazette keeps the receipts.
About the Creator
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.