Futurism logo

Star Wars Rogue One Delivers Original Story But Disconnected Characters Keeps You From Caring

Star Wars Rebels Lack Swashbuckling Abandon and are not Heroes Reborn

By Rich MonettiPublished 7 years ago 3 min read

For the first time in the five Star Wars prequels and sequels that followed the original Trilogy, the franchise has not completely embarrassed itself. Unfortunately, Star Wars Rogue One still falls a little short, and the twelve dollars I shoveled over feels like yet another drop in a money pit that has no foreseeable bottom.

Based on much positive discourse I didn’t trust on social media, I assumed this had to be another catastrophe, and I was definitely hoping for the worst.

Of course, in the interest of objectivity, this had me questioning whether I still have ability to believe. Have I grown old and cold? Would Luke Skywalker himself be unable to sense the good side of the force in me?

At the same time, the overwhelming acceptance of The Force Awakens sent me in search of a another possibility. What the hell is wrong with all you people?

Opening Going Rogue Returns Optimism

Nonetheless, I did enter with hope off a late flurry of positive reaction on social media. This was buoyed as Rogue One did not begin with fanfare and left the iconic scroll and John Williams’ score for Episode VIII.

We simply meet a scientist on a remote world with his wife and daughter. But Galen Erso’s self-imposed exile abruptly ends with the arrival of the Empire, and his only choice is to help build the Deathstar. His wife doesn’t so easily acquiesce and is killed, while the daughter eludes capture and grows up to become our heroine.

The tragedy is compounded as the reluctant scientist obviously completes the task, and the rebellion provides no grey area for his dilemma. The same goes for Jyn (Felicity Jones) who long discounted her father’s plea that he would always protect her.

Star Wars Rogue One certainly provides a compelling plot with lots of philosophical conundrums to consider. So the set up in place, you’re incited as the rebels free Jyn from Imperial control in hopes of using her to kill Galen before the Deathstar is completed. Add a defector from the Empire that supposedly holds the key to a vulnerability in the WMD, and chase is on.

We go here and there, take out some bad guys, meet a few more intriguing characters and get clued in on how Galen has played the impossible hand he was dealt. We also digest the film’s signature line that circles us back to 1977. “Rebellions are made of hope,” declares Jyn’s partner in crime Cassian Andor (Diego Luna).

Am I missing Something?

Nonetheless, I came to a realization and then a question. I really could care less about these supposed heroes reborn, and what the hell is wrong with all of you?

James Earl Jones showing up to phone it in as Darth Vader didn’t help the digression either.

One scene easy enough to put aside, Rogue One does not suffer the lifted story that awakened the force two years ago, but not adapting the basic facet of the trilogy comes too late to save this film. In other words, there is a lack of connective flaws to bound the characters together so the natural banter that originally made Star Wars so appealing is absent.

Why Does Star Wars Rogue One Leave out the old Banter

The only prolonged instance of back and forth takes place between Jyn and a reprogramed imperial droid and results in a touching send off that says Star Wars like no other moment in the film.

No matter, the original triumvirate embraced the fractures befalling them - allowing the viewer to take their place beside them as our heroes made it up as they went along.

Rogue One, though, does imply a force that must fly by the seat of their pants, and when the moment comes to start the final act, this installment does take its place with its storied predecessors.

This left me pondering why it took so long for the swashbuckling to begin. Their fate already revealed in Star Wars, can a tragedy be lighthearted? Please see The Empire Strikes Back

Either way, I did care, and while I couldn’t pull enough interest as the events unfolded, maybe it’s because the force is no longer strong in me. But a finale bringing reminiscence of the originals at least shows that the rest of the world isn’t completely screwed up.

fantasyscifi moviestar wars

About the Creator

Rich Monetti

I am, I write.

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights


There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2024 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.