
PART VI
Harrison did not like the plan.
He said so in the small room behind the courtroom, the morning after the photo had failed, with the door closed and his voice low enough that no one outside could hear it.
"You are asking me to put a woman on the stand who cannot identify him," he said, "and ask her to say she can."
"I am asking you to win," Melissa said.
She was calm. That surprised her, how calm she was. In the cell, the plan had felt wild, desperate, like something she had dreamed up in the dark because she had nothing else. In the daylight, it felt simple. It felt like the only thing that made sense.
"Rebecca is falling apart," Harrison said. "Her marriage is falling apart. She is scared to go outside. If we put her on that stand and she lies, and Porter breaks her on cross — and he will try — she will break in front of a jury, and we will lose everything."
"Then we tell her exactly what to say," Melissa said. "That she knows for a fact it was Daniel. That she saw him. That she is certain."
"How?" Harrison asked. "She never saw his face. Porter will ask her that in the first minute, and she will have nothing to say."
"She will have something," Melissa said. "Daniel has a stopwatch. He always wears it, as a nurse. He never takes it off. Rebecca never saw it — she never saw anything but an arm — but if she says she saw the stopwatch on the arm that grabbed her, on his wrist, they will believe her. Porter cannot prove she did not see it, because Daniel does wear it, every day."
"That is still not seeing him," Harrison said.
"Then she will say she did see him," Melissa said. "Not straight on. A quick glimpse, in the reflection of the car window, as he came around her from behind. Just for a second, just enough to see his face. She is going to straight up claim she saw Daniel."
Harrison closed his eyes.
"That is perjury," he said.
"I know," Melissa said.
He looked at her for a long time. Then he opened his folder, and he took out Rebecca's statement, and he read it again, as if the words might have changed since the last time he had read them.
"One day," he said, very quietly, "he will blow up. You are counting on that. But if he does not — if he stays calm, if he lets her lie sit there — then Rebecca has lied for nothing, and Daniel walks out of here as the victim."
"He will blow up," Melissa said. "I know him. He cannot stand someone else getting the credit for his work. He cannot stand it."
Harrison did not say yes. He did not say no. He just stood up, and he put his folder under his arm, and he said, "I will talk to Rebecca."
---
Harrison went to Rebecca's house that afternoon, and he did not come back for three hours.
When he did, he sat down across from Melissa in the small room behind the courtroom, and he did not open his folder. He just looked at her.
"She said no," he said. "Three times. She said no, and she meant it."
He told Melissa how it had gone. Rebecca had opened the door with her husband standing behind her, and she had cried before Harrison had even finished explaining what Melissa was asking. She did not remember a face. She had never seen a face. She was afraid of Daniel, and she was afraid of lying, and she was afraid of being caught, and she was afraid of what would happen to her husband and her marriage if the jury did not believe her.
"I told her she could still say no," Harrison said. "I told her I was not going to make her do it. I told her, plainly, that perjury is a crime, that she could go to prison for lying under oath, that Porter would try to break her on cross, and that if she broke, we would lose everything — and she would lose with us."
"Then why did she say yes?" Melissa asked.
"Because I told her the other side of it," Harrison said. "I told her Daniel chose her. I told her he watched her, the way he watched Hannah, and that the arm that grabbed her was his, even if she never saw his face. I told her that if she did nothing, Daniel would walk out of that courtroom as the victim, and Melissa would take the blame, and he would be free to do it again. I told her she was not the only one who was afraid to go outside — there were five other women who never got to go home at all. And then I told her the one thing she could not argue with: Melissa saved your life. Melissa is the one who got you out, who drove you to the precinct with Daniel locked in the back, who turned him in. If Melissa had not done that, Rebecca you would be dead. Now Rebecca you have the chance to save Melissa's life, the way Melissa saved yours."
Rebecca had asked him, crying, what would happen if Daniel did not blow up. What if he stayed calm, and let her lie sit there? Harrison had not lied to her. He had told her that was the risk. He had told her the lie would still be hers, and she would still have to live with it, even if it worked.
She had asked for time. She had gone into the kitchen with her husband, and Harrison had sat in the living room, alone, for twenty minutes, listening to them argue in low voices through the wall. Her husband had said no. He did not want his wife going to prison for a woman she barely knew.
And then Rebecca had come back out, by herself, with her eyes red, and she had said, "I will do it. But I want you to tell Melissa — I am not doing this for her. I am doing this because I know it was him. I felt his arm. I know it was him. And I am tired of being afraid to go outside. And she saved my life. Now I have the chance to save hers."
