Journal logo

Adverse Possession: Key elements, myths, facts and legal challenges

All about Adverse Possession India

By NRI Legal ServicesPublished 2 years ago • 6 min read

Introduction

Adverse possession is an act of claiming ownership of land without the original owner’s permission. The Adverse possession promote the productive use of land and to clarify ownership disputes.

Possession in order to be adverse has to be open and as of right. Only such kind of possession can be said to be adverse or hostile to the true owner by reason of the fact that it is adverse or prejudicial to his interest unless it is proved that the possession started with his permission or under a grant made by him. In such circumstances, the possession cannot be said to be permissive in nature.

Concept of possession and adverse possession

Possession implies dominion and control over an object.

The concept of adverse possession, on the other hand, implies a hostile possession. In the possession to be adverse in nature, it must be by a person who prefers not to acknowledge the other’s rights and denies them. It is firmly established that a person who has based his title on adverse possession must show evidence that his possession was hostile to the real owner and has amounted to a denial of his title.

Principles of establishing adverse possession

  1. In order to establish adverse possession, it must be shown that possession was adequate in publicity, in continuity and in extent.
  2. The possession should be overt and without any attempt at concealment so that the person against whom time is running, if he exercises due vigilance to be aware what is happening.
  3. It is not necessary that in order to establish adverse possession proof of acts of possession should cover every moment of the period of occupation.
  4. Title by adverse possession is limited to what has been actually possessed by the trespasser.

Key elements of adverse possession

The party who asserts possession in accordance with adverse possession needs to establish the following:

  1. Actual Possession: The claimant who bases his or her title to a property on adverse possession should have actual possession of the same.
  2. Exclusive Possession: The possession of the person who is claiming adverse possession in a property must be exclusive and no other person should in possession of the property in question.
  3. Open and Notorious: The possession of the person who is living in adverse possession of the property must be visible and obvious enough that the rightful owner could have noticed and acted.
  4. Hostile Possession: Possession of property must be completely hostile i.e. without the consent of the actual owner.
  5. Continuous Possession: The person claiming adverse possession of a property must be in continuous possession must have occupied the property for a period of 12 years continuously as per the Limitation Act,1963.

Common myths and facts about adverse possession

  • Myth: Any individual can claim Land through Adverse possession
  • Fact: Adverse possession is not easy. Strict compliances that include long-term, uninterrupted possession under specific conditions laid down by law are mandatory.
  • Myth: A trespasser can own a property instantly
  • Fact: Adverse possession is not an overnight process. It generally requires possession for 12 years uninterrupted period.
  • Myth: Adverse possession is illegal
  • Fact: Adverse possession is a rule of law. It aims at settling disputes on land, resolving title ambiguity, and making land use effective.
  • Myth: Paying property taxes can grant ownership
  • Fact: Payment of property taxes may support an adverse possession claim but it is not a determining factor for gaining ownership.

Legal challenges

  • Burden of proof: The party who is claiming Adverse possession must provide clear and convincing evidence that all elements are met so that due compliance can be given by the Court to the evidence so produced by the party in support of his claim.
  • Right to Challenge: The person who is the rightful owner of the property reserves the right to interrupt the adverse possession by taking legal action such as serving a legal notice for eviction upon the person who is in possession of the property or filing a lawsuit against him in a competent Court of law.
  • Exception to land owned by the Government: Adverse possession cannot be claimed for a land which is owned by the Central or the State Government.
  • Good Faith vs. Bad Faith Possession: In some circumstances the Courts of competent jurisdiction may consider whether the possessor had a genuine belief that he was the owner of the suit land.

Conclusion:

It is apparently clear and evident that Adverse possession is a complex and misunderstood aspect of real estate law. It may serve a purpose to clarify land ownership disputes and prevent land from being unused but it is not a proper method to acquire a property. Property owners have to be vigilant and they should take appropriate steps to prevent unauthorized occupation. A better understanding of the legal framework of Adverse possession will ensure informed decision making for both landowners and claimants.

FAQ:

Q. Can a Tenant claim Adverse Possession?

A No a tenant cannot claim adverse possession in a property as he is in possession of the property with the owner’s possession and for being in adverse possession it is essential that he is occupying the property without the actual owner’s consent.

Q. How can a property owner prevent Adverse Possession?

A property owner can prevent Adverse Possession by taking the following measures:

  • By ensuring regular inspection and maintenance of the property
  • By posting “NO TRESPASSING” signs outside the property
  • By taking necessary legal action against the persons who have illegally occupied the land
  • By giving a written consent to the persons who have occupied the land in order to prevent the “hostile” claim.

Q. Can government land be claimed under Adverse Possession?

No, Adverse Possession cannot be claimed in a government land following as it is protected under the Indian Law and there can be no claims of adverse possession against it following the ruling of the Supreme Court in State of Haryana vs. Mukesh Kumar (2011) 10 SCC 404.

Q. What is the role of Limitation Act,1963 in Adverse Possession?

The Limitation Act,1963 has set a time limit for filing property related claims. The statutory period for filing property related claims is 12 years as per the Limitation Act and if the true owner doesn’t take any legal action within this stipulated period, then he loses his right to reclaim the land from an adverse possessor.

Q. Can an Adverse Possession claim be challenged in the Court?

Yes, the real owner of the property can challenge a claim of adverse possession in the Court by establishing the following:

  • The possession was not hostile
  • There were interruptions in possession of the property
  • The claimant was given permission by the actual owner to use the property.

Q. Can co-owners claim adverse possession against each other?

Yes, it is possible, however, a little difficult. It is essential that one co-owner must demonstrate exclusive, hostile and continuous possession while preventing the co-owners from using the property.

Q. How can an adverse possessor get legal property ownership?

If all the necessary requirements are met then the possessor can file a suit for declaration in a competent court of law. Once the Court passes a decree in the claimant’s favour then he can get the legal title transferred in his favour.

Q. Can Adverse Possession be claimed over Agricultural Land?

Yes, Adverse Possession can be claimed if the possessor has been in actual and continuous possession of the same for a statutory period of 12 years without the permission of the actual owner. However, some specific state laws may impose restrictions, especially on tribal or government owned land.

Q. Can paying property tax help in claiming adverse possession?

Property tax receipts can be considered as one of the requisites for establishing adverse possession of a property however it alone cannot be considered to be a sole factor while determining the same. Other factors such as hostile and continuous possession must also be met for determining the same.

Q. Can a family member claim adverse possession against another family member?

Yes, it is possible however a little difficult. In family disputes the Courts draw a presumption of permissive possession, meaning that one family member’s occupation is said to be with consent. In order to prove adverse possession, the claimant has to prove that his possession was hostile and exclusive for the required period.

advice

About the Creator

NRI Legal Services

NRI Legal Services is a premier global legal management firm set up 2 decades ago in the year 2000 exclusively for NRIs. Our purpose since our inception has been to offer a proactive, responsive and hassle-free legal services to NRIs.

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by NRI Legal Services