The Swamp logo

Empathy Lost: Is the Damage Permanent?

When political loyalty eclipses compassion, survivors of sexual assault are abandoned, and the damage spreads far beyond them.

By Carl J. PetersenPublished a day ago • 7 min read

“The fish rots from the head.”

—Proverb

When a jury found that Trump had forcibly penetrated E. Jean Carroll’s vagina with his fingers, it should have morally disqualified him from ever becoming president. Instead, many in the MAGAverse decided Carroll was too ugly to be sexually abused and subjected us all to a second Trump presidency. Apparently, his supporters had exhausted their moral outrage worrying about the nonexistent practice of schools arranging gender-affirming surgery.

The willingness to ignore accusations against Trump is not an isolated phenomenon. Some of the same people who worked themselves into a tizzy over fabricated sex-abuse allegations supposedly committed in the basement of a pizza place that didn’t even have a basement were willing to dismiss a civil lawsuit accusing Trump of raping a 13-year-old girl. They are also willing to look past Trump’s documented friendship with convicted sex trafficker Jeffrey Epstein.

Trump’s gender gap was substantial: he won 55% of the male vote but just 45% of the female vote in 2024. But take that in for a minute. Nearly half of all women who voted chose Trump despite the jury’s finding that he had sexually abused E. Jean Carroll by forcibly penetrating her vagina with his fingers. Many people would describe that conduct as rape, even though New York law classified it as sexual abuse.

It should come as no surprise that Trump, other Republican politicians, and some of his supporters have repeatedly failed to show compassion for victims of sexual assault or harassment. The following stories share a common thread: society's increasingly selective distribution of empathy.

Gang Rape at Cornell

“Free pussy in alum pu”

— Message posted in a Snapchat group named “Chi Phi Activities”

It should go without saying that a person who is incapacitated by alcohol or drugs cannot consent to sex. That should be especially obvious when the person initiating the sexual activity is also the one who supplied the intoxicant.

The allegations detailed in a former Cornell student’s court filing are horrific. According to the complaint, multiple fraternity members had sex with the plaintiff while she was so intoxicated that she was incapable of giving consent. During the hours-long ordeal, they allegedly forced her to continue consuming alcohol and ketamine.

Although these allegations have yet to be proven in court, the complaint cites a text-message exchange between the defendants as evidence. If authenticated, the messages could lend significant support to the plaintiff’s account.

Given the seriousness of the allegations and the trauma described by the plaintiff, one would expect the President to act as empathizer in chief, expressing concern for her recovery. On behalf of a shocked nation, he should have promised a fair investigation and vowed the truth would come out.

Not Trump. Rather than expressing concern for the alleged victim, he said he felt "badly" for the accused because they would not receive a "fair shake" in the investigation. It wouldn't surprise me if they are eventually invited to the White House, where their ordeal will be recast as persecution for nothing more than locker-room behavior. After all, boys will be boys.

Trump's behavior is enabled, in part, by support from incels (people who identify as involuntarily celibate) and members of the manosphere. In these circles, outrage over the alleged gang rape at Cornell is dismissed as another example of woke culture. Some object to lumping the Cornell 7 together, arguing that certain defendants are innocent because they “only” forcibly kissed the plaintiff rather than penetrating her, as if forced kissing wasn’t also a form of sexual assault.

If they took the time to listen to themselves, they might understand why no one is volunteering to relieve them of their involuntary celibacy.

Childhood Lost

“Whether the ad was appropriate or not is not really my concern…Politics is a tough business.”

— JD Vance

It would seem that few things could represent a greater betrayal of a child’s innocence than being raped by a stepfather over a period of two years, beginning at age ten. But then Dr. Amy Acton’s mother remained married to her husband after he was charged with raping her daughter. To compound the betrayal, the mother accompanied the accused when he fled the state rather than face trial.

Despite the significant trauma she endured during childhood, Dr. Acton persevered. Her accomplishments include serving as director of the Ohio Department of Health, where she helped lead the state’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic during Donald Trump’s first term. Ohio ranked among the states with the lowest adjusted COVID-19 death rates in the country between 2020 and mid-2022, according to a study published in The Lancet.

Now she’s Ohio’s governor-elect. An ad released by Dr. Acton’s opponent, Vivek Ramaswamy, gave her estranged mother another opportunity to demonstrate why she deserves consideration if FIFA ever decides to create a Mother of the Year award to sit alongside the peace prize it gave to Trump. Donna Arthur told voters:

“It’s not easy for a mother to say this, that Amy has a serious problem. She is a liar. She lies about her past. She says she grew up living in a tent. None of that is true.”