Harrison had told her she could still back out, right up until she was under oath. She had nodded. She had said she understood. She had said she would be there in the morning.
"I do not know if she will hold," Harrison said. "Porter will come at her hard. She is terrified. But she did not just agree, Melissa. She fought me on it for three hours. She said no three times, and she only said yes when she was sure she could live with it — and even then, she was not sure."
Melissa did not ask him anything else. She just nodded, and she thought about the scratching, faint behind the wall in her cell that morning, so faint she had almost missed it. A pipe. A mouse. Nothing.
Not yet.
---
The next day, Rebecca took the stand.
She looked smaller in the courtroom than she had looked on her couch. Her husband sat in the gallery, his hands clasped so tightly his knuckles were white. She kept her eyes on Harrison, not on Daniel, not on the jury, not on Melissa.
Harrison asked her, gently, what she remembered about the parking lot.
"I remember an arm," Rebecca said. Her voice shook. "It came around me from behind. It was strong. It was a man's arm."
"And then?" Harrison asked.
"And then everything went dark," she said. "I woke up in the back of a car."
"Do you know who that arm belonged to?" Harrison asked.
There was a pause. A long one. The courtroom was so quiet Melissa could hear the air conditioning hum.
"Yes," Rebecca said. "I know for a fact it was Daniel Vance. I saw him."
Harrison leaned forward, very gently. "You saw him? How?"
"I caught a glimpse of him," Rebecca said. "In the reflection of the car window, as he came around me from behind. Just for a second. Just a quick glimpse. But I saw his face. I know it was him."
Melissa felt her own breath catch. She had known Rebecca was going to say it. She had planned it. She had wanted it. And still, hearing it out loud, in a courtroom, under oath, felt different from planning it in a cell. It felt like a line being crossed, and once it was crossed, there was no going back.
Porter stood up for cross-examination. He was polite, at first. He asked her how long it had been dark. How long she had been unconscious. Whether she had seen a face, even for a second.
"No," Rebecca said. "I did not see his face straight on, in the parking lot."
"Then how do you know for a fact it was Daniel Vance?" Porter asked. "You just told this jury you saw him."
"I saw him in the reflection," Rebecca said. "In the car window. A quick glimpse, as he came around me. I saw his face in the glass, just for a second, before everything went dark."
"And the stopwatch?" Porter asked, his voice sharp now. "You said you saw a stopwatch."
"On his wrist," Rebecca said. "On the arm that grabbed me. I remember the way it caught the light, and I remember his face in the reflection, right beside it."
Rebecca looked down at her hands. They were shaking. She looked at Harrison. She looked at Melissa. And then she looked at Daniel, for the first time, and her voice, when it came back, was steadier than it had been all morning.
"Because I know," she said. "I know it was him. I felt his arm. I saw his face in the reflection, and I saw his stopwatch on his wrist."
When she stepped down from the stand, her husband met her in the aisle, and she leaned into him, and she was crying, quietly, into his shoulder. Melissa watched her go, and she felt something cold settle in her stomach, the same cold she had felt watching Daniel on the television, calm and believed.
Rebecca had lied. She had lied for Melissa. And Melissa had asked her to.
She told herself it was necessary. She told herself Daniel would blow up, and then the lie would not matter, because the truth would be out in the open.
She told herself that, and she almost believed it.
---
Melissa took the stand the next day.
She sat in the witness box, calm, certain, and she looked at the jury, and she told them she had planned it all.
The vials. The notes. The parking lot. Rebecca. All of it. She had come up with the idea, chosen the women, told Daniel what to do and when to do it, written the surveillance notes tracking Rebecca Lawson, stolen the sedatives from the nursing home herself, and driven them to the parking lot that night.
She said it calmly. She said it clearly. She said it like a woman who was proud of how clever she had been.
And then she got the details wrong. On purpose. The way she and Harrison had planned it.
She said she had hidden the photographs in a box under the bed — not in the hidden compartment behind the panel, where Daniel had kept them. She said she had chosen Hannah Whitmore because she had seen her at the nursing home, visiting her grandmother — not because Daniel had watched her for weeks. She said she had drugged Rebecca with a pill in her drink — not with a needle, in the parking lot, the way Daniel had done it.
Each wrong detail was small. Each one was the kind of mistake a person might make if they were telling a story they had only heard secondhand.
