Horror logo

The Mysterious Disappearance Of The Yuba County Five

Lost in the wilderness: unraveling the enigma of the yuba county five

By Emmanuel AwoyemiPublished 3 months ago 4 min read

In the annals of unsolved mysteries, the case of the Yuba County Five stands as one of the most perplexing and haunting. Five friends set out for a night of basketball and snacks, but what followed was a series of events that continue to baffle investigators and theorists to this day. This article delves into the enigmatic story of the Yuba County Five, exploring various theories and questions that surround their disappearance.

The Fateful Night:

On a chilly Friday evening, five close-knit friends – Jack Madruga, William Sterling, Jack Huett, Theodore Weiher, and Gary Mathias – embarked on a journey that would take them far from the comforts of home. Their destination was a Chico State Basketball game, a night of celebration for the Gateway Gators, a basketball team associated with the Yuba City Gateway Program, a rehabilitative center aimed at helping individuals with mild intellectual disabilities and mental health issues.

The group was led by Jack Madruga, who owned a 1969 Mercury Montego. It was a night filled with high hopes and anticipation for a win, but as events unfolded, their lives would take a dark and bewildering turn.

The Detour:

After the basketball game and a stop at Behr's convenience store for snacks, the group should have been on their way back home. Instead, they took a detour that would change the course of their lives. Rather than heading south towards Oroville via Highway 70, they turned east onto the Oroville-Quincy Highway, a road that led into the remote Plumas National Forest.

Their journey continued until their car became stuck in the snowdrift, miles away from civilization. What happened next remains a mystery, but they left their car and ventured into the unknown.

The Abandoned Car:

In an isolated area of the Plumas National Forest, a forest ranger stumbled upon the group's abandoned turquoise Mercury Montego. Strangely, the car appeared to be in immaculate condition, despite the rough terrain of the road they had taken. The car was unlocked, the window was down, and snack wrappers littered the seats. It seemed as though the car had been abandoned abruptly, with little or no damage.

The Search and Discovery:

The disappearance of the Yuba County Five prompted an extensive search operation, but it was complicated by harsh winter conditions and treacherous terrain. Tragically, their search yielded grim results. Ted Weiher was the first to be found, his body was discovered in an abandoned forest service trailer near Bucks Lake. He had lost nearly 80 pounds and died of starvation and exposure.

The search continued, and the bodies of Jack Madruga and William Sterling were discovered five miles south of where Weiher was found. Jack had his car keys, and both had succumbed to the elements and exhaustion.

The Mystery Deepens:

Two days later, the remains of Jack Huett were found, and it became apparent that he and Gary Mathias had made it to the forest service trailer with Weiher. However, Mathias and Huett had left the trailer, embarking on a journey that would ultimately lead to their demise. To this day, Gary Mathias remains missing.

Unanswered Questions:

The Yuba County Five case is riddled with unanswered questions and perplexing details. Why did they take the detour into the forest, and why did they abandon their car in such good condition? What compelled them to venture into the wilderness, knowing the harsh conditions they would face? The theories surrounding their disappearance are varied and complex.

Theories and Speculations:

Several theories have emerged over the years to explain the Yuba County Five's baffling disappearance:

Nefarious Involvement: Some believe that the group witnessed a crime or encountered dangerous individuals that night, leading them to flee into the forest. The mysterious sightings by Joe Shones add to the intrigue.

Accidental Misadventure: Others suggest that the group's detour and subsequent decisions were a result of confusion or disorientation. They may have believed they were on the right path to safety.

Gary Mathias's Influence: There are speculations that Gary Mathias, the only one without intellectual disabilities, may have played a significant role in the group's actions that night. Did he lead them astray intentionally or unintentionally?


The Yuba County Five case remains an enigma, with no clear resolution in sight. Theories abound, but the truth behind their disappearance remains elusive. The story of these five friends, who set out for a night of sports and laughter only to find themselves in a harrowing ordeal, continues to captivate the imagination of those who seek to unravel the mysteries of that fateful night.


About the Creator

Emmanuel Awoyemi

I am a passionate writer and content creator dedicated to bringing stories and ideas to life through the power of words. I have honed my skills to craft compelling narratives.

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments (1)

Sign in to comment
  • Alex H Mittelman 3 months ago

    Very interesting! Gazoogabloga! What do you think happened?

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

© 2023 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.