Trader logo

The Arithmetic That Destroys Fortunes

Why a 50 percent loss needs a 100 percent gain, and what four centuries of bubbles teach about keeping wealth

By Kris TPublished 2 days ago • 3 min read

Lose 50 percent, and you need a 100 percent gain just to get back to where you started. Lose 80 percent, and you need 400 percent.

That piece of arithmetic is not new and it is not complicated. But I have come to think it explains more about how fortunes disappear than any single crash, fraud or bad decision. It is one of the threads running through my book The Anatomy of Wealth: How Money Is Born, Why It Is Lost, and How to Keep It.

Losses and gains are not symmetrical

Take two investors who each start with 100,000. The first earns a steady 7 percent a year. The second has a more exciting record: plus 30 percent in good years, minus 20 percent in bad ones, and an average of plus 5 percent per year across two years. It sounds close. It is not. After a good year and a bad year, the second investor has 100,000 × 1.30 × 0.80 = 104,000. The first has 100,000 × 1.07 × 1.07 = 114,490.

The average return was not far apart. The money was. What matters is the compounded path, and deep losses do disproportionate damage to that path. Avoiding the big loss is worth more than catching the big gain.

The same arithmetic works in reverse, which is the good news. Cut your worst year from minus 40 percent to minus 20 percent and you need a 25 percent gain to recover instead of 67 percent. That is why diversification, an emergency fund and avoiding borrowed money matter so much: they do not make you rich in a good year. They stop one bad year from undoing ten good ones, and they keep you invested long enough for compounding to do its work.

Every generation believes its moment is unique

The book opens with a pattern that repeats across four centuries. In the Dutch tulip mania of 1636–37, traders were sure they had found a new kind of asset. In 1720, investors in London were sure the South Sea Company would make them rich, and Isaac Newton himself lost a fortune in it. The railway mania of the 1840s, the crash of 1929, the dot-com bubble of 2000: each time, the people inside the boom had good-sounding reasons why this time was different.

The common thread is not stupidity. It is leverage, crowd psychology and the asymmetry above. A boom lifts prices gradually. The fall takes back years of gains in months, and anyone who borrowed to buy at the top may never recover.

How money is born, and why it leaks away

The book follows money through its whole life. It looks at where wealth comes from in the first place: work, saving, ownership of productive assets and, for nations, productivity. It then follows where it leaks away. Inflation is a silent tax on cash. Fees and turnover take a little every year. Concentration means a "diversified" index can depend on a handful of companies. And there is the psychology that makes us buy high, sell low and trust the most confident voice in the room.

It ends with the practical side: paying yourself first, starting early, lowering permanent spending, and dividing money into baskets with different jobs, from the emergency fund to long-term productive assets.

The oldest question

Adam Smith asked in 1776 why some nations grow rich. The same question applies to families and to each of us. Part of the answer is how money is made. A bigger part, I think, is how carefully it is protected from the arithmetic of large losses.


Kris Trufev is the author of The Anatomy of Wealth: How Money Is Born, Why It Is Lost, and How to Keep It. This article is for education only and is not personal investment advice.

investinghistory

About the Creator

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Kris T