Horror logo
Content warning
This story may contain sensitive material or discuss topics that some readers may find distressing. Reader discretion is advised. The views and opinions expressed in this story are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Vocal.

The Boy from Bogger Hollow

The Feeding

By Rachel FosterPublished 4 months ago • 3 min read

The Boy from Bogger Hollow

When eleven-year-old Eli Foster arrived in Bogger Hollow, Arkansas, nobody knew where he came from. No information let of his birth either.

The county records listed him as a foster child transferred from another state. No surviving family. No history worth mentioning.

Mr. and Mrs. Holloway took him in.

At first, Eli seemed like any other quiet child.

Then strange things began happening.

Livestock disappeared during the night.

Dogs refused to enter the woods.

Children claimed they heard whispers beneath their bedroom floors.

And every morning, Eli returned from the forest covered in mud.

The woods behind Bogger Hollow were feared by everyone.

Deep within the trees was a place known only as The Pit.

Older generations spoke of tunnels beneath the earth stretching for miles.

Some claimed entire families once lived underground.

Others believed something far older waited there.

Nobody entered.

Nobody explored.

Nobody returned the same.

Except Eli.

Every afternoon he walked into the woods alone.

No flashlight.

No weapon.

No fear.

One evening, Sheriff Boone followed him.

The old sheriff watched from a distance as the boy disappeared into the trees.

What he discovered changed Bogger Hollow forever.

The pit was real.

Beneath tangled roots and rotting earth was a massive opening leading deep underground.

Torches flickered below.

Voices echoed through the darkness.

And standing at the center of it all was Eli.

Dozens of pale figures surrounded him.

Their eyes reflected the firelight.

Not human.

Not animal.

Something in between.

The creatures knelt as the boy approached.

As if they were waiting for him.

As if he belonged to them.

Then Eli looked upward.

Straight at the sheriff.

And smiled.

“You’re not supposed to be here,” he said.

The creatures began climbing toward the surface.

Toward Bogger Hollow.

The sheriff’s hands trembled as the creatures emerged from the darkness.

Their pale eyes reflected the torchlight as they climbed toward the surface.

For a moment, Sheriff Boone believed he was about to die.

Then Eli stepped forward.

The boy raised his hand.

Return to the tunnels,” he commanded.

Immediately the creatures stopped.

One by one, they turned and descended back into the darkness below.

The whispers faded.

The torches flickered.

Silence returned to the woods.

Eli looked at the sheriff.

His face was calm.

Almost disappointed.

“You will never speak of this again,” Eli said.

The words felt less like a request and more like an order.

Sheriff Boone nodded.

Without another word, he left the forest.

He never told the townspeople what he had seen beneath Bogger Hollow.

Not his wife.

Not his deputies.

Not even the church.

Some secrets were meant to stay buried.

Deep below the earth, Eli climbed down into the tunnels once more.

The creatures gathered around him.

They listened as he taught them how to survive.

How to remain unseen.

How to exist without existing.

For hours they sat together beneath the roots of the forest while the town above slept peacefully.

By dawn, Eli returned to the Holloway foster home.

Mrs. Holloway noticed it immediately.

A strange smell clung to him.

The scent of wet earth.

Ancient wood.

Something old.

Something familiar.

Her husband smelled it too.

For a brief moment they exchanged nervous glances.

Neither spoke.

Neither asked questions.

It was easier that way.

Eli simply smiled and walked to his room.

As his bedroom door closed, something moved outside the window.

A shadow.

Watching.

Waiting.

The Holloways ignored the signs.

Ignored the smell.

Ignored the growing fear in their hearts.

But deep down they knew.

The boy sleeping beneath their roof belonged to something far older than Bogger Hollow.

And whatever had come from the tunnels had not come alone.

urban legendmonsterpsychologicalsupernatural

About the Creator

Rachel Foster

I am an independent author living with scleroderma.

My work is inspired by personal experience and focuses on resilience, healing, and imaginative storytelling.

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Rachel Foster