FYI logo

Is Being Informed a Civil Right?

The US, Canada, and Europe draw the lines of free speech in different places, yet none of them treat being informed as a civil right. How the First Amendment, Canada's Charter, and Europe's Article 10 handle the right to receive information, and where each one stops.

By Kira ShishkinPublished 3 days ago • 9 min read

Summary: American law shields your access to information, false information included. Canadian and European law shield access as well, yet both carve out what their laws call harmful. Not one of the 3 makes being informed a civil right.

This article is Part 1 of a 2-part Perspectives series written by Chuck Black, Contributing Author at informed.now. Part 1 lays out the historical context behind the right to be informed. Part 2 argues whether that right should exist.

Most of us outside the US aren't American, yet the American model is the one we reach for whenever the talk turns to "free speech" and "civil rights."

In the American model, free speech is a "negative" liberty: Its laws aim mainly at keeping the government from censoring ideas. Few other democracies protect offensive, hateful, or controversial speech as fully as the US does, and few distrust government power to define or suppress "harmful" ideas as deeply.

That American model is the one most people worldwide invoke when free speech comes up, even where their own legal systems run on different rules.

What does the First Amendment actually protect?

The American model grows out of the First Amendment, which says: "Congress shall make no law ... abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press..."

"Congress shall make no law" is the heart of the US approach: Congress may pass nothing that limits or interferes with the free flow of ideas, religiously inspired ideas included.

At first, the First Amendment bound Congress alone. The 14th Amendment changed that. Adopted after the Civil War, the 14th Amendment set out to secure citizenship and equal civil rights for people who had been enslaved, and courts now read its Due Process Clause as holding state and local governments to the same First Amendment standard.

The First Amendment treats the right to receive information as a "civil liberty," and the Supreme Court has said so more than once:

  • In Martin v. City of Struthers, a 1943 ruling, the Court found that the freedom to hand out literature necessarily carries a right to receive that literature.

  • In Stanley v. Georgia, a 1969 ruling, the Court backed the right to receive information and ideas once again and applied that right to privately owned material the state deems obscene.

  • In Board of Education v. Pico, a 1982 ruling, the Court said school boards can't pull library books to suppress ideas the board members dislike.

All 3 cases asked a "negative" question: Could a government restrict the free flow of information? US law mostly says governments can't.

Today, no US law imposes a "positive" duty to keep the population informed. Nor does the Constitution hold a broad "right to know" capable of forcing records into the open or requiring public or private information to be accurate.

What US Law Protects and What It Leaves Unguaranteed

  • Negative Right (Protected): Government can't stop information from reaching you; Sharing Printed Literature (Martin v. City of Struthers, 1943); Private Reading at Home (Stanley v. Georgia, 1969); School Library Books Stay on the Shelf (Board of Education v. Pico, 1982)

  • Positive Right (Not Guaranteed): Government has to make sure you're informed; Reporters Get Only the Public's Access (Houchins v. KQED, 1978); Records Requests Can Be Limited by States (McBurney v. Young, 2013); Accuracy Isn't Required (no federal law requires accurate information)

Does US law guarantee access to information?

Access-to-information laws do exist in the US. Under the federal Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) and the states' open-records laws, governments must release some records, either on request or after a set period has passed.

US courts, though, have found no general right of access to government information anywhere in the First Amendment.

In Houchins v. KQED, a 1978 ruling, the Supreme Court decided the press could claim no First Amendment access to a county jail beyond what the general public gets. In McBurney v. Young, a 2013 ruling, the Court upheld the State of Virginia's power to reserve public records requests for Virginia's own citizens.

First Amendment theory guards hardest against one danger: Government control of the information environment, which may keep people from forming their own judgments. Because the amendment binds only the government, censorship, propaganda monopolies, and viewpoint discrimination by private companies mostly land beyond its reach.