It is hardly surprising that a woman who remained with the man charged with raping her young child would rationalize her actions by dismissing her daughter’s account of her childhood as a lie. But how did Ramaswamy think that using his opponent’s mother as a political weapon would help his case with voters, given that she had stood by the man accused of sexually abusing her daughter?

It is possible that Ramaswamy and his staff were simply ignorant of the facts when they decided to give a platform to a woman whose children had been removed from her custody nearly fifty years ago. However, the campaign’s initial reluctance to take responsibility for the ad raises questions about whether that was really the case.

Even after the circumstances surrounding Acton’s childhood became public, Ramaswamy continued to defend the ad while it remained on the air. That was reprehensible and reflected a profound lack of judgment and decency.

Vice President JD Vance jumped to Ramaswamy’s defense. Reacting to bipartisan condemnation, Vance claimed to be “a little bit disgusted.”

Vance apparently wasn't disturbed by the use of childhood family trauma against an opponent. What bothered him was that there are “Republicans across the country who are whining more about that advertisement than they are about…Democrats.” When the person who is a heartbeat away from the Oval Office is this brazen about a win-at-all-costs philosophy of government, is it any wonder that so many Americans have lost faith in the political process?

Trump reserves his sympathy for the person responsible, complaining that Ramaswamy has been treated “very unfairly” in the controversy. He has not only condoned the ad but admitted to advising Ramaswamy to keep running it, saying it was “hitting pay dirt.”

“This is a mother saying very bad things about her daughter, and I don’t know why that should be shielded,” Trump told a reporter. He added that, as a candidate for office, Acton was “fair game.”

At a rally for Ramaswamy, Trump told the crowd:

“The mother said that Amy Acton, the daughter, is a liar, that she’s no good, that she lied about the opponent. How the hell is that [Ramaswamy’s] problem?”                                                                                                               

According to The Independent, the crowd applauded.

Stop Using Rape as a Weapon

“A woman, by herself? She didn't even get some of her campaign workers to help her for security if nothing else? Sounds like exactly the kind of good judgment we need in DC.”

- Brad Pack, on Facebook

The news that Arizona Democratic congressional candidate Bernadette Greene-Placentia reported being raped while repairing campaign signs is horrifying. The possibility that the attack was politically motivated makes it even more disturbing.

Understandably, Greene-Placentia has difficulty remembering all the details of that night. She recalls one of her attackers making a derogatory remark that sounded like “...ick bitch.” She believes the first part may have been “Democratic bitch,” but cannot say for certain.

If investigators determine that the attack was politically motivated, it would be another disturbing example of political intimidation. More broadly, violence is a foreseeable risk in an environment where leaders attack, insult, and dehumanize their opponents rather than engage in good-faith conversation grounded in facts.

We saw this same dynamic when Trump whipped his followers into a frenzy on January 6, 2021, and some in the crowd violently forced their way into the Capitol, hoping to overturn an election that did not go their way. It was the ultimate expression of “never admit defeat.”

In my view, Trump’s actions that day should have landed him in jail. Instead, he was given a second crack at the Oval Office. His second term has been more dangerous, in part because his return to office has demonstrated how little accountability he has faced for his actions.

Where does this leave us as a country? Our political system is broken, focused more on entertainment than actual governance. The resulting animosity has made compromise all but impossible. It has also made empathy seem obsolete, particularly when the victim holds different political values.

It should have been easy for politicians to condemn the attack and express condolences for the candidate. Fortunately, her opponent has shown common decency by calling for the attackers to be arrested and prosecuted. Yet, according to MS NOW reporting, other Arizona Republican leaders were mostly silent.

Some online have been openly hostile, expressing skepticism or engaging in victim-blaming. While Facebook user Brad Pack invoked his mother's adage that “nothing good happens after midnight” to suggest that the candidate shouldn't have been out repairing campaign signs at 2:00 a.m., I would argue that “if you can't say something nice, don't say anything at all” would have been more appropriate.

Trump ran on a promise to make America great again, but this episode illustrates how much our civic culture has deteriorated. It used to be that we could find common identity with our fellow Americans, even when we voted for different candidates. Under Trump’s administration, tribalism has increased to the point where we can’t even come together long enough to provide unified support for the victim of a brutal assault.

That damage to our capacity for empathy will last long after the gold has been stripped from the Oval Office.

politics

About the Creator

Carl J. Petersen

Carl Petersen is a former Green Party candidate for the LAUSD School Board and a longtime advocate for public education and special needs families. Now based in Washington State, he writes about politics, culture, and family.

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Carl J. Petersen