
The Most Overrated
Write a critique arguing why a book, movie, TV show, album, or other widely praised work is more celebrated than it deserves.
Prizes
- 5 Winners:
- $200
- 15 Runners-up:
- $15
- 10 Honorable Mentions:
- $5
Status
CompletedTimeline
Submissions opened
Jul 22, 2026
Submissions closed
Aug 22, 2026 3:59 AM CUT
Results
Sep 02, 2026
Prizes
- 5 Winners:
- $200
- 15 Runners-up:
- $15
- 10 Honorable Mentions:
- $5
Status
CompletedTimeline
Submissions opened
Jul 22, 2026
Submissions closed
Aug 22, 2026 3:59 AM CUT
Results
Sep 02, 2026
About this challenge
The Prompt
Write a critique arguing why a book, movie, TV show, album, or other widely praised work is more celebrated than it deserves.
Not every beloved book, movie, album, or TV show lives up to its reputation. Sometimes the hype is bigger than the experience, and that's where this challenge begins.
Write about a work you think gets more praise than it deserves. Explain why it missed the mark for you, using specific examples to support your perspective instead of relying on a simple thumbs down.
Your piece can be thoughtful, funny, passionate, or analytical. The goal isn't to be contrarian for the sake of it. It's to make a clear case for why your experience didn't match the work's reputation.
In order for your submission to qualify, it must be:
- 3,000 words or less.
- Submitted to the Critique community. Your story will be disqualified if it is submitted to any other community.
- Submitted before August 21, 2026 at 11:59 PM EST.
- Your work must be original and unpublished.
The Prizes
- 5 Winners: $200 each
- 15 Runners-up: $15 each
- 10 Honorable Mentions: $5 each
How to enter
For your story to be eligible, it must be 3,000 words or less and adhere to our Community Guidelines.
Stories published on Vocal and entered into the Challenge up until August 21, 2026 at 11:59 PM EST will be entered for consideration. Official Rules for the Challenge can be found here.
The The Most Overrated Challenge is exclusive to Vocal+ members. To learn more and upgrade to Vocal+, visit https://vocal.media/vocal-plus.
To be eligible to win, you must be over the age of 13 and reside in a country where Stripe is available at the time of entry. A complete list of countries where Stripe is available can be found here—winners will need a Stripe account created and connected to receive prizes. Entrants located outside of these countries will not be eligible to win.
Open challenges
Challenges you can enter now for a chance to win.
My First Internet
Write a nonfiction story about a memorable experience from your early days online and what it meant to you.
$1,000 Grand Prize12 days leftIn Lieu of Gifts
Write a fiction story about someone who asks their family for one unusual favor instead of holiday gifts.
$1,000 Grand Prize19 days leftDark Before Dinner
Write a poem inspired by the early darkness of winter.
$1,000 Grand Prize26 days leftI Used to Hate This Song
Write a nonfiction story about a song you used to dislike and how it won you over.
$1,000 Grand Prize38 days leftBelow Freezing
Write a story where more than the weather turns cold.
$1,000 Grand Prize47 days leftEnough
Write a poem exploring what “enough” means to you.
$1,000 Grand Prize54 days left
Challenge resources
No One Remembers It That Way Challenge Winners
Ever try telling a family story with someone who was there? Good luck getting through it without a “Wait, that’s not how it happened.” For No One Remembers It That Way , we asked you to tell us where your versions split.
By Vocal Curation Team4 days ago in Resources
Scroll No More Challenge Winners
For Scroll No More , we switched off every smartphone in the world and left the aftermath to you. The results gave us plenty to laugh about, worry about, and occasionally even feel hopeful about along the way. Thanks again to Lightning Bolt ⚡ Bill for recommending this prompt!!
By Vocal Curation Team11 days ago in Resources
Dead Air Challenge Winners
Dead Air brought out some incredibly creative and strange ideas, and we had a lot of fun seeing where everyone took the prompt. From creepy toys and mysterious phone calls to sinister supermarket intercoms and a full-blown musical nightmare, there was no shortage of unique ways to make us think twice about what we're hearing.
By Vocal Curation Team18 days ago in Resources