In American political theory, self-government and the "consent of the governed" depend on an informed citizenry. Still, no law requires citizens to be informed.

US law gives no general shield from private speech that's false, misleading, or biased. Tradition answers bad speech with more speech, criticism, and competition, and leaves officials out of ruling on what's true.

Private editorial choices and platform moderation get no general shield either. Courts treat those choices as protected speech in their own right, with limited exceptions such as fraud, defamation of private figures, or actual threats.

US law also gives private online platforms broad immunity from liability for their users' posts. That immunity comes from Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, passed in 1996 as an update to the Communications Act of 1934.

The hands-off approach leans on the "marketplace of ideas," an idea that traces back to Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes' 1919 dissent in Abrams v. US. In that view, the best test of truth is whether an idea can win acceptance in a free and open market of competing thoughts.

People still argue over whether concentrated ownership, algorithmic amplification, or coordinated private censorship can choke off access badly enough to undercut the "marketplace of ideas" rationale.

American law treats government "protection from bad information" as a greater threat to the right to be informed than the bad information itself. True to that spirit, the US has kept answering those concerns with competition, transparency, media literacy, or statutory disclosure rules in place of direct content regulation.

Other democracies trust the "marketplace of ideas" less than the US does.

How does Canadian law treat free speech?

Canada leans harder than the US toward shielding people from information the government judges harmful. Even so, Canadian law doesn't make being informed a civil right.

The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, in Section 2(b), guarantees "freedom of thought, belief, opinion and expression, including ... of the press." Section 1 then attaches a condition to every Charter right: Each one is subject to "such reasonable limits prescribed by law as can be demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society."

To decide whether a limit is reasonable, courts use the Oakes Test, named for R. v. Oakes (1986). The test checks whether a law that limits a Charter right serves a pressing goal, and whether the law cuts into the right no further than necessary.

The 4 Questions Canada's Courts Ask Before Limiting a Charter Right

  1. Pressing Objective: Is the goal behind the law pressing and substantial?

  2. Rational Connection: Is there a logical link between the limit and that goal?

  3. Minimal Impairment: Is the right restricted as little as reasonably possible?

  4. Proportionate Effects: Does the good the law does outweigh the harm the law does to the right?

A limit has to clear all 4 questions.

How Canadian courts apply the Oakes test remains contested.

John Carpay, founder and president of the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, makes that case in his 2025 book, "Corrupted by Fear." Carpay argues that the test was often misused and sometimes ignored in constitutional challenges to the lockdowns and restrictions that various municipal and provincial governments and the federal government imposed during the Covid-19 pandemic of 2021-2022.

Despite that criticism, Section 1 lets Canadian governments pass more proactive legislation than US law allows, and much of that legislation targets "hate speech." Section 319 of the Criminal Code is one example:

  • Section 319(1) now makes the "public incitement of hatred" against an identifiable group a crime, with groups defined by traits such as race, religion, ethnic origin, sexual orientation, and gender identity.

  • Section 319(2) bans wilfully promoting hatred. R. v. Keegstra, a 1990 ruling, upheld that ban as a justified limit.

  • Since 2022, Section 319 has also made it an offence to promote antisemitism by condoning, denying, or downplaying the Holocaust.

  • In 2026, the Combating Hate Act wrote into law a definition of hatred as "an emotion of an intense and extreme nature that is clearly associated with vilification and detestation." The same act repealed the good faith religious opinion defence for some hate propaganda offences.

The law still protects core political, journalistic, and artistic speech. Critics say that arguing about health care, immigration levels, or other contested topics now invites accusations of hate speech. Prosecutions, though, have been rare.

