Dinah's Piano
A Short Story
Dinah placed her knobby, aged fingers in position on the ivory keys of James’ piano. The beginning of the song was easy, she had played it often enough. It was at about the sixth measure where she struggled with the notes in the bass clef. The simple act of being near this piano was challenging for Dinah, but hearing her broken, amateur version of their song coming from it almost seemed blasphemous compared to how James used to play it.
“You’re doing great, Grandma!”
She smiled at the words of encouragement coming from her grandson, Drew. Although the idea of being a student to a nine year old was strange at first, there was no denying his musical prowess. Besides, her days were often spent alone now, so she was grateful to spend the time together.
He gave a reassuring grin, and with newfound determination, she plugged away. Growing more bold at the stroke of each note.
Bonk!
She hit the wrong key as she moved to the second page of her sheet music. Frustration boiling over, she pressed her fingers down flat on every key she could, letting out a blaring cacophony of discontent.
“It’s ok, Grandma. You made it farther than last time.”
She looked over at her little grandson, amazed by his optimism. “Why don’t we take a break? I baked some of your favorite cookies, you know.”
Drew’s eyes grew wide, a toothy grin on his face.
“Chocolate chip! Thanks, Grandma!”
Dinah chuckled. She reached her hand out to touch Drew’s cheek. “You just hang tight, and I’ll be right back!”
As she moseyed around in the kitchen, Drew tinkered on the piano.
Such a talented boy, she thought, opening the refrigerator to grab some milk.
She reached for the plate of her famous cookies, and heard Drew’s playing transform into the song she used to hear resounding from it all the time. Except it wasn’t riddled with errors like her own attempts, it was perfect, just as James had played it.
The all too familiar, bitter melancholy returned. The once happy memories the song triggered, were laced with sadness. Her eyes blurred until at last they ran over, tears flowing down her face. Perhaps she should never have tried to play that song, perhaps she should have buried it, alongside her husband.
She was so engrossed in her grief, it took her a moment to realize the music had stopped, and her grandson was staring at her from the kitchen door.
“Grandma, are you ok?”
She looked up, embarrassment and shame passing over her for letting her grandson see her in such a state.
“Oh Drew, I’m sorry dear,” she said, trying her best to suppress her emotions and force a thin smile. There was a long pause as she searched for something to say, but she could think of nothing.
“You know, I miss him too.” Drew’s head was bowed, as he stared into his small hands, moving his fingers around as if he were trying to win a thumb wrestle with himself. “Mom thought these lessons would help you feel closer to Grandpa, but… but maybe she was wrong.”
“Oh, Drew!” Dinah embraced her grandson. “I love being your piano student! You really are a great teacher.”
As she held him in her arms, she began to feel him shake, his sniffles turning into weeping.
“It’s ok, honey,” she whispered to him.
Her sadness had left, and in its place, compassion for her grandson. They sat on the kitchen floor, sharing in their grief, and for the first time since James passed, Dinah felt as if somebody could understand her.
“Dad doesn’t like to see me cry,” Drew finally said with a shaky voice. “He says I need to be strong for Mom and you.”
Dinah stared down at her grandson, trying to piece together what to say.
“It’s ok to cry sometimes. It’s our body’s way of letting a tiny part of our sadness leave us in the tears. When we cry in front of someone we love, that helps them to know we need comfort and help. If you hold it all in, the sadness can build up and hurt you.” As she said the words, she realized she could do a better job at following them herself.
Drew’s nose scrunched up, he seemed to be weighing everything in his mind.
“Tell you what kiddo, if you ever need to cry, you can cry with Grandma. And if your Dad gives you a hard time, you bring him to me,” she said with a wink.
Drew looked up at her, a half smile on his face.
Dinah got to her feet, her aged bones aching with every movement.
“You ok, Grandma?” Drew said, concerned.
“Oh yes, dear. When you get to be old like me, sitting on the floor just isn’t a good idea anymore.” She smiled. “Now, who’s ready for some cookies and milk? I can’t eat these all by myself!”
“Me!”
Drew bounced off the floor and ran to the counter.
“Sorry I’m late Mom,” Samantha said, as Dinah opened the front door. “How was your lesson?”
“It went well, that boy has such a gift with music.” She led her daughter into the living room where Drew sat at the piano, playing something beautiful that Dinah had never heard before.
“How was he — y’know, as a teacher?” Samantha said in a hushed tone, setting her purse on the coffee table.
“He’s got the makings of a wonderful teacher, Sammy. He taught me more today than I’ve learned in a long time.” Dinah glanced over at her grandson with a smile.
Samantha looked taken aback. “The only things he teaches me are patience and Pokémon facts.”
The mother and daughter shared a quiet laugh as they listened to Drew’s piano piece crest to near crescendo. He played through it with a grace that made Dinah sure James’ talent had skipped a generation. Drew finished the piece with a triumphant staccato, and was met with applause.
“Bravo!” Dinah said, joy in her heart. For the first time since her husband passed, she was able to look at the piano without pain. The memories of James’ soothing melodies would always be with her, but now there was something else there. It gave her a connection to Drew.
“Hi Mom!” Drew said, hopping down from the piano bench and running to hug his mother.
“How was playing the piano with Grandma?” She asked.
“It was great! Grandma gave me cookies too!”
“I’m sure she did,” Samantha said, a hint of a chuckle in her voice.
“Grandma, will you show Mom all the progress you made?” Drew asked, looking up at Dinah.
“Oh, I don’t know if I’m quite ready for that.”
“Please?” He looked up at her with the puppy dog eyes of legend.
“Honey, Grandma has had a long day,” Samantha said.
“Oh it’s fine dear, I think it’s good for me to be playing more on your father’s piano.” Dinah positioned herself on the piano bench, the emotions of the day running through her mind. “Drew, will you help me play it?” She patted the bench in invitation.
“Sure!” Drew jumped up on the bench, next to Dinah. “You play treble Grandma, I’ll play bass.”
Dinah beamed down at her grandson and placed her fingers on the keys.
“Y’know Grandma, I think Grandpa would want you to have his piano.”
The comment caught Dinah off guard. Since James had passed, she had been the owner of the piano of course, and yet, she always referred to it as his piano. Could Drew see the pain in her eyes every time she looked at it? Had she turned what had been James’ greatest passion into her greatest object of grief?
“Y’know Drew, I think you’re right,” she said with a smile. “Let’s play the song on Grandma Dinah’s Piano.”
About the Creator
Eric Law Burton
I am passionate about storytelling in its many forms. I hope you enjoy what I have to share!
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.