Visiting Ebenezer
A Refreshing Reminder That Sometimes the Original Story Is Enough
There is something wonderfully refreshing about watching a film that understands the strength of its source material and doesn’t feel the need to reinvent it simply for the sake of being different.
As a film scholar, I have spent a great deal of time examining how stories evolve when they move between mediums, how filmmakers reinterpret familiar narratives, and how audiences respond to adaptations of stories they already know. I am certainly not opposed to creative reinterpretation. Some of the most fascinating films are those that take familiar material and invite us to see it through an entirely different lens. However, there is an increasingly familiar tendency in contemporary filmmaking to treat originality as synonymous with changing things, even when those changes add very little to the story being told.
This is why Ebenezer felt like such a welcome change.
Rather than attempting to distance itself from the foundations of Charles Dickens’s A Christmas Carol, the film embraces what has made the story so enduring. It recognises that the original material already contains everything a filmmaker could want: a deeply flawed protagonist, a powerful moral journey, supernatural encounters, psychological torment and the unsettling idea that we might be forced to confront the consequences of our own actions.
In many respects, A Christmas Carol has always been a ghost story first and a Christmas story second. Dickens understood the power of fear as a means of provoking reflection, and it is wonderful to see a film that appreciates those darker foundations.
There is a misconception that fidelity to source material somehow limits creativity. In reality, adaptation is an art form in its own right, and remaining faithful to an existing narrative does not mean abandoning artistic expression.
The creative challenge simply changes.
Rather than asking what can be altered, the filmmaker must consider how the original story can be communicated through the unique language of cinema. How can a moment described in prose become visually unsettling? How can a character’s internal conflict be expressed through performance, lighting or composition? How can the audience experience a familiar supernatural encounter as though they are seeing it for the first time?
These are fascinating questions, and they are far more interesting to me than changing established material simply to create the illusion of innovation.
There is also something to be said for trusting the audience. We do not always need a surprising twist, an unexpected character motivation or a dramatically rewritten ending to remain engaged with a story. Sometimes the pleasure of an adaptation lies in recognising the narrative while appreciating the craft of its presentation.
We know where Scrooge’s journey is going. That does not mean we cannot enjoy the journey.
One of the things I appreciated most about Ebenezer was its use of physical effects.
We live in an age in which digital technology has given filmmakers almost limitless creative possibilities. CGI can create entire worlds, manipulate performances and bring the seemingly impossible to life. There is undoubtedly a place for it within contemporary cinema, and it would be foolish to dismiss the extraordinary work of digital effects artists.
However, there is something about practical effects that digital imagery can struggle to replicate: the sense that something genuinely occupies the same physical space as the actors.
Physical effects interact with light, shadow, texture and movement in ways that give them a tangible quality. They provide performers with something to respond to, and they can make supernatural encounters feel more immediate.
This is especially important in horror.
The genre relies heavily upon the audience’s willingness to believe that what they are seeing might, within the reality of the film, actually exist. The more convincing that physical presence becomes, the easier it is to suspend disbelief.
Practical effects also carry a wonderful sense of cinematic craftsmanship. There is something immensely satisfying about recognising that an effect has been achieved through physical construction, performance, lighting or carefully controlled camera work.
It reminds us that cinema is not simply about what can be created on a computer. It is about what can be achieved when artists understand the tools available to them.
In a supernatural story rooted in Victorian Gothic traditions, this approach feels especially appropriate. The physicality of the effects complements the atmosphere of the narrative rather than overwhelming it.
Perhaps my favourite aspect of Ebenezer was its understanding of the fundamental rules of horror filmmaking.
I found myself watching with my film scholar’s brain fully engaged, appreciating the use of camera angles, movement and composition to establish tension.
Horror is an especially interesting genre to study because so much of its effectiveness depends upon the relationship between what the audience can see and what they believe might be there.
A carefully composed frame can create unease without showing anything frightening at all. A slow pan can encourage us to search the image for something that may never appear. A low camera angle can give a character an imposing presence, while a high angle can make another appear vulnerable or powerless.
These are not revolutionary techniques. They are among the foundations of cinematic storytelling.
That is precisely why I enjoyed seeing them embraced.
There is a wonderful confidence in a filmmaker who understands that a camera movement does not have to be elaborate to be effective. Sometimes all that is needed is the correct angle, the right pace and an understanding of where the audience’s attention should be directed.
The camera is not simply recording the action. It is guiding our emotional response.
In horror, that relationship becomes even more important. We are often frightened not by what we see, but by what the filmmaker encourages us to anticipate.
The best horror understands that suspense is an agreement between the filmmaker and the audience. We know that we are being manipulated, but we willingly participate because the experience is so enjoyable.
As I watched, I found myself recognising so many of the traditional techniques associated with horror cinematography that I began mentally ticking them off.
Camera angles? Yes.
Pans? Yes.
Visual techniques designed to unsettle the audience? Certainly.
But where was my Dutch tilt?
For those unfamiliar with the term, a Dutch tilt, sometimes called a canted angle, is achieved by tilting the camera so that the horizon is no longer level. It is a familiar technique in horror and psychological thrillers because it creates a sense of imbalance, instability or unease.
Of course, a Dutch tilt is not compulsory. No filmmaker is required to work through a checklist of cinematic techniques, and its absence does not undermine the effectiveness of a film.
Nevertheless, I found it rather amusing that Ebenezer appeared to embrace so many of the fundamental conventions I associate with horror filmmaking while leaving out one of the most recognisable.
I loved it. Not because I believe horror must follow a formula, but because there is genuine pleasure in watching familiar techniques used with purpose.
These conventions have survived for a reason. They work.
