Critique logo

Review of Clearing the Catacombs

For Paul's The Critique The Work of Paul Stewart Unofficial Challenge

By Alyson Smith Published 9 days ago • 1 min read
Review of Clearing the Catacombs
Photo by Carnet de Voyage d'Alex on Unsplash

Clearing the Catacombs - A review of this work by Paul Stewart

https://vocal.media/poets/clearing-the-catacombs


Reviewed because it absolutely deserves a proper critique but also for Part Four of Paul’s Unofficial Vocal Challenge https://vocal.media/writers/pauls-super-fun-multi-part-unofficial-challenge


Clearing the Catacombs

I am completely blown away by how raw, fierce, and human Clearing the Catacombs is. 

There’s power in how you performed this and I love how you refuse to hide behind safe, vague metaphors. The moment you name addiction directly in the chorus, you strip away the safety net. It takes radical bravery to say those words out loud, and that directness is exactly what created an instant, deep connection with me that moves the piece from a poem into a breathing human confession.

Your beautiful accent gives the text a melodic quality, giving lines like ‘down again in the mire’ and ‘clear the catacombs’ a haunting weight. What makes this piece truly stunning is the brutal contrast between the musicality of your delivery and the graphic, angry imagery. It perfectly mimics the internal chaos of addiction—the whiplash between a person's inner light and the destructive ugliness they are fighting against. Having the audio live alongside the text is exactly how this deserves to be experienced.

DialoguePoetry

About the Creator

Alyson Smith

Neurodivergent, working-class writer and artist diagnosed with Bipolar. Based in Newcastle-upon-Tyne. MA in Creative Writing. Currently waitressing while finishing my novel.

https://buymeacoffee.com/alysonsmith

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Alyson Smith