Horror logo

The Mirror Remembered

I covered every mirror in my house after my sister died. Last night, one of them uncovered itself.

By Noman AfridiPublished 4 months ago • 4 min read

We covered the mirrors the old way, the way our grandmother taught us.

White sheets, pinned at the corners, pulled taut so not even a sliver of reflection could escape beneath the edges. It's a mourning tradition — something about the soul getting confused, looking for itself in glass instead of finding its way home. I never believed in it, not really. But when Sara died, I did it anyway. Because it was something to do. Because grief makes you desperate for ritual, for the feeling that you are doing something, anything, that might matter.

That was three weeks ago.

The sheet on the bathroom mirror came down on a Tuesday.

I noticed it when I went in at half past eleven at night, half-asleep, not really looking at anything. The sheet was folded neatly on the edge of the sink. Not fallen. Not crumpled on the floor the way something falls. Folded — corners matched, edges aligned, the way Sara used to fold things. She was particular about that. Drove me insane when we were teenagers sharing a bathroom, the way she folded every towel like it was going into a hotel drawer.

I stood there in the doorway for a long time looking at that folded sheet.

Then I looked at the mirror.

It was just a mirror. My own face looked back at me — pale, hollowed out, hair unwashed for days. Just me. The bathroom behind me. The dark hallway beyond the open door.

I told myself I must have done it myself without remembering. Grief does strange things to sleep. I had been walking through the days like a person underwater — slow, muffled, not entirely present. It was possible. It was the only explanation that made sense.

I refolded the sheet. Pinned it back up. Went to bed.

Wednesday night, the same thing.

Sheet folded on the sink. Mirror uncovered. And this time — I stood there longer, because something felt different about the room. Not cold, the way people always describe it in stories like this. Warmer, actually. The kind of warmth that comes from a person standing very close to you. The kind of warmth that has a shape.

I looked at the mirror.

My reflection looked back.

But it was a half-second slow.

I know how that sounds. I know exactly how that sounds and I am telling you it was not a trick of the light and it was not my tired brain misreading what it saw. I raised my right hand. My reflection raised its hand — but just after. The way a person mimics you, watching your movement and then copying it. A delay so small you would miss it if you weren't standing absolutely still in a silent bathroom at midnight watching for exactly that thing.

I took the sheet off the sink.

I held it up.

And just before I covered the mirror — my reflection smiled.

I did not smile.

I was not smiling.

My face was doing the thing it had been doing for three weeks — that flat, gutted expression of someone who has forgotten what their face is supposed to do without grief running through it. I was not smiling.

But in the mirror, my reflection pulled the left side of its mouth up. Slow. Deliberate. Like a person suppressing something. Like a person trying very hard not to show how pleased they are.

Sara smiled like that. Only on the left side, just slightly. A habit so specific to her that our mother used to call it her secret smile — the one she made when she knew something you didn't.

I covered the mirror.

I slept with the light on.

Thursday, I didn't go into the bathroom at all. I used the one downstairs. I told myself I would not check. I made it until 2 a.m. before I walked upstairs and stood outside the bathroom door with my hand on the frame and just — listened.

Nothing. Silence. The house settling, the radiator ticking.

I pushed the door open.

The sheet was folded on the sink again.

And on the mirror — on the glass itself, in the condensation that had gathered from nowhere because I had not showered, had not run any water, had not done anything that would put moisture in that air — there were letters.

Six of them. Written from the inside.

FOUND IT

I called my mother at 2 a.m. and she cried in a way I hadn't heard since the hospital. Not sad crying. The other kind.

She told me that when Sara was seven years old, she got lost at a fairground for forty-five minutes. When they found her, perfectly fine, eating a candyfloss by the exit gate, they asked her where she had been. Sara looked at them both with that left-sided smile and said:

"I was looking for the way out. Don't worry. I found it."

I have not uncovered any of the mirrors since.

But some mornings, when I pass the bathroom door, the air near it is warm.

And it smells like her shampoo.

And I leave it alone, because I think she is still finding her way, and I think she knows I am here, and I think that, for now, is enough.

book reviews

About the Creator

Noman Afridi

I’m Noman Afridi — welcome, all friends! I write horror & thought-provoking stories: mysteries of the unseen, real reflections, and emotional truths. With sincerity in every word. InshaAllah.

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Noman Afridi