She watched Daniel as she spoke. At first, he did not move. Then she said the photographs had been her idea, and his jaw tightened. Then she said the necklace had been hers all along, and his fingers curled against the table. Then she said she had decided Rebecca would be next, because Rebecca was easy, because Rebecca was alone — and Daniel's head came up.
He was looking at her now. His face was still calm, but his eyes were not. His eyes were furious.
She kept going. She told the jury she had been the mastermind, that Daniel had only done what she told him to do, that he had been too weak, too afraid, too ordinary to come up with any of it himself.
"Objection," Porter said, standing up, his voice sharp for the first time. "Your Honour, my client —"
But Daniel was already standing too.
His chair scraped back against the floor, loud in the quiet courtroom, and his calm was gone. All of it. The brave victim, the exhausted nurse, the man who had been afraid of his wife — all of it fell away at once.
"That is not how it happened!" he shouted.
The courtroom went completely still.
"She did not plan any of it!" Daniel said, his voice rising, his hands shaking — not from fear, but from rage. "I planned it! I chose them! I watched Hannah for weeks before I took her necklace! I took the photographs! I kept them in the compartment behind the panel, because I wanted to remember them, because they were mine!"
Porter was pulling at his arm, telling him to sit down, but Daniel shook him off.
"She did not drug Rebecca with a pill! I did it with a needle, in the parking lot, the way I always did it! I signed out at 7:42 because I wanted to be there before the store closed, and I swapped my shift with Patel so no one would notice I was gone!"
He was shouting now, and the jury was staring at him.
"She did not do any of it!" Daniel said. "It was me! It was all me! I am the one who did it, and she is trying to take it from me, and I will not let her!"
Melissa sat in the witness box, her hands folded in her lap, and she did not move. She looked at the jury, and she let them see what she had known all along: that he could not stand the idea of someone else getting the credit for his work.
The judge called a recess. Daniel was led out, still shouting, still trying to take it back. Porter followed him, his face white.
As the guard led her back down the corridor, she heard it again, very faint, under the sound of her own footsteps. Scratching. Behind the wall. Small, patient, deliberate.
She did not stop. She told herself it was a pipe. It was still minor. It was still nothing. Not yet.
---
Daniel was convicted. Melissa was acquitted.
That was how the newspapers put it, in the days after. That was how the television put it, in the corridor outside the courtroom, where Melissa's name had once been under a headline about missing women, and now it was under a headline about a survivor.
She moved into a new apartment. A small one, on the third floor. She bought new sheets, a kettle, a plant, and she kept it alive, which surprised her.
Rebecca came to see Melissa one last time, three weeks after the trial. She looked thinner. Her marriage was worse, not better. She was still scared to go outside.
"I keep hearing it," Rebecca said, sitting on Melissa's new couch, her hands wrapped around a mug of tea she did not drink. "The scratching. I hear it at night. I hear it in the walls. And I keep thinking about what I said in court. I keep thinking about how I lied, and how I can never take it back, and how guilty I feel, and how afraid I am that someone will find out."
"I am sorry," Rebecca said. "I just wanted it to be over."
"It is over," Melissa said. "It is over now."
Rebecca left, and Melissa told herself that Rebecca would be all right.
Shortly after that, Rebecca got in a car accident.
Melissa heard about it from Harrison, on the phone, two days later. Rebecca had been driving, distracted, in so much distress she had not been watching the road. She had survived, but she was in the hospital, and she was not doing well.
Melissa hung up the phone. She sat on her new couch, in her new apartment, and she listened to the silence. The buzz of the refrigerator. The drip of the faucet. The faint scratch of something, somewhere behind the wall.
She told herself it was a pipe.
---
That night, Melissa lay in bed, in her new apartment, in her new life, and she breathed a sigh of relief.
She had made it out. She had gotten away with it. Daniel was the one who had taken the full blame. Daniel was the one in prison. She was free. She was alive.
And deep inside, in a place she had never said out loud, not to Harrison, not to Miller, not to anyone, she knew the truth she had been hiding all along.
She had honestly liked it.
She had liked the idea. She had liked being close to it. She had liked participating. She had not changed her mind until the very end, and even then, she had only changed it enough to save herself.
She smiled to herself, in the dark, a small, secret smirk, because she had liked it, and she had gotten away with it, and no one knew. No one would ever know.
She closed her eyes.
And she heard it. Loud. Certain. Sure. In the back of her mind.
SCRATCH!
About the Creator
K-jay
I weave stories from social media,and life, blending critique, fiction, and horror. Inspired by Hamlet, George R.R. Martin, and Stephen King, I craft poetic, layered tales of intrigue and resilience,
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.