Parliament has passed some laws, and is weighing others, aimed at content the government considers harmful. The Combating Hate Act (Bill C-9) took effect on July 18, 2026, changing definitions in Section 319(1) of the Criminal Code. The Safe Social Media Act (Bill C-34), introduced in June 2026, is before Parliament, and the Canadian Civil Liberties Association calls it "a blank cheque for the government to regulate." The Protecting Young Persons from Exposure to Pornography Act (Bill S-209) has passed the Senate and is before the House of Commons. Critics of Bill S-209 cite privacy risks, a broad definition of restricted content, state-controlled internet filtering, and mandatory age verification that could mean tracking the online activity of every Canadian adult.

Taken as a group, critics argue, these laws chill public discourse.

How does European law treat free speech?

Across the European Union (EU) and most of the rest of Europe, the legal concepts look much like Canada's, even though the details of the legislation often differ.

Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights protects freedom of expression, but it adds that exercising that freedom "carries with it duties and responsibilities." A restriction is permitted when it meets 3 conditions:

  • A law prescribes the restriction.

  • The restriction pursues a legitimate aim, such as preventing disorder, crime, or infringement on the rights of others.

  • The restriction is necessary in a democratic society, a "proportionality test" similar to Oakes.

National governments and courts make the first call on what counts as "legitimate" and "necessary," and the European Court of Human Rights can review those calls. European states also owe "positive obligations" to protect people against hate and discrimination.

The result is a far more proactive model than the US model, and it parts ways with the US in 5 areas:

  • Constitutional structure: The US text comes close to an absolute bar on government abridgment, with narrow exceptions set by judges. Canada and the EU build limitation clauses into their texts, so content-based restrictions are easier to justify there than in the US when they're perceived as serving social goals.

  • Hate speech: US law protects hate speech unless it involves imminent harm or true threats. Canada and most of the EU criminalize or otherwise restrict hate speech as a harm to groups and democracy.

  • Approach to regulation: The US approach is reactive and restrains government. Canada and the EU take a more proactive line than the US, relying on criminal law, human rights remedies, and (especially in the EU) duties placed on platforms.

  • Platforms and online speech: Moderation in the US is mostly up to private companies. The EU's Digital Services Act and Canada's proposals go further, imposing or encouraging proactive responsibilities over content they define as illegal or harmful.

  • Historical and philosophical roots: American tradition stresses a skepticism of government power over ideas that dates to the founding era. Canadian and European approaches accept laws that protect people from hate speech and harmful content more readily than the American tradition does.

So where does the right to be informed stand?

Free Expression in 3 Systems: Different Rules, the Same Answer on Being Informed

  • Founding Text: United States: The First Amendment (1791); Canada: Section 2(b) of the Charter (1982); Europe: Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights (1950)

  • How Limits Work: United States: Courts carve out narrow exceptions; Canada: Section 1 permits reasonable limits, tested with Oakes; Europe: Any limit has to be lawful, legitimate, and necessary in a democratic society

  • Hate Speech: United States: Protected, except incitement to imminent lawless action and true threats; Canada: Criminal Code Section 319 makes it a crime; Europe: Most countries restrict it

  • Online Platforms: United States: Section 230 shields platforms from liability for user posts; Canada: The Safe Social Media Act (Bill C-34) is still before Parliament; Europe: The Digital Services Act gives platforms duties across the EU

  • Being Informed: United States: Not a civil right; Canada: Not a civil right; Europe: Not a civil right

Each of the 3 systems draws the boundaries of free speech somewhere different, and all 3 stop short of making being informed a civil right.

American law protects your access to information even when the information is false. In Canada and Europe, the law restricts access to information it defines as harmful.

Should being informed be a civil right? Part 2 of this Perspectives series takes up that question.

Kira Shishkin is the CEO of informed.now, the news research company on a mission to put the power of facts in your palm. informed.now/join

Originally published by our Contributing Author Chuck Black on informed.now.

legislationHistoricalHumanitysupreme court

About the Creator

Kira Shishkin

Kira Shishkin is the CEO of informed.now, the news research company on a mission to put the power of facts in your palm by texting you impactful news without bias, clickbait, or ads.

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Kira Shishkin