Is Elon Musk Actually About to Revive Vine?

I enjoy social media. Twitter is one of the tools I use a lot.

A few days ago, Elon Musk posted a tweet with an attached poll with a simple yes or no question.

“Bring back Vine?”

Of course, the results of the poll were yes, since many people were upset after Vine got shut down due to what most people thought was a stupid decision by Twitter. Although we aren't entirely sure if Musk is serious about this endeavor.

What was Vine?

Vine was a short-form video hosting platform where users could share six-second videos with their followers. This six-second restriction forced creators to convey their message or make people laugh as quickly and creatively as possible.

Vine was initially founded in June 2012 but was then acquired by Twitter in October 2012. It was then officially released on the 24th of January 2013. Eventually, Vine was shut down in October 2016.

The platform had millions of users, and some of its creators had millions of followers. After Vine shut down, most of its creators moved on to create content on other platforms, such as YouTube and Instagram.

Here’s a list of a few creators who began their careers as a creator on Vine. You may have heard of a few of them.

• Zach King

• Logan Paul

• Lele Pons

• King Bach

• Amanda Cerny

• Thomas Sanders

Why did Vine shut down?

Many people accused Twitter of making a stupid decision by shutting down Vine without knowing exactly why they actually did it. There were actually a bunch of valid reasons why Vine had to be shut down.

1 — The first reason was its failure to meet market needs. Vine was initially envisioned as a social media platform catered to individuals who just wanted to share short clips with their social circles.

But instead, Vine became an entertainment media platform, which can currently be compared to TikTok.

After these popular creators constructed the well-known ecosystem of Vine, it was very difficult for any creator to build a meaningful connection with their fan base. Due to the six-second video restriction, Vine couldn't be used as a platform to properly convey a message or properly interact with one's viewers.

This led creators to direct their Vine viewers to other media platforms such as YouTube and Instagram, where not only could they build a meaningful connection with their viewers but where they could also be compensated with monetization for their content. This leads me to the second reason Vine Shut down.

2 — The second reason was Vine’s monetization problems. Creators constantly attempted to direct their viewers to other platforms since they weren't financially compensated for creating videos on Vine.

This was a big issue that eventually led many creators to abandon the platform to begin content creation on other platforms which could monetize their content.

Additionally, the business itself wasn't making any money due to its reluctance to experiment with monetization solutions. After the platform's growth eventually stopped, there was no reason to continue operating.

3 — The third season was about problems with Vine’s parent company, Twitter. Twitter’s reasoning for acquiring Vine at such an early stage was an attempt to use Vine to grow Twitter’s own brand.

This means that from the beginning, Vine never intended to be a standalone brand.

After Twitter developed its own video feature, there was no need to keep Vine around since, from their point of view, it seemed like a redundant platform.

Can Musk actually bring back Vine and fix all its previous issues?

As Elon Musk acquired Twitter, making him the new CEO, he absolutely has the power to bring back Vine since the brand is under his name now. But the main question is, will he actually do it, and will it work?

After posting the poll on whether to bring back Vine or not, almost five million users voted, with almost 70% of the votes slanted toward yes.

It’s clear the people want Vine back, but will it be revived in the same state in which it shut down? Or will Musk work to improve the platform in order to alleviate all its previous issues?

If Vine were to be revived in the state we all remember it, it’s highly likely the platform will fail all over again since there already exists a superior short-form video platform. I’m, of course, talking about TikTok.

I assume in that state, the platform would initially be very popular due to “hype” created in the community, but over time most people will likely go back to TikTok since the platform has a lot more to offer.

On the other hand, if Musk attempts to transform Vine into an inviting platform, it could potentially be TikTok’s main competition.

Although I honestly can’t see a reimagined version of Vine surpassing TikTok since the main reason I believe most people will start using Vine again will be nostalgia.

If Musk revives Vine in the state, it was shut down, but with the additional monetization and financial compensation for its creators, I believe it can be another media platform that can exist besides TikTok, offering an alternative method of media consumption that wouldn't necessarily leave TikTok in its shadow.

Elon Musk’s seemingly simple tweet seriously got the internet riled up over its own nostalgia. I guess we’ll just have to wait and see if Musk is serious about reviving the platform which was taken from us.

I recently read an interesting story posted by Dr. Mehmet Yildiz, showing an optimistic view that Twitter might get better with the vision of Elon Musk. I hope his thoughts will be right in this context.

Here is his informative story: Elon Musk Fired 3 Top Executives, Aiming to Make Twitter a Free-Speech Platform. So what is the future of Twitter in this economic and political climate?

Thank you for reading my story and have a good one.

About the Author

I write articles and stories in my field covering gaming, filmmaking, media, and design. You can subscribe to my account to get notifications when I post on Medium and Vocal Media. I'm new on Vocal but I plan to post regularly. As an editor, I support Illumination Integrated Publications and participate in collaborative activities in the Slack Workspace, where writers can share Vocal Stories with thousands of members. I own and manage two publications, one for gaming and one for YouTube. You may join via my referral link if you are new to Medium. You can also join Vocal Media to share your stories. I look forward to reading your stories on both platform.