Petlife logo

A Case Of Mistaken Identity

The Day I Almost Kidnapped My Neighbor’s Dog

By Brittany MadoniaPublished 5 years ago • 3 min read
A Case Of Mistaken Identity
Photo by Tanner Crockett on Unsplash

It was a hot summer afternoon when I realized I needed to run outside to get something that I had left in the car earlier that day. As I was about to go back inside my house I noticed a little dog on my neighbor’s porch. I knew he didn’t belong to my neighbor, as they had three big dogs. Being one of those dog people, who would love to pet every dog, I called the little guy over. He came happily wagging his tail, and though he was a little shy at first he warmed up to me pretty quickly while enjoying getting some attention.

Now I should probably mention that I don’t know all the neighbors on my street, but I have noticed almost every dog in my neighborhood, or at least I thought I had. This little guy didn’t have a collar, but he looked like a dog I had seen around the corner, belonging to a little old lady, whom I have never met. Regardless, I couldn’t just leave him outside knowing he could get lost, or hurt, not to mention how worried the little old lady down the street might be if he didn’t come home. So I determined that I would bring the little guy back to his home, but when I went inside my house for a moment he took off, and I lost him.

Still thinking of how sad and worried the little old lady would be without her dog, I grabbed my spare dog leash, and headed out to look for him. Now those who know me always laugh a little at this part of the story, because they all know I don’t have a dog at the moment. Yet I have a few dog leashes, and feeding bowls for the occasional stray dogs, or cats that I have had the pleasure of caring for. But enough about that, let’s get back to the story.

At that point I went back outside, and looking down the street I spotted the little dog, three houses down, closely following one of my neighbors who was carrying his little daughter into the house. They were a fairly new family on the street, whom I had also never met, but since the time they had moved in I had never seen them with a dog. So with every good intention to get the dog back to the little old lady, that I thought he belonged to, I quickly walked down the street to get him.

Thinking my neighbor might be annoyed at this little dog at his heels I said, "I’m so sorry about him, let me get him out of your way." I called the little dog over, and once again he came happily running over to me. Feeling pretty good about myself, and the good deed I was doing, I placed my slip leash over the dogs head. However, just as I was about to walk him down the street to the little old lady’s house, my neighbor said, "I thought that was my dog?"

I froze as a sudden wave of panic came over me. I am pretty sure the look on my face had to have been hilarious! The thought of asking if the little guy was his dog hadn’t even crossed my mind! In shock I exclaimed, "Oh my gosh! Is he your dog?! I’m so sorry, I thought he was the little dog from down the street!"

I quickly let the little dog off the leash, now apologizing profusely! My neighbor said, “Come on Tigger”, and Tigger went happily running back to his owner. My neighbor explained that the little guy had just gotten a haircut, so he didn't recognized him right away, but that he thought it is was cool that I was offering to help him get his dog inside. I apologized one more time, and headed back up to my house thoroughly embarrassed!

When I walked through the door my sister asked from the kitchen, “Did you get the dog home?” I burst out laughing saying, “Oh yes, he’s home now! And it was so embarrassing!” Needless to say my family, and I have really enjoyed laughing at my “good deed” turned “embarrassing story.”

For the next couple of weeks we were on the lookout for the little old lady down the street, and her dog. When we finally saw them again I realized that her little dog, though about the same size, and similar color, actually looked nothing like Tigger! We couldn’t help but laugh imagining if my neighbor hadn’t been out to stop me from taking his dog, and if I had brought Tigger to the little old lady’s house, only to discover she had her dog! Who knows maybe I could have met all my neighbors that day searching for the home of the little dog without a collar.

dog

About the Creator

Brittany Madonia

Hi! I'm Brittany, I'm new to the Vocal community, and especially new to sharing anything I have written. I hope you enjoy my stories! I love animals, music, reading, pizza, and chocolate chip cookies. :)

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Brittany Madonia