There is no shame in using the established language of cinema, especially when that language serves the story so effectively.
Of course, I cannot talk about Ebenezer without mentioning the absolute joy of seeing Johnny Depp back on the big screen. Gosh, how I have missed him!
As someone with a particular interest in star studies, I find the relationship between an actor and their audience fascinating. We do not simply watch performers in isolation. We bring years of cinematic memories, emotional associations and expectations into the cinema with us. Certain actors become part of our personal film histories, and Depp is certainly one of those for me.
There is something wonderfully familiar about his screen presence. He has always had a remarkable ability to inhabit eccentric, unconventional and deeply theatrical characters, often finding a balance between the grotesque, the vulnerable and the strangely endearing. His performances have frequently embraced the heightened nature of storytelling, making him particularly well suited to the Gothic and fantastical traditions that I love studying.
What I have always appreciated about Depp is his willingness to embrace the theatricality of a character. His work reminds us that film performance does not always have to strive for absolute naturalism. Sometimes the most memorable characters are those who exist somewhere between realism and exaggeration, inviting the audience to accept the extraordinary as entirely believable.
There is also something rather lovely about the emotional connection we develop with performers over time. Watching an actor whose work has accompanied so many years of your life can feel almost like welcoming an old friend back into the room. It is a reminder that cinema is not simply an academic interest or an art form to be analysed. It is something we develop deeply personal relationships with.
For all my academic interest in cinematography, adaptation theory and the construction of cinematic meaning, sometimes I am simply a film lover sitting in the audience, delighted to see someone I have missed. Seeing Johnny Depp on screen again was one of those moments. Welcome back, Johnny. Gosh, it is lovely to see you in your element again with your shine back.
Back to the film: What makes A Christmas Carol such fascinating material for a horror adaptation is that its supernatural elements are not decorative additions to the narrative. They are fundamental to its meaning.
Scrooge is not simply visited by ghosts who teach him to be kinder. He is subjected to an extraordinary psychological confrontation with his past, present and possible future.
The Ghost of Christmas Past forces him to revisit memories that expose the emotional foundations of his character. The Ghost of Christmas Present confronts him with the consequences of his behaviour and the lives unfolding beyond his narrow worldview. The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come presents him with the ultimate human fear: death, obscurity and the possibility that our lives may have meant very little to those around us.
This is profoundly unsettling material.
Dickens uses the supernatural to dismantle Scrooge’s emotional defences. The ghosts are frightening not simply because they are otherworldly, but because they reveal truths he has spent years refusing to acknowledge.
That is the real horror of A Christmas Carol.
It is the possibility that we might be confronted with the person we have become and discover that we do not like what we see.
When filmmakers recognise this, they do not need to manufacture additional darkness or introduce unnecessary complications. The Gothic horror is already present in the text. It simply needs to be brought to the screen.
One of my recurring frustrations with contemporary adaptations is the assumption that familiar stories must be radically altered to justify their existence. I understand the argument. Cinema is a creative medium, and every new adaptation should have something to contribute. However, that contribution does not always have to come from rewriting the narrative.
It can come from cinematography. It can come from performance. It can come from production design, practical effects, editing, sound or the careful construction of atmosphere.
A filmmaker can tell an established story in a visually distinctive way without dismantling the qualities that made it successful in the first place.
In fact, I would argue that there is considerable artistic discipline involved in knowing when not to change something.
Faithful adaptation should not be confused with creative laziness. It requires an understanding of the source material, an appreciation of its themes and the confidence to allow the original narrative to speak for itself.
This is what I found so refreshing about Ebenezer.
It reminded me that familiarity does not have to diminish enjoyment. Sometimes it enhances it, allowing us to focus more closely on the decisions made behind the camera.
Rather than wondering how the story might have been rewritten, I could appreciate how it was being told.
I sometimes wonder whether studying film professionally changes the experience of watching it. It certainly changes what I notice.
I find myself paying attention to framing, transitions, camera movement and the construction of visual meaning. I notice the techniques that might pass unnoticed by someone watching purely for entertainment.
Occasionally, that can be distracting.
With Ebenezer, it was part of the enjoyment.
There was something immensely satisfying about recognising traditional horror techniques and appreciating the decision to use practical effects. It felt like watching filmmakers draw upon the foundations of their craft rather than relying upon spectacle alone.
Most importantly, I could enjoy those choices without feeling that the film was trying to prove how clever it was by distancing itself from the story it had chosen to adapt.
Not every film needs to reinvent cinema.
Not every adaptation needs to subvert expectations.
Not every supernatural encounter needs to become an elaborate digital spectacle.
Sometimes a good story, a carefully positioned camera, a physical effect and an understanding of how suspense works are more than enough.
Ebenezer reminded me of something that is easily forgotten in discussions of contemporary filmmaking: there is a difference between doing something new and doing something well.
I love ambitious filmmaking. I love creative interpretations and directors who challenge the conventions of their medium. However, I also love watching a film that understands the foundations of cinematic storytelling and has the confidence to use them.
There is room for both approaches.
For me, the pleasure of Ebenezer came from its appreciation of the original material, its use of physical effects and its embrace of the familiar visual language of horror.
It demonstrated that a well-known story can still feel engaging without being rewritten beyond recognition.
Sometimes the most refreshing creative decision a filmmaker can make is to trust the story they have been given.
Although, next time, perhaps someone could give me a Dutch tilt.
Just one.
For the film scholar in me.
Millie Hardy-Ashton
About the Creator
Millie Hardy-Ashton
I’m Millie Hardy-Ashton, writer, theatre practitioner and PhD researcher. Through personal reflection, humour and honest commentary, I explore disability, accessibility, creativity, popular culture and the beautifully messy business of life
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.