Journal logo

The Green Energy Paradox: Why Malaysia-Singapore Power Trade Stalls Despite High Demand

As Singapore seeks low-carbon imports and Malaysia aims to maximize resource value, a mismatch in economic priorities and market structures threatens to stall the region’s most promising cross-border renewable energy initiative.

By Mark Lim Published 6 days ago • 4 min read

The vision of a seamless, green energy grid connecting Malaysia and Singapore has long been touted as a cornerstone of Southeast Asia’s energy transition. For Singapore, a land-scarce island nation with ambitious net-zero targets, importing renewable energy (RE) from its larger neighbor is a logistical necessity. For Malaysia, rich in solar and hydro potential, exporting power offers a lucrative revenue stream and a chance to position itself as a regional energy hub. Yet, despite strong political will and conditional approvals for gigawatt-scale imports, the market reality has been far more tepid than anticipated. According to Ditrolic Energy, a regional renewable asset developer, the primary obstacle is not a lack of technology or demand, but a fundamental asymmetry in economic priorities that makes long-term contractual stability difficult to achieve.

The Asymmetry of Interest

At the heart of the stalemate is a divergent set of goals. Singapore’s priority is clear: secure competitively priced, low-carbon electricity to meet its environmental mandates without compromising its economic competitiveness. For the city-state, the ideal import is cheap, reliable, and green. Malaysia, however, views its renewable resources through a different lens. Having lifted a previous ban on RE exports in 2023, Kuala Lumpur is now focused on maximizing the economic value of these assets. The government seeks to ensure that exporting green power does not come at the expense of domestic industrial growth, particularly as it attempts to attract high-value, energy-intensive industries like data centers and semiconductor manufacturing.

“If the arrangement between two countries is asymmetrical, where one side captures more economic interest than the other, then it is very difficult for the contracts to be maintained over a long period of time,” said Tham Chee Aun, CEO of Ditrolic Energy. Speaking at the Singapore International Energy Week, Tham highlighted that this imbalance creates friction. If Malaysia pushes for export prices that reflect the full strategic value of its resources, Singapore may find the cost prohibitive compared to other alternatives. Conversely, if Singapore demands rock-bottom prices, Malaysian developers may struggle to achieve adequate returns, especially given the high upfront capital costs of solar farms and energy storage systems.

Structural Mismatches: Open Markets vs. Vertical Integration

Compounding the pricing dilemma is the structural difference between the two nations’ electricity markets. Singapore operates a highly liberalized, competitive energy market where generators and retailers compete on price and service. Malaysia’s market, by contrast, remains more vertically integrated, with Tenaga Nasional Bhd (TNB) playing a dominant role through its Single Buyer model.

This structural disconnect complicates the "discovery" process necessary for fair pricing. In a fully open market, prices are determined by supply and demand dynamics in real time. In a more regulated environment, prices are often set through auctions or government-mandated tariffs. Tham noted that finding a pricing structure that balances affordability for Singaporean buyers with sufficient returns for Malaysian exporters requires a nuanced approach. “There needs to be a genuine process of discovery of what the benefit is that the exporting country would have, and what the benefit is that the importing country would have, and whether the benefits are symmetrical and sufficient for both parties, not only for a while, but for the next 20, 30, 40 years to come.”

The ENEGEM Pilot and Market Hesitation

The Malaysian government has attempted to bridge this gap through initiatives like Energy Exchange Malaysia (ENEGEM), which recently completed a pilot green energy auction for exports. The mechanism pools renewable energy generated in Malaysia and channels it through TNB’s national grid. However, market reception has been lower than expected. Investors and buyers have cited two major concerns: pricing uncertainty and the "greenness" of the power.

Because the electricity is drawn from a national grid that still relies heavily on fossil fuels, buyers are concerned about the actual carbon intensity of the power they are purchasing. Without robust guarantees of origin or direct line connections, the environmental credentials of grid-pooled energy can be ambiguous. Furthermore, the pricing mechanisms in the pilot auctions have not yet provided the long-term visibility that large corporate buyers require.

Customer Demand: The Ultimate Arbiter

Ultimately, regulatory frameworks and government agreements can only enable the market; they cannot create it. As Tham pointed out, “Regulation can enable the market, but ultimately the customer makes the market.” Corporate buyers in Singapore are not simply looking for the cheapest kilowatt-hour. They are seeking specific, high-quality attributes: round-the-clock renewable supply backed by energy storage, guaranteed carbon abatement, and long-term price stability.

For cross-border trade to truly take off, developers must move beyond simple bulk power sales and offer tailored solutions that meet these sophisticated demands. This may involve hybrid projects that combine solar generation with battery storage, or direct corporate power purchase agreements (CPPAs) that bypass some of the complexities of the national grid.

The path forward requires a shift in mindset from both governments. Rather than viewing the trade as a zero-sum game where one side’s gain is the other’s loss, Malaysia and Singapore must collaborate to design a framework where economic benefits are shared equitably. Only by aligning their long-term interests Malaysia’s desire for industrial value addition and Singapore’s need for affordable decarbonization, can the two neighbors unlock the full potential of their green energy partnership. Until then, the wires may be connected, but the flow of commerce remains constrained by the friction of competing priorities.

industry

About the Creator

Mark Lim

Hi I am mark an automotive student and a car, tech and food enthusiast ! Im gonna try and post daily & hope you enjoy what I write and do share my page with people you know. I would gladly appreciate it! Cheers

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Mark Lim